Structural Engineering & Statics
where the load goes
Concept

Negative stiffness — where it appears

A restoring force that falls as the displacement grows, so that pushing further takes less force rather than more. A rocking block has it once it lifts, because its weight's lever arm shortens as it leans, and a tendon that stretches with the rotation is how a designer gives the slope back.

Named by 3 essays across one field — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

A restoring moment that gets smaller the further it leans. Restoring moment against rotation for a block 0.90 m wide and 4.20 m tall, both normalised — the moment by its value at first uplift, the rotation by the angle α = 12.1° at which the block topples. It is mgR·sin(α − θ), which is a weight times a geometry with no material property in it at all, and it has two features an elastic system does not. There is a jump at the origin: the moment is whatever the ground demands until uplift and then it is mgR sinα, so the law is discontinuous where a spring's is steepest. And the slope is negative — the further it leans the less it pushes back — so the equilibrium at θ = 0 is stable only because of that jump, and there is no stiffness to divide into a mass. The straight line is what a spring of the same first-uplift strength would have done.

The block that is safer for being bigger

A block resting on the ground lifts off at an acceleration that depends only on its shape and not at all on its size, and then falls over at one that depends strongly on its size. Two objects of identical proportion begin rocking at the same instant and only the smaller one topples — which is why the slender water towers stood in Chile and the squat tanks beside them did not.

dynamics · Rocking The same pulse on a wall that is designed to rock. Rotation as a fraction of the toppling angle under one 0.8 s sine pulse of 1.00 g, for the same 2.0 × 8.0 m wall of 400 kN three ways. Bare, it lifts at 0.250 g; with a 600 kN tendon it lifts at 0.625 g. The bare wall reaches 79 per cent of its toppling angle with one landing; with the tendon it reaches 27 per cent of its toppling angle with eight landings; with tendon and bars it reaches 12 per cent of its toppling angle with 43 landings. With its bars it comes to rest upright. The landings are where the bare wall loses energy; the bars add a loss that does not wait for a landing.

A wall that is allowed to lift

A block that rocks inherits everything that decides whether it survives — a restoring moment set by its weight and shape that falls as it leans, and a loss of energy set by its proportions at each landing. Put a tendon through a wall and yielding bars across its base and both become design quantities, and the ratio between them decides whether the wall comes home.

dynamics · Rocking After a yield, the prestress left does not remember the prestress put in. The prestress left in the tendon of a 2.0 × 8.0 m rocking wall of 400 kN once it has rocked to each rotation and come back upright, for a tendon yielding at 1,370 kN and stiffening by 20 kN a millimetre as the base opens, prestressed to 300 kN, 600 kN and 900 kN. Each keeps all its prestress until it yields — at 53.5 mrad, 38.5 mrad and 23.5 mrad — and then loses 20 kN for every further milliradian, so past 53.5 mrad the three lines are one: the yield force less the stiffness times the stretch. Every one of them is slack at upright past 68.5 mrad. With bars of 400 kN the wall re-centres only while 400 kN remains, dashed, and it keeps that only up to 48.5 mrad, whatever it was prestressed to.

The tendon that forgets its prestress

A rocking wall comes home because a tendon pulls it, and the tendon must not yield — yet the rotations that test the wall are exactly the ones that stretch it. Past its yield, the force a tendon keeps is its yield force less its stiffness times the stretch, whatever it was prestressed to, so the guarantee a design needs is a limit on rotation, and more prestress only reaches that limit sooner.

dynamics · Rocking

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Ductility demandEnergy dissipationNon-linear responseOverturningRockingHysteresisImpulsePrestressRestitutionBase isolationDampingEquilibrium

All concepts