Structural Engineering & Statics
where the load goes
Depth

Series — page 3

A field says what an essay is about. A series follows one idea essay by essay — from the question that introduces it to the one that assumes all the others.
One of these two curves is a stiffness and the other is a statement of statics. The torque a spandrel beam carries, against how much of its torsional stiffness is left. The rising curve is compatibility torsion — a floor beam framing into the side of the spandrel, which shares its fixed-end moment of 197 kNm between the spandrel's torsional stiffness and its own flexural one. Uncracked, the spandrel takes 51% of it, or 100 kNm; at a quarter of that stiffness it takes 21%, or 41 kNm, and the floor beam picks up what was shed. The flat line is equilibrium torsion — a canopy cantilevering 2.2 m off the same spandrel, whose 116 kNm is fixed by statics and contains no stiffness at all. The first can be designed away by accepting a rotation. The second cannot be designed away by anything.

Compatibility torsion

  1. 1 The torsion that goes away if you let it
  2. 2 The torque that should not be shed
2 essays · internal-forces Two beams, or one beam four times as stiff. Two 200 × 150 planks spanning 4 m under 6 per millimetre. Loose, they have 112.5×10⁶ mm⁴ between them and deflect 16.2 mm, with the two faces at the interface sliding past one another. Bonded, the pair has 450.0×10⁶ — exactly 4 times as much, because doubling a depth cubes — and deflects 4.0 mm at half the extreme-fibre stress. Nothing was added but a restraint on slip. With connectors of stiffness 200 the same beam deflects 5.4 mm, which is 89% of the way from one bound to the other.

Composite action

  1. 1 Two beams, or one beam four times as stiff
  2. 2 The connection is busiest where the beam is not
2 essays · internal-forces A strength with no mechanism in it, made of four. The shear a member carries with no links in it, split into the mechanisms that carry it, against the member's effective depth on a logarithmic axis. The three bands are calibrated to Taylor's measured shares at one 300 mm × 500 mm member and are then evaluated everywhere else, so the shape of the total is a prediction. Aggregate interlock is the band that dies: it depends on how tightly the crack faces are held together, crack width grows with member depth, and it falls from 62% of a shallow member's strength to 22% of a deep one's. That decay is the whole of the size effect, and the dashed line is the design code's fitted k = 1 + √(200/d), which knows nothing about interlock and falls by a factor of 1.52 where the model falls by 2.05 over the same twentyfold range. Dowel action is why the expression contains the flexural reinforcement ratio, which nothing in a truss analogy would predict.

Concrete shear

  1. 1 The strength with no mechanism in it
  2. 2 The angle is a choice, not a property
2 essays · internal-forces The plan a straight beam does not have. A beam of radius 12 m turning through 60°, seen from above, with bending drawn outward from the axis in one colour and torsion in the other. The load is vertical and uniform and nothing is applied off the axis. Bending reaches 446 and torsion 155; the two peaks are in different places, which is why the section has to be chosen for a combination rather than for either.

Curved in plan

  1. 1 Bending that arrives as twist
  2. 2 The torque that has nowhere to go
2 essays · internal-forces The building does not care how far it went down; it cares how much it tilted. Five footings on soil that is 35% as stiff under one of them, carrying 60 kN/m. They settle between 12 and 54 mm, and the number that matters is neither of those: it is the angular distortion between neighbours, 4.32 per thousand, or one in 231 — against a limit of one in 500 for cracking in finishes, which this does not. A building that went down half a metre uniformly would be undamaged and would need a new front step; this one has moved a twentieth as far and has cracked.

Differential settlement

  1. 1 The settlement that matters is the difference
  2. 2 The crack is a strain, not a slope
2 essays · deflection The worst force in a pile is not at the top of it. A 0.6 m pile 24 m long through ground that is settling, carrying 800 kN at its head. Above the neutral plane the soil moves down past the shaft and the friction acts downward, so the axial force grows with depth; below it the friction acts upward in the ordinary way and the force falls again to the 300 kN the base takes. The maximum is 1282.87 kN at 13.78 m — 1.60 times the load applied, and it is at a depth where nothing is applied, nothing is connected and nothing can be inspected. A pile section chosen for the head load is under-sized by that factor over the middle third of its length.

Downdrag

  1. 1 The ground that hangs on instead of holding up
  2. 2 The coating that takes the resistance with it
2 essays · internal-forces Two materials pulled until they stop. Two stress-strain curves — mild steel, cast iron — plotted to a strain of 2.0%. One of them has a plateau, so the stress at which yielding starts is something the specimen does rather than something anyone chooses. No offset construction is drawn.

Ductility

  1. 1 The property that appears in none of the equations
  2. 2 Yielding one way, and then the other
2 essays · materials The ends decide the length that matters. Four columns of identical height and section, buckling under four sets of end conditions. The effective length factor is the fraction of the column that behaves like a pin-ended one, and the buckling load goes as its inverse square.

Effective length

  1. 1 The ends decide the length that matters
  2. 2 The brace that need not be strong
2 essays · stability The flange that is drawn, and the strip of it that is working. A plan of a flange 3 m each side of the web on a 20 m span, with the working strip shaded. The effective width is 2.531 m per side, 84.4% of what is drawn, so 101238 mm² of the 120000 mm² of flange is doing the work and 18762 mm² is not. Widening the flange does not move the shaded strip much, because its width is set by the span: the design code would allow 2.500 m per side here and no elastic flange of any width beats 3.183 m, which is L/2π. The lag exists because longitudinal stress can only enter the flange through shear along the junction with the web, so the free edges arrive late — 76.5% of the web's stress at the edge, in this case.

Effective width

  1. 1 The flange that is not all there
  2. 2 The flange works least where the shear is largest
2 essays · sections One coefficient, and nothing else in it. The deflected shapes of one beam under four load cases, each scaled so that its mid-span deflection is the same, with the tangent at the left-hand support drawn on each. The end rotation is that deflection times a coefficient that depends only on the shape of the load: 3.20 for a uniform load, 3.00 for a load at mid-span, 2.99 for a triangular load, 3.60 for a load on half the span. Every material property, every second moment and the span itself cancel out of the ratio θL/δ, so a beam at any deflection limit has an end rotation that is known before anything about it is: at L/360 it is 8.89 milliradians, or 0.51 of a degree.

End rotation

  1. 1 The angle nobody limits
  2. 2 The angle made in the casting yard
2 essays · deflection A beam, its loads and its reactions. A free body: the beam cut away from everything it touches, with the forces that were doing the touching drawn on it. The reactions are computed from the loads, so their arrows are to scale relative to each other.

Equilibrium

  1. 1 Everything adds to nothing, and that is the whole of statics
  2. 2 The equation that is not new, and the three that are
2 essays · equilibrium A cruciform has three critical loads, not one. The three critical loads of a cruciform in compression, against its length, with the load it actually buckles at drawn over them. At 3000 mm the flexural loads are 921 kN about the major axis and 921 kN about the minor, while twisting about the shear centre takes 700 kN. The lowest root is 700 kN, and the column twists. The shear centre is the centroid, so the three modes are independent and the envelope is simply the lowest of them. The governing mode changes at 3442 mm: below that length the column twists, above it, it bends — because the torsional resistance keeps a term that does not grow when the member is shortened, and the flexural loads have none.

Flexural-torsional

  1. 1 The column that twists instead of bending
  2. 2 The third root of the cubic
2 essays · stability Which floor frequencies a 2 Hz pace punishes. The response factor of a floor of 12 tonnes modal mass and 3.0% damping, against its own natural frequency, under a walker at 2 steps per second. The peaks are at 2, 4, 6, 8 Hz — the harmonics of the pace — and they fall away sharply: four peaks, each smaller than the one below it, because the harmonics of walking get smaller. A floor at 2 Hz reaches R = 31 and one at 8 Hz reaches 6. Between them the floor is quiet.

Floor vibration

  1. 1 The floor that is strong and unusable
  2. 2 The crowd that is also the structure
2 essays · dynamics A general force system is a screw, not a force. Two forces that are neither parallel, nor concurrent, nor coplanar. Their resultant is (30, 0, -60) and no point in space reduces them to it alone: the moment left on the central axis is (14.40, 0.00, -28.80), which is parallel to the resultant and has a pitch of 0.4800. The simplest object equivalent to the system is therefore a force and a couple about the same line — a wrench — and a planar drawing can never produce one, because a coplanar system has its moment perpendicular to its resultant by construction.

Force couple

  1. 1 Moving a force, and what it costs
  2. 2 Equivalent in work, not in resultant
2 essays · equilibrium The cable and the arch are the same curve. The shape a cable takes under a uniform load is a parabola, and it carries that load in pure tension. Reflected, the identical curve carries the same load in pure compression, which is what an arch is.

Funicular

  1. 1 The shape that carries itself, and the arch that is its reflection
  2. 2 The polygon that finds the shape
2 essays · structures The ductility number depends on the ruler. Elongation after fracture against the gauge length it was measured over, in units of √S₀. A tensile specimen extends uniformly until the ultimate load and then localises into a neck, so the total is a strain (16 per cent here) plus a length (7.2 mm), and dividing a length by the gauge length is what makes the curve fall. At the two standard gauges the same steel reports 27.5 per cent over 5.65√S₀ and 21.8 over 11.3√S₀ — a ratio of 1.264, and 42 per cent of the first number is a property of the specimen rather than of the material.

Gauge length

  1. 1 The ductility that depends on the ruler
  2. 2 The curve was rising the whole time
2 essays · materials Where the peak moment goes when a restraint is added. The same uniformly loaded beam with three sets of restraints, and the bending moment in each. Adding restraint moves moment from mid-span to the supports and lowers the peak — but only the first case can be solved by statics.

Indeterminacy

  1. 1 One support too many, and what it costs to know
  2. 2 The support that moved
2 essays · deflection Influence line for the bending moment at x = 3. The bending moment at one fixed station, plotted against the position of a unit load walking across the span. The beam was re-solved at 301 load positions. The worst position is x = 3.00, giving 2.100.

Influence line

  1. 1 The worst place to stand
  2. 2 The train that is worse than its heaviest axle
2 essays · internal-forces The same beam, cut at x = 5. A beam separated at one station. On the exposed face a shear force and a bending moment appear, equal and opposite on the two pieces, with values obtained by summing the forces on whichever piece is easier.

Internal forces

  1. 1 What a cut reveals, and why it was there all along
  2. 2 The moment that will not lie flat
2 essays · internal-forces A pile has no length until the ground gives it one. Deflection, bending moment and soil reaction down a 0.6 m pile carrying 150 kN at a free head, in ground whose modulus grows by 0.005 N/mm³ per millimetre of depth. The one length in the problem is T, the fifth root of EI over n_h, which is 1.89 m here; the head moves 20.5 mm, the worst moment of 219 kNm is at 2.50 m — 1.32 T — and below about four T nothing happens at all. The classical coefficients come out of the finite differences rather than a table: 2.430 against Matlock and Reese's 2.435, and 0.772 against their 0.772.

Lateral pile

  1. 1 A pile has no length until the ground gives it one
  2. 2 The pile that is too short to bend
2 essays · internal-forces

All essays