Structural Engineering & Statics
where the load goes
Ladder

Membrane analogy — the ladder

One essay so far against this idea. A ladder is the distinct arguments that stand against one idea, and this one has room to grow.
  1. A soap film over a hole, and its volume is the torsion constant. The stress function for Saint-Venant torsion of a square of 100 mm, relaxed on a 97 by 97 grid until it stopped moving — 385 sweeps. Its contours are the lines the shear stress runs along, its slope is the magnitude of that stress, and twice its volume is the torsion constant: 1.4053e+7 mm⁴ against a closed form of 1.4058e+7, an error of -0.035 per cent. The steepest slope is 67.515 at the boundary, at the point on it nearest the centre — which is why the peak shear in a solid section is at the middle of the longest side and never at a corner, where the film comes down to zero from two directions and its slope vanishes.

    Two volumes, and both of them are torques

    Torsion of a solid section that is not a circle has no elementary answer, and for thirty years after Saint-Venant posed it the only way to get one was to blow a soap film over a hole cut in a plate and measure it. The film is not an illustration of the solution. It is the solution, and so is a heap of sand poured on the same hole.

    rung 1 · sections

All ladders