Structural Engineering & Statics
where the load goes
Theme

Geometry beats material

Moving the same steel further from the neutral axis, or making the truss deeper, buys more than making the steel stronger. Shape is the cheap variable.
tensioncompression2 carrying nothing Structural form

The triangle that cannot fold, and everything built out of it

A square of pinned bars is a mechanism. A triangle is not, and that single fact is the reason trusses exist and the reason they look the way they do.

 0.511.52050100150200250300depth of the truss2501671251007150the same moment, resisted by a longer lever arm Structural form

Depth is the cheapest strength there is

Doubling the depth of a truss halves its chord forces without adding a gram of material to the chords. Nothing else in structural design is that cheap, and almost every structure has already spent it.

 00.050.10.150.20.250.30.3501020304050overhang, as a fraction of the spanbest at 21% — peak 8.8sagging, mid-spanhogging, over the supportmoving the supports in by a third of the way halves the worst moment Internal forces

Where to put the supports, which is not at the ends

Moving the supports of a uniformly loaded beam inward by about a fifth of its length halves the worst bending moment. The load has not changed and nor has the beam.

 neutral axiscontribution of each striptotal I = 79.86 × 10⁶the outer strips do almost all of the work Sections and stress

The material far from the middle does nearly all the work

A strip of steel contributes to bending stiffness in proportion to the square of its distance from the centre. Move the same steel outward and the section gets stiffer for nothing.

 neutral axiscompressiontensionI = 29.97 × 10⁶Z = 299.7 × 10³peak stress 200.2σ = M y ÷ I, at every height Sections and stress

Bending is a pair of forces, pushing and pulling

A bending moment is not a mysterious twisting. It is a push near the top of a section and a pull near the bottom, separated by a lever arm — a couple, made out of stress.

 the same, laid flatI = 0.06 × 10⁶1.0× the firstsquareI = 0.75 × 10⁶13.3× the firsttall rectangleI = 10.00 × 10⁶177.8× the firstI-sectionI = 24.29 × 10⁶431.8× the firstevery section here has an area of 3000 — only the shape differsthe bar is the second moment of area, to scale Sections and stress

The same steel in a different shape, and a factor of forty

Four sections of identical area, identical weight and identical cost. The stiffest is dozens of times the stiffest of the flattest, and the only thing that changed was the arrangement.

 5010015020000.20.40.60.811.2slenderness (effective length ÷ radius of gyration)they cross at λ = 75squashingEuler bucklingreal columns, which are neither Stability

Strong enough and still falls over

A column can fail at a fraction of the load its material could carry, by going sideways. Buckling is a failure of stability rather than of strength, and it is decided by geometry.

 11.522.533.54050100150200250300span, relative to the first1×5×16×81×256×moment: the squareload: the first powerdeflection: the fourth Deflection

Span to the fourth, which is why spans are short

Doubling a span multiplies its deflection by sixteen. No other relationship in ordinary structural work is that steep, and it is the reason long spans are always a different kind of structure.

All themes