Structural Engineering & Statics
where the load goes
Concept

Cable stiffness — where it appears

A cable's resistance to a transverse load, which comes from its tension acting through its own curvature rather than from any property of its material. It rises as the cable is pulled and it falls to nothing as the cable goes slack, so a cable structure's stiffness is a function of the load already on it.

Named by 8 essays across 2 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

The abutment force is the sag turned upside down. A 100 m ribbon carrying 35 kN/m at a sag of 2.0 per cent of its span. H = wL²/8f, so the horizontal force at each abutment is 21875 kN — 6.25 times the entire weight of the deck, and five times what a suspension bridge of the same span and weight at a tenth would have needed. The curve is a reciprocal and it has no flat part: halving the sag doubles the force, at any sag. What stops a designer flattening it further is not the ribbon, which is in tension and cannot buckle. It is what the ground at each end will take, and at 6.25 deck-weights that is usually rock or a very large anchor block.

The deck that is its own cable

Every other cable structure hangs something from the cable. A stressed ribbon hangs nothing — the walking surface is the catenary, laid at a fiftieth of the span rather than a tenth, because a footbridge has to be walkable. That one decision hands the abutments six and a quarter times the entire weight of the bridge.

structures · Stressed ribbon Evenly spaced modes, so one of them is always where the feet are. The first 6 modes of a 120 m stay under 3.50 MN. A taut string's frequencies are an arithmetic progression — every one of them 1.006 Hz above the last — where a beam's go as the square of the mode number and spread out. That difference is the whole of why a cable is a lively member and a beam is not: a beam has a first mode and then a gap, and a cable has a mode every 1.01 Hz for ever. The shaded band is ordinary walking, 1.6 to 2.4 Hz, and mode 2 sits inside it. Nothing about the tension can move a mode out of the band without moving another one in.

The force read off a frequency

Nothing can measure the tension in a stay cable directly — there is no gauge, no accessible end and no place to put a load cell. What there is, is a member whose frequencies are an arithmetic progression whose spacing is the square root of its own tension, so a phone taped to it for thirty seconds returns the force.

dynamics · Cable dynamics The same bridge by the two theories it might have been designed by. Deck moment along a 500 m suspended span with half of it loaded, computed twice. Elastic theory treats the deck as a beam and applies the cable's extra tension as an upward load: 80.1 MN·m. Deflection theory keeps the cable's total tension acting on the deck's own deflected shape — a geometric stiffness — and returns 56.3, which is 30 per cent less. The extra cable tension is very nearly the same in both (6.20 against 6.11 MN), so nothing about the cable is in the difference: it is entirely the H·v″ term the older theory drops.

The tension that was left out

A suspension bridge's deck sits on a cable pulling hard along it, and a member with a large tension in it is stiffened by that tension. Leaving the term out of the deck's own equilibrium is what elastic theory does, and on a long span it asks for fourteen times the girder.

structures · Stiffening girder A load on one span moves the other. The change in level along two 100 m spans of stressed ribbon at a sag of 2.00 per cent, carrying 35 kN/m, when 20 kN/m of live load is added to the left-hand span, with a rigid pier (dashed) and with a pier of 200,000 kN/m (solid). With a rigid pier the loaded span sags a further 195 mm and the other does not move. With a pier of 200,000 kN/m the pier top leans 25 mm towards the load, the loaded span sags 358 mm and the unloaded span rises 191 mm; the pier carries 4,953 kN of the 9,440 kN a rigid pier would.

The pier that carries only the difference

A stressed ribbon continued over a pier pulls on it from both sides, and under its own weight the two pulls cancel. Load one span and they do not: the pier is asked for the difference, nearly ten meganewtons for a crowd on one of two hundred-metre spans. Whether it gives it depends on its stiffness against a number the ribbon supplies itself, and whatever the pier does not carry, the ribbon turns into movement — a third of a metre of extra sag in the loaded span and a fifth of a metre of rise in the empty one.

structures · Stressed ribbon One span hung, the other still bare tendon. The level along two 100 m spans at a sag of 2.00 per cent, 35 kN/m finished and 3.0 kN/m of bare tendon, the tendons at 1100 N/mm² when finished, with the deck hung on the left span only (solid) and as finished (dashed), on a pier of 200,000 kN/m. The hung span sags 2.04 m and pulls 21,442 kN; the bare tendon beside it sags 0.20 m and already pulls 18,363 kN, because it was cut 455 mm shorter than the span so as to carry its share when finished. The pier is asked for the difference, 3,080 kN, and leans 15 mm towards the hung span — against 4,953 kN under 20 kN/m of crowd on one finished span.

The tendon that pulls before the deck arrives

A stressed ribbon is hung one span at a time, and the obvious fear is the stage at which one span carries its deck and the next does not: the pier between them asked for a whole span's thrust. It is not asked for that, because tendons cut to the finished length are already stretched across the empty span and pulling. For two 100 m spans at a fiftieth, the rigid pier's stage force is 4,109 kN against a crowd's 9,440 — unless the tendons were sized generously, when the stage overtakes the crowd.

structures · Stressed ribbon The pier reads the difference between the two spans' temperatures. Contours of the pier force between two 100 m spans at a sag of 2.00 per cent with the deck hung on one, the tendons at 1,100 N/mm² when finished, on a pier of 200,000 kN/m, every half meganewton, over the warming of the hung span's tendons (across) and of the bare tendon's (up) since they were cut. With neither warmer the pier carries 3,080 kN; warming the bare tendon 30 °C alone gives 4,126 kN, the hung span alone 2,342 kN, and both together 3,392 kN. The contours are straight and parallel: the pier gains 35 kN for each degree the bare tendon warms and loses 25 for each degree the hung span does, so a warming both share moves it only 30 per cent as far as the same warming on the bare tendon alone, and what the pier feels is mostly how much warmer one span's strand is than the other's.

The strand in the sun beside the strand in the shade

Halfway through hanging a stressed ribbon, one span is a sagging cable full of segments and the next is bare tendon stretched nearly straight, and the pier between them carries the difference of their pulls. A warm day takes tension off both — and at the flat sag a ribbon is laid at, the hung span is so nearly all stretch that it loses three quarters of what the bare one does. What moves the pier is not the weather but the shade: strand in the sun beside strand under concrete, 35 kN on the pier for every degree between them. No sun slackens the bare tendon. The hour does change something else, which is the level the joints are cast at.

structures · Stressed ribbon Double the span and the deck is nearly three times nearer buckling. The factor on its own dead load at which a stayed deck buckles, against the main span, on logarithmic axes, for a deck of 0.50 × 10¹² N·m² under 150 kN/m with stays every 15 m from towers 0.40 of the half-span tall. At 300 m it is 40.7; at 600 m, 14.7; at 1,000 m, 6.9; at 2,000 m, 2.3. Beyond 600 m the line falls with a slope of 1.53; it crosses ten, below which a design has to follow the deck's deflections into its forces, at 805 m.

The deck the stays squeeze

Every stay of a cable-stayed bridge pulls the deck towards its tower, and the deck carries all those pulls as a compression that is largest at the tower — 95 MN in a 1,000 m span under 150 kN/m. The stays hold it up and hold it straight, as springs under a strut. The compression grows with the square of the span and the springs soften with it, so the factor on its own weight at which the deck would buckle falls as the span to the power one and a half: 41 at 300 m, 6.9 at 1,000 m, 2.3 at 2,000 m. A deck four times stiffer only doubles it, and the long stays' sag, which softens them for traffic, hardly enters.

structures · Stiffening girder The flatter the ribbon, the more the casting temperature matters. For two 100 m spans of a stressed ribbon under 35 kN/m on a pier of 200,000 kN/m, one span's joints cast 20 °C warmer than the other's: the force left on the pier as a share of the force a crowd of 20 kN/m on one span puts there, against the ribbon's sag as a percentage of its span. At a sag of 1 per cent the casting leaves 82 per cent of a crowd (1,902 kN against 2,316); at 2 per cent, 14 per cent; at 3, 3 per cent; at 4, 1 per cent.

The span cast in the afternoon

A stressed ribbon's joints are cast on whatever day the programme reaches them, and a span cast on a warm afternoon sets around strand that has lengthened in the sun. It cools that night as a concrete band eleven times stiffer than the strand, and the band does not stretch back as the strand would have. On a ribbon with a sag of 2 per cent, a span cast 20 °C warmer than its neighbour ends 72 mm higher than it was set and leaves 713 kN on the pier between them — a seventh of what a crowd on one span puts there. On a flatter ribbon the same afternoon costs more than the crowd. The difference between the two spans is the strand's flexibility against the band's, and only the elastic part of it differs; the part that comes from the sag is the same for both.

structures · Stressed ribbon

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Geometric stiffnessPrestressStressed ribbonErectionServiceabilityThermal movementThrustConstruction sequenceFunicularLoad sharingNatural periodSag ratio

All concepts