Load path — where it appears
Named by 78 essays across 9 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.
The load that is spread out, and the force that replaces it
A distributed load can be swapped for a single force at its centroid. The reactions come out identical and the bending moment does not, and knowing which side of the cut the swap is legitimate on is most of the skill.
What a cut reveals, and why it was there all along
Cut a beam anywhere and two quantities appear on the face — a shear force and a bending moment. Nothing was applied there. They are what the material was already doing.
The property that appears in none of the equations
Ductility is in no design formula on this site. Every method on this site depends on it — and a brittle structure does not merely fail early, it makes the analysis wrong.
The connection is not a point, and every diagram so far says it is
Every free body drawn here has joined its members at points. Real structures fail at the joints far more often than in the members, and the reason is that a joint is exactly the region the theory behind every other page explicitly excludes.
The metal between the holes, which comes out as a block
A bolted end connection can fail without a single bolt breaking and without the plate reaching its tensile strength anywhere. A block of metal simply comes out, bounded by two surfaces with two different strengths on them.
The angle that uses half of itself
Bolt an angle through one leg and the other leg is not fully working. The correction is one over a length — both halves of it are geometry, neither involves a material, and a two-bolt connection throws away a quarter of the section.
The load a beam is given is a decision
Every beam calculation so far has started with a load per metre, handed over as though it were a property of the beam. It is not. It is the answer to a prior question nobody draws, and two defensible answers to it differ by sixty per cent on the same floor.
The slab that spans both ways
A panel supported on four sides sends its load in two directions at once, and the share is decided by a fourth power — so a panel a third longer than it is wide has already stopped being a two-way slab in any useful sense. What it does at collapse is a different calculation with a different answer.
The stiffest path takes the load
When two members share a force the split can be argued about. When they share a displacement it cannot — stiffness settles it, and nothing about the load or the plan drawing gets a vote. The consequence is that stiffening a lightly loaded member raises its stress, and the way to unload something is to soften it.
The beam that sits on the ground
Every other beam in this collection is held at points. A footing is held everywhere, by something that pushes back in proportion to how far it is pushed — and that single change hands the structure a length it did not choose. Two or three of those lengths from the column, nothing knows the load happened.
The flange that is not all there
Stress can only get into a wide flange through shear along its junction with the web, and shear takes distance to do it. So the width that is working is set by the span, and a flange 3 m wide on a 20 m span has 18762 mm² of steel that is there, and paid for, and hardly carrying anything.
Which member moved the roof
A beam sags because it curves. A truss has no curvature anywhere — it comes down because every one of its members changes length, and the sum of those changes, weighted member by member, is a ranking that names which ones are worth stiffening. Usually not the ones a designer worries about.
The column that stops
A load path that runs straight to the ground costs almost nothing. Interrupting one costs depth in proportion to the square root of the load times the distance it is moved — and the interruption's own deflection becomes the settlement of everything standing on it.
The panel that carries more after it has failed
Everywhere else in this field a critical load is where the argument ends. A thin web is the exception — it buckles visibly, in waves anybody can see, and then goes on to carry nearly twice as much again by turning itself into a truss nobody drew.
When there is no section to design
Beam theory needs a section, and a section needs the strain to be linear across it. Within about a depth of a support, a load, a corner or a hole it is not — and those are the regions structures actually fail in.
The hole that costs nothing, and everything
A service opening removes 30% of a beam's second moment and 0.7% of its deflection. What it costs is not that. Across the opening the shear has nowhere to go but through the two tees, and a tee carrying shear over a length bends.
The truss with no diagonals
A rectangle without a diagonal is a mechanism, so a Vierendeel girder makes its corners rigid instead. The shear a diagonal would have carried as axial force now travels as bending in the chords, and bending is a far more expensive way to move a force.
Three equations at every joint
A plane truss is determinate when m + r = 2j. A space frame needs 3j, and that one changed digit is why a cube of twelve bars is six mechanisms short while looking perfectly solid — and why every three-dimensional frame ever built is made of triangles in several planes at once.
The most dangerous day is before it is finished
A structure is analysed once, complete, with every restraint present. It spends weeks in states nobody drew — a beam landed with no deck on it holds 17% of the moment its section is worth, a frame not yet braced buckles at a third of the load it will, and a bolt not yet tightened is a pin where the analysis assumed a fixity.
The torsion that goes away if you let it
A spandrel beam attracts a torque in proportion to its own torsional stiffness. Crack it and the stiffness falls by a factor of four, the torque falls with it, and nothing has failed — because the floor beam it was competing with picks up exactly what was shed. A canopy hung off the same spandrel is a different animal entirely.
The settlement that matters is the difference
A building that goes down half a metre uniformly is undamaged and needs a new front step. One that goes down a twentieth as far, unevenly, has cracked. The superstructure can even the difference out — and the only way it can do so is by carrying the difference itself, as a force.
The part that is meant to be weak
A braced frame is stiff and has nowhere to yield. A moment frame yields everywhere and is soft. Move the two diagonals a metre apart along the beam and the whole storey shear has to pass through the segment between them — which keeps most of the stiffness and puts every yielding in one member the designer chose.
The tree that strength does not ask for
A branching column carries a roof on many points and reaches the ground on one. Size every member by its stress and the optimum tree turns out to have no trunk at all — the best answer is a fan of straight struts from the base. Put buckling in and the trunk appears, at 57 per cent of the height.
The load that has to be lifted
Every shear calculation on this site assumes the load arrives on the top of the beam and walks down a diagonal to the support. Hang the same load from the soffit and the diagonal cannot start — the load has to be carried up to the compression zone first, by a tie no sectional calculation contains.
The shear the chords take
Every shear check in this collection has assumed the two chords of a beam are parallel, so that the whole of the shear crosses the web. Taper the member and that stops being true — and the sign of the correction is decided by which end the haunch is at.
The cable that is a spring
A suspension bridge's cable is a funicular — it takes the shape the load gives it, and the deck's job is to make the load one that shape is right for. A stayed deck is not that at all. Its cables are straight, each reaches the deck at one point, and every one of them behaves as an inclined spring.
Held up by the air inside
A membrane has no bending stiffness at all, so the only thing that can hold it in tension is a pressure difference. The pressure needed to hold up a roof is smaller than the pressure a closed door makes — and the same pressure arrives at the foundation as hundreds of tonnes of uplift.
The point the mechanism turns about
A collapsing frame is a chain of rigid pieces, and every piece is rotating about some point. Find those points and the whole collapse load reads off two ratios of lengths, with no trigonometry anywhere — and for a pitched roof the point in question is well above the top of the drawing.
The angle that doubles the force
A crane hook takes the weight and nothing else. What holds the load is a set of legs running down to it at an angle, and each leg is a two-force member — so at thirty degrees from the horizontal each of two legs carries the entire load, and the difference goes into the thing being lifted as compression.
Most of it is suction
A wind load is drawn as arrows pressing on the windward face, which is where about three fifths of it comes from. The rest is a pull on the back. The two side faces carry the largest suctions on the building and contribute nothing at all to the answer — and the inside of the building, which nobody draws, decides whether the roof stays on.
The width nobody drew
Every other member in this collection arrives with a cross-section. A gusset plate does not — it is a piece of steel with a brace bolted to it somewhere in the middle, and no geometry says how much of it is working. The profession's answer is a thirty-degree spread from a 1952 master's thesis, it invents three quarters of the area being checked, and the check it was written for is not the one that governs.
The load that arrives where the wind stops
Snow is the one load a structure is given rather than subjected to. What falls is spread evenly over a whole region; what a member carries is whatever the wind left above it, and the wind piles it against whatever gets in the way. The heaviest patch on a roof is usually a quarter of the snow on it.
The load that is really a lean
No frame is ever plumb. The columns are out of upright by something like a three-hundredth, and every tonne of gravity load standing on that lean has a horizontal component. The force that represents it is not a safety allowance — it is an exact statics substitution for a geometry nobody drew.
The weight that has to be known before it can be found
Every other load arrives from outside and can be looked up. A structure's own weight depends on how big it is, and how big it is depends on the load — so the first calculation on any project is a fixed point, and the fraction of a member spent carrying itself turns out to be the square of its span as a fraction of a span it can never reach.
The tie that spends an afternoon as a strut
A tension member is chosen by its area and nothing else. A compression member is chosen by how that area is arranged. So a member whose force reverses under some load case is not merely being asked for the same number with the other sign — it is being designed against a different variable, and the same steel can carry seventy times more or less depending on a shape nobody chose for that purpose.
The support that is not a point
A reaction is drawn as a single arrow because the equilibrium equations only need its total. Underneath the arrow is a bearing of some width, delivering a pressure over that width, and almost everything a designer would like to know about the region near a support is a consequence of the width the arrow does not have.
The moment the beam left behind
A beam reaction is drawn arriving on a column's centreline. It arrives on a cleat a hundred millimetres out from the face, and the difference is a couple that goes into the column and has to be shared between the lengths above and below it. Nothing about it appears in a frame model whose members meet at nodes.
The same span, four ways
A beam, a truss, an arch and a cable can all cross the same gap under the same load, and the choice between them is usually described as a matter of judgement or of taste. It is neither. Each carries the load by a different mechanism, each mechanism has a different exponent, and an exponent decides the ordering at every span rather than at some spans.
The columns that lean
A framed tube carries its wind load by bending the spandrel beams between its columns, and it does it badly — the corner columns take nearly six times what the middle ones do. Tilt the columns instead, so the perimeter is triangulated, and the same shear is carried axially. The concentration falls to 1.21 and the tube recovers most of the stiffness the plan said it had.
The strength thrown away on purpose
Masonry, concrete and soil are all analysed as though they had no tensile strength whatever. Each of them has some. The decision to set it to zero is the single most consequential modelling assumption in the subject, it is safe for one kind of check and unsafe for another, and almost nothing that uses it says which.
The failure that is in the concrete
An anchor bolt is a steel component and its capacity is usually decided by something else entirely — a cone of concrete pulled out around it, failing in tension, in a material every other calculation on the project has assumed cannot take tension at all. The exponent in the capacity says so: it is not the square the geometry implies.
The joint that has to be as good as the member
A splice exists because members come in lengths and structures do not. It has to deliver the same force, at the same stiffness, in the same distribution across the section, through a discontinuity — and each of those three requirements is met by a different feature of the detail, with the third one usually left to look after itself.
The load that is over before it has moved
A blast delivers an enormous pressure for a few milliseconds. Everything else in this field asks what force a structure can carry; a load that has come and gone before the structure has travelled any distance is not asking that question, and the answer turns out to depend on the mass and the ductility with the strength barely in it.
The liquid has a period of its own
Shake a tank and its contents do not all go with it. Part of the liquid moves as though it were bolted to the wall and part sloshes at a period fixed by gravity and the radius, which the tank's stiffness has no influence over whatever. The split is decided by one proportion, and the two parts then take entirely different amounts of the earthquake.
The strength with no mechanism in it
A concrete member with no links in it carries shear, and the expression that says how much is three variables raised to fitted powers with a size term in front. There is no free body anywhere in it. What it is fitting is a competition between four things that carry shear across a crack, and only one of them explains why a deeper member is worse at it.
Three times as strong under a smaller pad
Press a small plate onto a large block of concrete and it will carry three times the stress a cylinder of the same concrete fails at. The enhancement is a ratio of areas with no material property in it, which should be a warning: what has actually been measured is not the concrete's strength but the strength of a tie holding it together.
The load that comes from changing direction
A force that travels in a straight line asks nothing of anything. Bend its path and it asks for a transverse load of F over R along every millimetre of the curve, and that load is real, is nowhere on the load schedule, and is the same statement behind a prestressing tendon, a hoop force, an arch thrust and a web that buckles with nothing applied to it.
Two curvatures of opposite sign
A single family of cables is not a structure. It is a mechanism that takes whatever shape the load asks for, and it will do that under any load pattern it was not tensioned for. Cross it with a second family curved the other way, pull the two against each other, and the pair becomes stiff — with no bending anywhere and no material property involved in the stiffness at all.
Where the structure is allowed to move
One drawing decides how big every movement joint on a bridge is and where every horizontal force goes, it takes an afternoon, and it appears on no calculation sheet. Move the fixed point from an abutment to the middle pier and the largest joint halves and the horizontal force on that support drops from the whole of the friction to none of it.
The force the brace leaves behind
Two braces meeting under a beam carry the storey shear as a tension and a compression whose vertical components cancel, so the beam above sees nothing. They cancel only while both braces are elastic. Once the compression brace buckles it sheds most of its force, the tension brace goes on to yield, and the difference is a point load at midspan that nobody applied.
The web that is crushed from inside
A plate girder's compression flange is curved by the beam's own deflection, and a curved force needs a transverse load to stay on its curve. The only thing available to supply it is the web. So a deep girder can buckle its web vertically with nothing applied to it at all, and the rule that prevents it is the only clause in the codes about a load no load case contains.
The check that cannot see the error
Every analysis prints a global equilibrium residual, and it is the first thing anybody looks at. It catches a lost restraint and a load entered in the wrong unit immediately. It is structurally incapable of catching a member whose stiffness is wrong by a factor of ten, because the wrong answer is still in equilibrium with the same loads.
The roller that is not a roller
A sliding bearing is drawn as a roller and detailed as a sheet of PTFE, and it delivers a horizontal force of a few per cent of whatever it is carrying. The coefficient everybody quotes is the one at full design pressure, and PTFE's coefficient rises as the pressure falls — so the bearing is at its freest exactly where nobody checks it.
The ground that hangs on instead of holding up
A pile is driven through fill that has not finished settling. The fill goes down past the shaft, the friction along that length turns round, and the pile is now carrying the soil rather than the other way about. The worst force is not at the head and not at the toe, and nothing at that depth can be seen.
The crack that never reached forty-five degrees
Every shear expression for reinforced concrete is a curve fitted to tests, because a cracked section has no free body worth drawing. An uncracked prestressed web has one — a single point, a Mohr's circle and a principal tension — and it is the only shear check in the subject that is derived rather than measured.
Two cells, one equation, and a web with nothing in it
Bredt's formula answers a single closed cell because a single closed cell has one unknown and one equation. Put a web down the middle and there are two unknowns and still one equation — and the answer, when the missing statement is supplied, is that the new web carries exactly nothing.
Hung from the top, and nine per cent lighter
A tie is worth its full strength and a strut is not, so hanging the floors of a building from a hat truss ought to be an obvious economy. It is a real one, it is measurable, and it is nine per cent of the steel — shrinking as the building gets taller, which is the opposite of what the argument sounds like.
The deck that is its own cable
Every other cable structure hangs something from the cable. A stressed ribbon hangs nothing — the walking surface is the catenary, laid at a fiftieth of the span rather than a tenth, because a footbridge has to be walkable. That one decision hands the abutments six and a quarter times the entire weight of the bridge.
Every pressure points at the pin
Pressure acts normal to a surface, so on a curved one every element pushes in a different direction and no multiplication gives the resultant. Two free bodies recover it without an integral — and on a circular surface a third observation makes the whole force disappear from the equation a hoist has to satisfy.
The movement with no limit against it
Every code in the world gives a deflection limit. None gives a twist limit — and a beam loaded off its shear centre twists. On an open section a modest eccentricity moves the flange tip further sideways than four fifths of the sag that does get checked, and nothing anywhere says whether that is acceptable.
The joint that is crooked by construction
Lap two plates and fasten them and the two load paths are offset by the thickness of a plate. The joint carries a moment nobody applied, the peak stress is four times the mean, and the rotation that is supposed to straighten it out saves eleven per cent — because the rescue works for thin sheet with a long lap and a bolted structural joint is neither.
The section that is checked is not the one chosen
A beam framing into a girder has its top flange cut away so the two can sit at the same level. What is left is a tee with a quarter of the section modulus, a web with a free edge, and a re-entrant corner — and the beam was selected on a table entry that describes none of it.
The gap between two buildings
Two towers side by side in an earthquake need a gap. The obvious answer is the sum of what each can move, and it is wrong — because the two peaks do not happen at the same instant. What decides the answer is the ratio of the two periods, and buildings that sway alike need almost no gap at all.
The load that is never all there at once
A column at the bottom of twenty storeys is designed for the imposed load of twenty floors added up, and twenty floors do not reach their own worst day together. The reduction that follows is not a discount on the safety margin. It is the central limit theorem, and it has a floor it never goes below.
The deck that spans square
A slab bridge crossing a road at an angle is loaded uniformly and does not carry uniformly. Load takes the shortest route between the abutments, which is not the direction the carriageway runs, and the reaction piles up in two corners.
Every level is a longer span
A floor is a hierarchy — deck to joists to beams to girders — and the reason usually given is that breaking a long span into short ones saves material. A bending level's weight per square metre contains its span and not its spacing, so it does not.
The end that is only a plate
Cut one flange off a beam's end and what is left is a tee. Cut both and what is left is a plate with holes in it — no flanges, no section modulus worth the name, and none of the checks the beam was selected by. Three plate checks replace them, and the one that governs depends on dimensions that appear in no section table.
Turn the column, and the slab passes
A flat slab that is comfortable under gravity fails its punching check the moment a moment arrives at the column, and nothing about the load has changed. The fix is not more concrete. It is the column's plan shape and, at equal area, which way round it is turned — worth more than adding half again as much column.
The lacing decides the force it has to carry
A perfectly straight column carries no shear, so the diagonals of a built-up column are resisting a force that exists only because the column is crooked. Computing it turns out to be circular — the shear is amplified by the very flexibility the lacing supplies — and the rule of thumb that replaces the calculation is wrong by a factor that grows as the lacing gets worse.
The coating that takes the resistance with it
The cure for downdrag is to make the pile slippery, and it works — a bitumen slip layer takes the drag on this pile from 1,131 kN to 34. It also removes the shaft friction that was holding the pile up, in the same proportion and over the same length, and past a certain smoothness there is no neutral plane to find because there is no equilibrium.
The frame is a girder stood on end
Every unbraced building frame is a Vierendeel girder turned through ninety degrees, and the identification is not an analogy — it is the same equations with the axes swapped. Which means the frame inherits results that read as absurd for a building — more bays is stiffer, a wider building is not, and doubling one section property halves the sway.
The tension has to pull on something
A buckled web carries its shear on a diagonal band of membrane tension, and the band pulls sideways on the flanges and stiffeners that bound it. That pull is the design output nobody plots — it runs from 72 to 603 newtons per millimetre across ordinary panel proportions, it is largest exactly where the panel is most efficient, and at the end of the girder there is nothing beyond to take it.
One diaphragm is nearly none
A box girder's distortion decays over a length the section decides, and on a sixty-metre span that length is twenty-four metres. So a single diaphragm at midspan sits further from each end than the distortion can reach and removes a third of the problem; three diaphragms remove nine tenths. The spacing rule is not span over five — it is a property of the plates.
A determinate truss has no robustness at all
Remove any one of a Warren truss's thirty-one members and what is left is a mechanism. Not weakened — gone, with no set of forces that holds the load in any position. Robustness is not a property a structure has by degree; it is bought by adding members that carry nothing until something else stops carrying, and a truss without them has none of it to measure.
A column nine hundred millimetres long
The patch-load check asks how much of a web a flange can spread a wheel over, and answers in a plate-buckling reduction that throws seven tenths of it away. A pair of stiffeners does not improve that answer. It replaces the question with a different one, from a different family, with a different failure in it.
The plate that is only as big as it is thick
A base plate's design is presented as a bearing calculation: an area, a bearing strength, and a check that the pressure fits. The area in that calculation is the plate, and the plate cannot deliver it — a 20 mm plate on a 500 square reaches 43 mm past the column and the corners carry nothing at all.
The repair that fixes the wrong check
A coped beam end that fails its checks is usually repaired by welding a plate along the edge the cope left, because the cope removed a flange and the plate puts one back. On ordinary proportions that repair restores the check that was not failing. The check that governs is carried by the web, and only a plate on the web reaches it.
The column given more than its rectangle
The tributary rule draws a rectangle round each column and hands it whatever stands inside. A floor is continuous over its columns, and a continuous beam does not give each support the load above it — the first interior one takes a quarter more and the end ones a quarter less. On a grid the two directions multiply, and two columns on the same floor differ by a factor of nearly three.
Named alongside it
The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.
Free bodyStiffnessEquilibriumServiceabilityBucklingCompatibilityDuctilityFunicularMembrane actionPlastic hingeRobustnessSaint-Venant's principle