Structural Engineering & Statics
where the load goes
Concept

Capacity design — where it appears

Choosing where a structure will yield and then making everything else strong enough for that choice to come true. The forces the protected members are designed for come from the yielding element's own capacity rather than from the applied load.

Named by 8 essays across 5 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

A ground motion, on a structure of 1.00 s period. Displacement against time for a single-degree-of-freedom structure of natural period 1.00 s and 5.0% damping, under a ground motion of 3.5 m/s² peak. The elastic peak is 74.47 mm, and the same frame given a 4th of that strength peaks at 69.87 mm and comes to rest 11.82 mm from where it started.

The earthquake asks for a displacement

A structure a quarter as strong as the elastic demand does not deflect four times as far. It deflects almost exactly as far, yields on the way, and survives — which is why no ordinary building is designed for the force an earthquake would apply if it stayed elastic.

dynamics · Ductility demand Every path to the ground goes through the link. A braced bay 8 m by 4 m whose two diagonals stop 800 mm apart instead of meeting. The storey shear reaches the ground through the diagonals, and the vertical components they deliver to the beam have to pass through the segment between them: the link carries 47% of the applied shear as a shear force, at a lever arm short enough that its ends reach 0 kNm while the rest of the beam carries 0. The deflected shape drawn is the solved one, magnified — the real drift under this load is 0.008 mm. Everything outside the link is designed to stay elastic while the link is yielding, which is what makes the mechanism a choice rather than a hope.

The part that is meant to be weak

A braced frame is stiff and has nowhere to yield. A moment frame yields everywhere and is soft. Move the two diagonals a metre apart along the beam and the whole storey shear has to pass through the segment between them — which keeps most of the stiffness and puts every yielding in one member the designer chose.

structures · Eccentric brace How fast the strain arrived, which a quoted strength does not record. The dynamic increase factor on strength against strain rate, over eight decades. Steel follows Cowper and Symonds' fit, whose constant D = 40.4 s⁻¹ is not an arbitrary parameter — it is the rate at which the material is exactly twice as strong. Concrete in tension follows the model code's two-branch curve and is steeper. The four marked regimes are the argument: a testing machine works at about 10⁻⁴ per second, an earthquake at 5 × 10⁻³, a vehicle impact at a half, a blast at a hundred, and the enhancement across them runs 1.00, 1.08, 1.32, 2.04. So this is a correction that is either negligible or decisive with very little in between, which is why no seismic code carries it and every blast code does. What does not rise is the modulus, which is a lattice property, and the ultimate strength rises only a third as much — so the ultimate-to-yield ratio closes from 1.56 to 1.23 and the material has less warning left in it than it started with.

The steel that is stronger in a millisecond

Every strength quoted anywhere in this collection was measured at about a ten-thousandth of a strain per second, because that is what a testing machine does, and nothing on a drawing says so. Load the same steel a million times faster and its yield stress rises by a third.

materials · Strain rate A base plate, and when the bolts start working. A 500 × 500 mm plate carrying 600 kN and 180 kN·m, so the resultant sits 300 mm from the centre against a kern of 83.33 mm. The plate is in bolts engaged: bearing over 150.88 mm at a peak of 20 N/mm², with the holding-down bolts carrying 154.42 kN. The plate lifts at 50 kN·m and crushes at 126 kN·m, and the bolts are not needed until 150 kN·m.

The failure that is in the concrete

An anchor bolt is a steel component and its capacity is usually decided by something else entirely — a cone of concrete pulled out around it, failing in tension, in a material every other calculation on the project has assumed cannot take tension at all. The exponent in the capacity says so: it is not the square the geometry implies.

connections · Anchor breakout The two braces balance until one of them buckles. An inverted-V brace after the compression member has gone. While both braces are elastic they carry equal and opposite forces and their vertical components cancel on the beam above, which is why the beam in a chevron bay is usually sized for gravity alone. The compression brace buckles at 445 kN and then sheds most of what it was carrying — 30% is left here — while the tension brace goes on to yield at 1065. The difference between the two vertical components is 659 kN, applied at the middle of the span with no help from either brace, and it asks the beam for 1317 kNm against the 200 kNm the gravity load asks for — 6.6 times as much. The beam drawn does not: 1517 kNm against a capacity of 731. The force is not a load case anybody applies; it is what the frame leaves behind on its way to the state it will actually be in.

The force the brace leaves behind

Two braces meeting under a beam carry the storey shear as a tension and a compression whose vertical components cancel, so the beam above sees nothing. They cancel only while both braces are elastic. Once the compression brace buckles it sheds most of its force, the tension brace goes on to yield, and the difference is a point load at midspan that nobody applied.

structures · Chevron brace The loop a brace has when it cannot buckle. Force against axial deformation for two braces with the same core area, cycled six times at a storey drift of 2 per cent. An ordinary brace yields at 900 kN in tension and buckles at 482 in compression — 54 per cent of it — and the buckled shape leaves a plastic hinge that does not straighten, so the compression side loses capacity every cycle and is at 12 per cent of its first value by the last. A restrained brace has a casing that carries no axial force at all and only holds the core straight, which decouples axial capacity from flexural stiffness — the coupling that makes a strut weaker than a tie — so it yields at the same force both ways and hardens instead. The energy dissipated is 2.07 times as much over the six cycles, and the casing has to satisfy one inequality: π²EI/L² above the fully hardened core force, 2.56 here, which is a buckling check on a member carrying nothing.

The brace that yields both ways

An ordinary diagonal yields in tension at its full strength and buckles in compression at half of it, and the buckle leaves a hinge that does not straighten. Stop it buckling with a sleeve that carries no load at all and the loop becomes symmetric.

dynamics · Buckling-restrained A preloaded joint, before and after it slips. Eight preloaded bolts at 100 kN each, on two friction faces at μ = 0.35. The joint carries 560 kN by friction with the bolts in tension and not in shear at all; past that it slips into bearing and carries 900 kN with the bolts now in shear. Two different mechanisms, one joint.

The force that is capped on purpose

Everywhere else in this collection friction is a nuisance whose value nobody controls, checked with a coefficient known to one figure. In a friction damper the inequality is the design intent — the device is specified so that a member behind it can never be asked for more than a stated force.

equilibrium · Friction A fuse caps the force the strand ever sees. The force in the tendon line of a 2.0 × 8.0 m rocking wall of 400 kN, prestressed to 600 kN, with bars of 400 kN, against the opening of the base under the tendon, loaded to 79 mm and back: the strand alone, 20 kN/mm yielding at 1,370 kN, and the strand with a fuse yielding at 1,000 kN with a stiffness of 500 kN/mm in series, together 19.2 kN/mm and capped at 1,000 kN. The strand alone yields at 39 mm and is slack at upright after any opening past 69 mm; the fused line yields at 21 mm and is slack past 52 mm. In the fused line the strand carries the line's force and never more than 1,000 kN, so it stays elastic and all the plastic stretch, 58 mm at this opening, is in the fuse.

The fuse that protects the strand and not the wall

A rocking wall's tendon loses its prestress when it yields, so give it a fuse: a short link in series that yields first and is replaced afterwards. The strand then never passes 1,000 kN and stays elastic. But the fuse caps the restoring moment lower, so under the same 1.5 g pulse the wall rocks to 110 mrad instead of 89, and the line loses all its prestress just as the strand did. A new fuse gives the prestress back; the bars' stretch stays, and the next pulse takes the wall to 134 mrad.

dynamics · Rocking

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

DuctilityHysteresisEnergy dissipationPlastic hingeBucklingLoad pathFree bodyLateral systemOverstrengthAnchorageBase plateBehaviour factor

All concepts