Structural Engineering & Statics
where the load goes
Concept

Creep — where it appears

The strain a material accrues under a constant stress, which for concrete roughly trebles a sustained deflection over a structure's life. It is an imposed deformation rather than a load, so in a restrained member it relaxes force away and in an unrestrained one it multiplies a deflection.

Named by 27 essays across 5 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

The deflection that arrives years late. The multiplier on a concrete member's deflection under a sustained load, against time. The elastic deflection arrives on the day the load does and is the 1.0 at the left. After a year it has been multiplied by 3.00, after five years by 3.29, and it approaches 3.38. Nothing has been added to the load and nothing about the strength has changed: this is a serviceability failure arriving on a structure that passed every strength check on the day it was built.

The deflection that arrives three years late

A concrete beam that passes every check on the day it is built goes on deflecting for a decade, and ends up three times where it started. Nothing about the load changed, and nothing about the strength was ever in question.

materials · Creep The stress that leaks away. A restrained shrinkage strain of 300 microstrain in concrete of modulus 32000 N/mm². Ignoring creep it produces 9.60 N/mm², which is above the tensile strength of 3.5 and predicts that every restrained concrete member ever cast has cracked. Counting creep by the superposition integral leaves 2.32 N/mm² after 27 years, and the one-line age-adjusted shortcut at the usually quoted ageing coefficient of 0.8 leaves 3.31. The two disagree — this creep function implies an ageing coefficient of 1.32, not 0.8 — and both are below the tensile strength, so the conclusion turns on counting creep at all rather than on how it is counted.

The strain that was imposed, and the stress that leaked away

Multiply a restrained shrinkage strain by the modulus and the answer is three times the tensile strength — which predicts that every restrained concrete member ever cast has cracked. Most have not, and the reason is that the material creeps while it is being stressed.

materials · Relaxation The hour that is really a temperature. The retention factors for carbon steel against temperature: the yield stress and the elastic modulus. The modulus falls away first — at 500°C the steel has kept 78% of its strength and 60% of its stiffness — so a member's failure mode can change during a fire. A member working at 60% of its cold capacity runs out of strength at 558°C, and out of the stiffness for the same ratio at 500°C, 58 degrees earlier. There is nothing about time in any of it: a fire rating is a temperature the member must not reach, converted into the minutes a particular fire takes to get it there.

The hour that is really a temperature

A fire rating is quoted in minutes and there is no time in the physics anywhere. What decides is a temperature, and the stiffness reaches its limit sixty degrees before the strength does — so the way a member fails can change while it is burning.

materials · Fire The props decide where the stress ends up. Bottom-fibre stress in the steel of a 12 m composite beam carrying 12 kN/m of wet concrete and 18 kN/m afterwards. Unpropped, the bare steel takes the first stage alone and reaches 292 MPa; propped, the finished composite section takes everything and reaches 186 MPa — a ratio of 1.57. 62% of the unpropped beam's final stress was locked in before the slab was structural at all. The deflections differ by 1.73 times for the same reason, and no drawing of the finished beam distinguishes the two.

The structure that was never complete

Every analysis in this collection is of a finished structure loaded once. Real ones are built in pieces, and each piece carries whatever was present at the moment it became structural — so the stress in a member depends on when it arrived, which appears nowhere on any drawing.

structures · Construction sequence The depth is decided by how far it moves, not by what it can carry. A column carrying 6000 kN landing 3 m into a 12 m transfer member. The free body is the member itself, cut under the column: M = P·a(L − a)/L = 13500 kNm, with 4500 kN of shear on one side of the cut and 1500 on the other. At an allowable stress that moment asks for 1.94 m of depth — the dashed outline — and keeping the settlement it causes inside the floors' own bending asks for 2.55 m, which is the member drawn solid. 31% more depth is bought by nothing the strength calculation can see. The depth grows as √(P·a), so four times the load is exactly twice the depth, and depth in a transfer member is a storey nobody occupies.

The column that stops

A load path that runs straight to the ground costs almost nothing. Interrupting one costs depth in proportion to the square root of the load times the distance it is moved — and the interruption's own deflection becomes the settlement of everything standing on it.

structures · Transfer structure Four camber rules, and what each leaves on the finished beam. The same 12 m composite beam, cambered against four different things, followed through its own load history. Positive is a sag and negative a hog, and the point at the left of each line is the shape it was fabricated to. Cambering against the wet concrete leaves 12.7 mm of sag at the end and a flat beam on the day the slab is poured; cambering against the total load leaves the beam dead flat when fully loaded and hogged 37.9 mm — one part in 316 of the span — before anything is on it at all.

Built to the wrong shape on purpose

A cambered beam is fabricated curved upward so that load bends it down to something like straight. Nothing in the analysis changes, no stress anywhere is altered, and almost every mistake made with it is a bookkeeping mistake about which loads count.

deflection · Camber The same strain, two moduli, and a width multiplied to say so. A timber section with a steel plate in it, carrying 20.0 kNm. Plane sections stay plane, so the strain at a height is the same in both materials; Hooke's law then puts the stresses in the ratio of the moduli, which here is 19.09. Multiplying the stiffer material's WIDTH by that ratio gives a fictitious section of one material with the same neutral axis and the same forces — 595.2×10⁶ mm⁴ of it, against 351.0 for the same shape with the moduli ignored. The steel plate is 3.8% of the area and carries 43% of the moment, at 96 N/mm² against the timber's 5.0. The transform is not an approximation: it is compatibility and Hooke's law written down.

A section made of two materials, one of them pretended away

Multiplying a material's width by the ratio of the moduli produces a fictitious section of one material with the right neutral axis and the right forces. It is not a trick — it is compatibility and Hooke's law written down — and it says a stiff material takes what its modulus asks for.

sections · Transformed section Two differences up the same building, peaking in different places. Differential shortening between a perimeter column and the core of a 40-storey building, plotted up the height. The part driven by load peaks at level 20 — exactly half way up, because a floor near the top has almost nothing built above it to shorten what is beneath, and a floor near the bottom has almost nothing beneath it to shorten. The part driven by shrinkage does not care what is above it at all and accumulates all the way to the roof. Their sum is worst at level 40, at 43 mm, which across a 9 m bay is a floor out of level by one in 208.

The columns are shorter than the core

Every column in a tall building gets shorter as the building is built on top of it, and the core beside it gets shorter by a different amount. The floors between them tilt by the difference — and the difference is largest exactly half way up, because a floor near the top has almost nothing built above it and a floor near the bottom has almost nothing beneath it.

deflection · Differential shortening Four inequalities, and the wedge between them. The Magnel diagram: every limit on a prestressed section, plotted as a bound on 1/P against the eccentricity. Two of the four come from transfer, when the force is largest and the only moment is the beam's own weight, and two from service, when 20% of the force has been lost and the moment is 640 kNm. Each is linear in 1/P, which is the substitution that makes the problem a picture rather than a search. The shaded region is every force-and-eccentricity pair the section will accept: it is a wedge opening to the right, so the cheapest prestress is always at the largest eccentricity the cover allows — 1029 kN at e = 400 mm here. The section's kern is 241 mm, and every useful answer is outside it.

Four inequalities and a wedge

A prestressed section has to satisfy two stress limits when the force is largest and the load smallest, and two more when the force has relaxed and the load has arrived. Each is linear in one over the force — which turns a search for a prestress into a region on a page, and turns an impossible section into an empty one.

sections · Prestress limits The deflection goes on growing, and sometimes it does not stop. Second-order deflection of a sustained-loaded concrete column against age, on a log time axis. Creep takes the effective modulus down, which takes the buckling load down with it — from 11580 kN on the day to 3309 in the long term, 29 per cent of it — so the amplifier 1/(1 − N/N_cr) grows even though nothing was added to the load. At 2200 kN the column settles: 25 mm of eccentricity on the day and 60 mm at the end, a factor of 2.4 for a load that never changed. At 5294 kN — still only 46 per cent of the day-one critical load — it does not settle, and the divergence arrives at 55 days for no new reason at all.

The column that fails years later

A concrete column under sustained load goes on straining at constant stress, so its deflection grows — and because the second-order moment is the load times that deflection, the demand grows with it. There is a load below which the two settle and one above which they never do.

stability · Creep buckling The beam is stiffer than its cracked section and softer than its gross one. Moment against mid-span deflection for a 300 × 550 mm beam spanning 8.0 m, with the two bounds it lies between. The uncracked line is what the gross transformed section gives; the cracked line is what the section at a crack gives; and the curve between them is the member, because between the cracks the concrete is still carrying tension and the average curvature is not either section's. At the service load the deflection is 23.2 mm — span over 345 — against 8.3 uncracked and 25.2 fully cracked, a factor of 3.03 between the bounds. The interpolation ζ = 1 − β(M_cr/M)² sits it 88 per cent of the way across, and β falls from one to a half under sustained or repeated load because the bond that does the dragging deteriorates.

Stiffer than its cracked section says

At a crack the concrete below the neutral axis has gone and the steel carries the tension alone. Between the cracks it has not gone — bond drags it back into tension, the steel strain drops, and the curvature averaged over a length of beam is neither section's.

deflection · Tension stiffening The props decide where the stress ends up. Bottom-fibre stress in the steel of a 12 m composite beam carrying 6 kN/m of wet concrete and 9 kN/m afterwards. Unpropped, the bare steel takes the first stage alone and reaches 146 MPa; propped, the finished composite section takes everything and reaches 93 MPa — a ratio of 1.57. 62% of the unpropped beam's final stress was locked in before the slab was structural at all. The deflections differ by 1.73 times for the same reason, and no drawing of the finished beam distinguishes the two.

The section that changed while it was being loaded

A stress is computed from a moment and a section modulus. When part of the moment arrived while the section was a different shape, there is no single section modulus to divide by — the stresses add and the properties do not, and two identical finished beams can differ by half again in stress with nothing on the drawing to say which is which.

sections · Staged section The least reliable number in the material decides the answer, briefly. What a twenty per cent error in the concrete's tensile strength does to a computed deflection, against how far past cracking the beam is. Well past the cracking moment it does almost nothing — at 1.9 times M_cr the spread is 56 per cent — because the section is nearly fully cracked and the interpolation has run out. Just above cracking it does everything: at 1.19 times M_cr the same twenty per cent moves the deflection by 3658 per cent. Tensile strength is the property with the widest scatter and the least direct test, and a beam designed to sit near its cracking moment has put the answer on it.

The curvature nobody applied

Concrete shrinks as it dries, by about half a millimetre in every metre. In a symmetrically reinforced member that is a shortening and nothing else. In a member with more steel in one face than the other — which is every beam and every slab — the steel holds one side back and the section bends, with no load on it at all.

deflection · Shrinkage curvature The gap is a sum of five things and only one of them is computed. What a 30 mm movement joint is asked to accommodate, by three combination rules. The top bar is every term at its extreme, added: 33.2 mm, which assumes the hottest day, the fullest floor, the whole of the shrinkage and the worst-placed wall arrive together. The chance of that is about 1.5%. The bottom bar treats them as independent and asks for 16.0 mm. The middle bar is the rule used for actions and almost never for movements — one term at its full value and the rest at their coincidence factors — and gives 25.5 mm. The segments across the top bar are the terms themselves, and the ordering is the finding: the largest is tolerance at 10.0 mm, which is not a structural quantity at all, and the smallest is deflection at 3.2 mm — the only one anybody computes carefully, and 10% of the total.

The gap nobody computed

A movement joint is sized by adding up everything the structure will do to it, and the deflection calculation — the only term anybody computes carefully — is usually the smallest one in the list. The largest is a construction tolerance, which is not a structural quantity at all, and the sum of the extremes is nearly twice what treating them as independent would ask for.

deflection · Movement budget Ten decades of time for forty per cent of the strength. Strength as a fraction of the five-minute test value, against the length of time the load is held, over 12 decades of seconds. The relation is a straight line on this axis, which is the reason a single duration factor works at all: every decade of time costs about the same amount of strength. A load held for 60 years leaves 59% of the short-term strength, and the member need not have moved — this is not creep, and it is not fatigue, because nothing about the load varies. It is that a static stress slowly breaks fibres. The curve has an asymptote at 18% that nobody quotes: below about a fifth of its short-term strength a member has no time to failure at all, so there is a stress under which duration stops being a question rather than merely becoming a small one.

The load that was left on too long

A timber beam that carries a load for fifty years fails at about fifty-nine per cent of the stress the same beam carries for five minutes in a testing machine. Nothing about the load varies, the member need not have deflected, and the relation between the two is a straight line on a logarithmic time axis over ten decades.

materials · Duration of load The check that depends on a date. Total deflection and the deflection occurring after the brittle finishes are built, for one 12 m beam, against the day those finishes go up. The total barely moves — the beam ends up where it ends up. The increment falls from 32 mm at a week to 14 mm at a year, because creep is fast at first and slow later and a partition built early inherits nearly all of it: 44% of the final creep has already happened by day 28. The span/500 limit is 24 mm and the span/250 limit is 48; this beam passes the first only after day 25. Camber subtracts from both terms of the difference and therefore changes the upper curve and not the lower one, which is the reason a cambered beam can satisfy every total-deflection check and still crack the wall.

The limit that depends on a date

Total deflection can nearly always be met, and on a long span it is met with camber. The limit that actually decides the member is the other one — the deflection occurring after the brittle finishes are built — and camber does nothing for it whatever, because it is subtracted from both terms of a difference. The same beam passes or fails on the day the partitions went up.

deflection · Incremental deflection A tenth of a per cent of the thrust is all of the moment. The thrust a two-hinged arch loses to its own axial shortening, against rise-to-span. The flexibility equation's denominator has two terms — ∫y²ds/EI for bending and ∫cos²θ ds/EA for shortening — and their ratio is about (15/8)(i/f)², the square of the radius of gyration over the RISE. At the 10 per cent rise drawn that is 0.10 per cent of the thrust, which sounds like a rounding error and is not: a parabolic arch under a uniform load is funicular, so the rigid solution has NO crown moment at all, and the 0.10 per cent that the rib shortening removes from the thrust leaves 28 kNm behind. The correction that is a tenth of a per cent of the thrust is a hundred per cent of the bending. At a two per cent rise the loss is 2.6 per cent, because a shallow arch's thrust is enormous and its lever arm is not.

The arch that gets shorter

A parabolic arch under a uniform load is funicular, so the perfect solution gives it no bending at all. Then the rib shortens under its own thrust by a tenth of a per cent, and every kilonewton-metre of moment the arch will ever carry comes from that.

deflection · Rib shortening Seventy per cent of the strength and ninety of the stiffness. Strength and modulus against age, each as a fraction of its own twenty-eight-day value. They do not move together: E follows f to the power 0.3, so at seven days the concrete has 78 per cent of its strength and 93 per cent of its stiffness, and at three days 60 and 86. A young structure is much nearer its final deflection than its final capacity. The 20 N/mm² a striking calculation asks for arrives at 2.2 days at 20 °C, 4.6 at five degrees and 1.7 at thirty-five.

The strength it had on the day

Every concrete strength on this site is a twenty-eight-day cylinder value, and a structure is loaded long before that — formwork struck at three days, the next storey cast at seven, a prestressing force transferred at two. The number that existed at the moment the load arrived is a different one.

materials · Maturity

Counted, not checked

A column with pinned ends and no bracing cannot buckle on its own, so nothing about it fails a stability check. It still carries load, and load with no stiffness attached lowers the buckling load of everything around it — which is why a gravity-only column is put on the frame model and never designed by itself.

stability · Second-order

The stress that leaks away

Creep makes a load's deflection grow and an imposed strain's stress shrink, and the second is why restrained concrete does not crack as often as an elastic calculation says. The same material property runs both ways, and which way it runs depends on whether the structure was given a force or a movement.

materials · Creep

The creep that belongs to the member

A creep coefficient is quoted for a concrete, and half of it is not a property of the concrete. It is the member drying out, and drying goes through the surface — so one mix creeps a quarter more in a thin slab than in a deep beam, gets there years sooner, and in saturated air forgets its size altogether.

materials · Creep

The slab that dries from one face

A creep coefficient is one number for a member, and a member drying through one face does not have one. Give every depth its own humidity and the section a strain profile it cannot deliver, and two things follow that no single coefficient contains — a six-metre slab lifts eleven millimetres at its edges with nothing on it, and its top surface is past cracking before it has been loaded.

materials · Creep

The support that had no moment when it was cast

Two beams are set on their bearings, carry their own weight for a month, and are then stitched together over the middle support. Nothing about the loading changes afterwards. Twenty years later the stitch is carrying 155 kilonewton-metres, because the concrete went on creeping and the joint would not let it — and how much arrives is decided by a crane schedule.

materials · Creep

The prestress the member takes back

A tendon is stretched, locked off against the concrete, and then has to hold that extension while the concrete underneath it shortens by itself. Fifteen per cent of the force goes, most of it to creep, and how much goes is decided by the shape of the member and the air it stands in rather than by anything about the steel.

materials · Creep

The slab that shrinks onto a finished beam

A precast beam with an in-situ slab cast on it is one member made of two concretes, and they do not age together. The slab's shrinkage is nearly the same whenever it is poured; what changes is how much shrinking the beam has left to share it with. Cast the slab at six weeks and it takes a ninth of the soffit's precompression away over thirty years. Cast it at a year and it takes a quarter, and goes into tension itself.

materials · Creep

The angle made in the casting yard

A bridge bearing is designed for the rotation of the beam it carries, and the rotation is listed as a sum of load, temperature, creep and a tolerance. Followed through the life of a pretensioned beam, the largest term is none of those. It is the upward turn the prestress gives the beam's ends in the casting yard, before any bearing exists, and under every load the beam will ever carry its ends still point up.

deflection · End rotation

The pier that bends the wrong way

Two precast beams are made continuous over a pier by a joint cast with the deck, and the joint is designed for the hogging moment a continuous beam has there. Thirty years later it is sagging, by more than the moment that cracks its underside, because the beams were still cambering upward when they were joined. Whether that happens is decided by two dates — when the beams were cast and when the joint was — and the deck's shrinkage, which pulls the other way, is not enough to stop it.

materials · Creep

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

ServiceabilityShrinkageImposed deformationComposite actionPrestressConstruction sequenceDeflectionEffective modulusSuperpositionAgeingCamberElastic modulus

All concepts