Structural Engineering & Statics
where the load goes
Concept

Bound theorems — where it appears

The pair of plasticity theorems that bracket a collapse load. Any mechanism gives a load at or above it and any equilibrium moment field within capacity gives one at or below, so the answer is known rather than estimated when the two meet.

Named by 5 essays across 4 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

What is left after the first fibre yields, which is a property of shape. The shape factor — plastic modulus over elastic — for six sections, computed by finding each one's equal-area axis and summing ±f_y over it. The numbers contain no dimension, no stress and no material: a rectangle is exactly 3/2 whatever its size, a diamond exactly 2, a circle 16/3π. The spread is the argument. An I-section keeps only 13 per cent in reserve past first yield, because nearly all its material is already at the extreme fibre and there is nothing further in to recruit; a diamond keeps 100 per cent, because most of its material is near the middle and doing very little elastically. So the section shapes that are best at elastic bending are the ones with the least left afterwards, which is exactly backwards from the way the reserve is usually described.

What is left after the first fibre yields

The elastic section modulus stops at the moment the outermost fibre reaches yield. Nothing else in the section has, so it goes on taking load — and how much more it takes turns out to be a property of the shape alone, with no dimension, no stress and no material anywhere in the answer.

sections · Shape factor The point the rafter turns about, which is off the frame. A pitched portal of 8 m span and 4.0 m to the eaves, with a 1.5 m rise, collapsing. Each rigid part of the mechanism rotates about some point: the left column about its base hinge, the right about its own. The rafter between them does neither, and its centre is found by one rule — two bodies joined at a hinge share that hinge, so the second body's centre lies on the line through the first body's centre and the hinge, extended. Two hinges give two lines and they cross at (8.0, 11.0) metres, which is 5.5 m above the ridge and outside any drawing of the frame itself. From there the whole collapse is two ratios of lengths and no trigonometry: the load factor is 1.339. Flatten the roof and the centre descends; make the two lines parallel and it goes to infinity, which is the statement that the rafter translates instead of turning.

The point the mechanism turns about

A collapsing frame is a chain of rigid pieces, and every piece is rotating about some point. Find those points and the whole collapse load reads off two ratios of lengths, with no trigonometry anywhere — and for a pitched roof the point in question is well above the top of the drawing.

equilibrium · Instantaneous centre Six ways for one dowel to fail, and the capacity is the smallest. Johansen's single-shear mechanisms for a 12 mm dowel through 40 and 40 mm members, each drawn as the shape it is: the dowel straight and the timber crushing, the dowel rotating rigidly, one plastic hinge, then two. The capacity under each is that mechanism's own, and the joint's strength is the smallest — 5.02 kN by mode c, which is the dowel rotates rigidly and both members crush. That is the kinematic theorem of plasticity: every mechanism gives an upper bound and the true collapse is the lowest of them. The crushed timber is shaded, and the circles are plastic hinges in the steel.

The smallest of six failures

Everything else in this collection that fails does so in one way at a time. A dowel through timber does not — the wood can crush while the steel stays straight, or one plastic hinge can form in it, or two — and the capacity is the smallest of the six, which is the kinematic theorem of plasticity applied to a joint rather than to a frame.

connections · Dowel yield What the shape of a load in time is worth, for two load shapes. The peak displacement as a multiple of the static deflection, against the load's duration divided by the structure's natural period, for two load shapes: a load that rises linearly, then stays; a rectangular pulse, then nothing. The lines are closed forms and eight dots are the peak of a complete time integration of an oscillator of 0.300 s period under that load, agreeing with the line to within 0.19% everywhere.

The load that is over before it has moved

A blast delivers an enormous pressure for a few milliseconds. Everything else in this field asks what force a structure can carry; a load that has come and gone before the structure has travelled any distance is not asking that question, and the answer turns out to depend on the mass and the ductility with the strength barely in it.

dynamics · Blast The circle is searched for, and the first guess is 39 per cent optimistic. The same slope with 81 trial circles evaluated, each one through the toe and each one giving its own factor of safety. There is no equation whose solution is the answer: the slip surface is a shape the ground chooses, so the calculation is a search over shapes and the answer is the smallest number found — 1.191 against 1.650 for the circle a first guess puts through the toe from above the middle of the slope, which is 39 per cent optimistic. A slope analysis that reports one circle has reported nothing.

The surface that has to be searched for

Every other check in this collection is made at a section somebody drew. A slope has no section — the failure surface is a shape the ground chooses, so the calculation is a search over shapes, and the answer is the smallest number found rather than the solution of anything.

equilibrium · Slope stability

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Plastic hingeFree bodyCollapse loadDuctilityEquilibriumLoad pathAnisotropyBearingBlastCollapse mechanismConnection designDamping

All concepts