Structural Engineering & Statics
where the load goes
Concept

Uplift — where it appears

Tension where a structure was expected to press down, which arrives at one edge of a base long before anything is close to tipping over. It appears at one edge of a base as soon as the resultant leaves the kern, long before the overturning factor of safety is anywhere near one.

Named by 8 essays across 3 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

Weight is the only thing holding it down. A body 2.5 m wide and 6 m tall weighing 120 kN, under a wind pressure of 1 kN/m². The wind delivers 48 kN and an overturning moment of 144 kNm about the leeward toe; the weight restores 150 kNm, a factor of 1.04. The resultant lands 1.20 m from the centre against a middle third of ±0.42 m, so the base is lifting over 2.35 m of its width.

Weight is the only thing resisting it

A structure that is strong enough everywhere can still be blown over, and nothing in its material properties has any part in whether it is. The whole answer is a weight and a width — and the failure begins long before anything tips, at the moment one edge stops pressing down.

equilibrium · Overturning The middle third, computed. The kern of a 400 × 600 mm rectangle, computed by asking, for every direction, how far the resultant can move before the far face would be pulled. It reaches ±100.0 mm vertically and ±66.7 mm horizontally, which are h/6 and b/6 exactly, and the region between is a rhombus rather than the ellipse the two numbers suggest — a resultant on a diagonal has less room than either axis allows.

The middle third

A material that cannot be pulled imposes a condition on where the load may land, and the condition is a region rather than a point. For a rectangle it is the famous middle third; for every other section it is a shape nobody quotes, and one ordinary section's is nearly twice as generous as the rule allows.

sections · Kern A basement is a boat. A 20 by 30 m substructure dug 6 m into ground whose water table stands 2 m down. The head on the underside of the base slab is 4.0 m, so the pressure there is 39.2 kN/m² over the whole plan — 23.5 MN of it, pushing upward. Nothing about the structure changes that number. What resists it is weight: 18.7 MN of concrete and whatever is built above, giving a factor of 0.80. The structure floats if the water reaches 2.82 m below the ground, and a base slab alone would have to be 1.64 m thick to hold it down.

A basement is a boat

Every load in this collection presses down and is resisted by strength. Hydrostatic uplift presses up, is resisted by weight, and does not care what is built on it — so the check contains no material property at all. It is a ratio of two weights, and one of them is water.

equilibrium · Uplift Held up by a pressure nobody can feel. An air-supported roof of 60 m span and 9 m rise. The membrane has no bending stiffness whatever, so the only thing that can hold it in tension is a pressure difference, and the pressure has to exceed the load per unit plan area and nothing else: 0.25 kN/m² of fabric plus 0.6 of snow is 0.85 kN/m², so 1.19 kN/m² does it — 1190 pascals, which is 1.17 per cent of an atmosphere and 121 millimetres of water. Ears do not notice it. A door does: at 2.1 kN on an ordinary leaf, the building needs an airlock rather than a handle. And the whole of it arrives at the foundation as 3365 kN of uplift — 17.9 kN on every metre of perimeter — which is the bill the pressure's smallness conceals.

Held up by the air inside

A membrane has no bending stiffness at all, so the only thing that can hold it in tension is a pressure difference. The pressure needed to hold up a roof is smaller than the pressure a closed door makes — and the same pressure arrives at the foundation as hundreds of tonnes of uplift.

structures · Pneumatic structure The wind pushes on one face and pulls on three. A 30 × 20 m building in plan, with the measured pressure coefficient on each face and the arrows drawn in the direction the pressure acts. Only the windward face is pushed; the other three are sucked, and the side faces are sucked hardest of all at c_p = -0.7. The horizontal resultant is 842 kN at a velocity pressure of 0.9 kPa, and the arithmetic of it is the whole point: the leeward suction pulls the building downwind, so it ADDS, supplying 38% of the answer, while the two side faces cancel each other exactly and supply none of it. The coefficients are wind tunnel data; what is computed is the free body they are applied to.

Most of it is suction

A wind load is drawn as arrows pressing on the windward face, which is where about three fifths of it comes from. The rest is a pull on the back. The two side faces carry the largest suctions on the building and contribute nothing at all to the answer — and the inside of the building, which nobody draws, decides whether the roof stays on.

equilibrium · Wind pressure The group is not weaker; it is very much softer. A 3 × 3 pile cap on the left, with each pile's share of 9.0 MN and 4.5 MNm in meganewtons — N/n plus M·y/Σy², the same three terms in the same order as a bolt group under an eccentric load and a section under biaxial bending. The corner piles take 1.25 times the average and a pile added at the centroid would change that by nothing at all, because it adds to neither second moment. On the right is the effect a bolt group cannot have: the piles share ground, so the stress bulbs overlap and the group settles 3.9 times as much as a single pile at the same load per pile, rising to 14.2 for 144 of them. The capacity check everyone makes — block failure against the sum of the piles — comes out at 4.54 here and does not govern at all. The check nobody tabulates is the one that does.

Nine piles, and four times the settlement

A pile cap divides its load between its piles by the same three terms a bolt group uses and a section under biaxial bending uses. What a bolt group does not have is neighbours it shares ground with — and the group effect that matters is not the strength check everybody makes, but a stiffness effect nobody tabulates.

structures · Pile group Every pressure points at the pin, so the water lifts nothing. A radial gate of radius 8 m holding 6 m of water, with its pivot 6 m above the sill. The pressure on a curved surface cannot be obtained by multiplying anything by anything, so it is integrated round the arc: the horizontal component comes to 176.6 kN/m and the vertical to 110.5. Both are recoverable without any integral at all — the horizontal is the pressure force on the surface's own vertical projection, γH²/2 = 176.6, and the vertical is the weight of the water standing above it, 110.5. They agree to 0.000 per cent. And because every pressure is normal to a circle, every one of them passes through the centre: the moment of the whole 208 kN/m about the pivot is -3.4e-15 kNm, against 353 for a flat gate on the same hinge.

Every pressure points at the pin

Pressure acts normal to a surface, so on a curved one every element pushes in a different direction and no multiplication gives the resultant. Two free bodies recover it without an integral — and on a circular surface a third observation makes the whole force disappear from the equation a hoist has to satisfy.

equilibrium · Curved surface pressure The push that tips it, in every direction. The tipping push in each plan direction, drawn as a distance from the centre, for a 6000 kN body with its weight 15 m up and the push at 18 m. On rigid ground the curve is the hull's: weakest along the axes at 1333 kN. On four equal pads it shrinks, and more toward the corners. With the pads as built — stiffnesses 20000, 20000, 8000, 20000 kN/m — it is no longer symmetric: the weakest direction is 15°, on the soft pad's side, at 1039 kN.

It tips inside its own hull

On rigid ground a body tips when its resultant reaches the edge of its base, and how stiff its supports are has nothing to do with it. On pads that settle, the body leans as it is pushed, the lean moves its weight, and the push that tips it falls by one number a site engineer already has: settlement times the height of the weight, over the square of the half-width. Toward a corner the loss doubles, and one soft pad makes the weakest direction one nobody checks.

equilibrium · Overturning

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

EquilibriumFree bodyOverturningBearing pressureFactor of safetyLoad pathEccentricityHydrostatic pressureKernResultantSecond momentAnchorage

All concepts