Depth

Ladders — page 5

A field says what an essay is about. A ladder says what else there is to say about it — the distinct arguments that stand against one idea, from the one that introduces it to the one that assumes all the others.
00.050.10.150.20.250.30.3501020304050overhang, as a fraction of the spanbest at 21% — peak 8.8sagging, mid-spanhogging, over the supportmoving the supports in by a third of the way halves the worst moment

Where to put the supports, which is not at the ends

Moving the supports of a uniformly loaded beam inward by about a fifth of its length halves the worst bending moment. The load has not changed and nor has the beam.

1 rung · internal-forces
free at one end10.8 mmno stressheld at both ends75.6 MPaheld by a spring of 100 kN/mm53.2 MPaE·α·ΔT = 210000 × 12×10⁻⁶ × 30 = 75.6 MPa, at every length

The movement nobody applied

A temperature change is the only load in this collection that a structure can decline. Let it move and it produces a movement with no stress; hold it and it produces a stress with no movement — and that stress contains no length, no area and no second moment, so a bracket and a bridge girder carry exactly the same one.

1 rung · deflection
56.8 kN13.6 kN49.6 kN120 kNthree legs · rank 3 · determinateΣV, ΣMx and ΣMy all close to 1e-14 kN

Six equations, and the drawing shows three

Ninety essays have taken place on a piece of paper, where equilibrium is three equations and a structure is a diagram. The real object has six, the extra three are the ones nobody writes down, and the difference between three legs and four is not a matter of degree.

1 rung · equilibrium
40 kNm26.7 kNm13.3 kNmthe step at the load is 40 kNm, and the diagram closes

The internal force with no diagram

A cut through a member reveals four things, and this collection has drawn diagrams for three of them. The fourth is a torque, it obeys exactly the same rules, and whether it exists at all can depend on a decision the designer is free to make.

1 rung · internal-forces
15.0 m²9.38 kN/m15.0 m²9.38 kN/m9.0 m²7.50 kN/m9.0 m²7.50 kN/m8 m6 m48.0 m² divided, 48.0 m² of panel — the division closes

The load a beam is given is a decision

Every beam calculation on this site so far has started with a load per metre, handed over as though it were a property of the beam. It is not. It is the answer to a prior question nobody draws, and two defensible answers to it differ by sixty per cent on the same floor.

1 rung · equilibrium
0.60.70.80.911.11.21.31.41.501020304050forcing frequency ÷ the structure's ownamplitude ÷ static deflectionno absorber — peak 503.0% absorber — peak 7.34a factor of 6.8, for 3.0% of the mass

The mass that helps by being late

Hang three per cent of a building's mass from a spring in its roof, tune the spring so the mass arrives a quarter-cycle behind the motion, and the peak response falls by a factor of seven. Nothing was strengthened and nothing was stiffened.

1 rung · dynamics
11.522.530.40.50.60.70.80.91long span ÷ short spanshare taken by the short strips6 × 8 m: 76.0%by 2 : 1 it is a one-way slab

The slab that spans both ways

A panel supported on four sides sends its load in two directions at once, and the share is decided by a fourth power — so a panel a third longer than it is wide has already stopped being a two-way slab in any useful sense. What it does at collapse is a different calculation with a different answer.

1 rung · structures
-0.6%-0.4%-0.2%0.2%0.4%0.6%-300-200-100100200300strainstress, N/mm²0.469% of the strain never came back

What is left when the load comes off

Unload a section that has yielded and it does not return to nothing. It returns to a self-equilibrating stress field it did not have before, a permanent set, and an elastic range wider than the one it started with.

1 rung · materials
00.511.522.533.540510152025forcing frequency ÷ natural frequencyforce out ÷ force in√2 — nothing gained, at any damping2% damping5% damping20% damping

The machine that shakes the building

Put a machine on springs to keep its vibration out of the floor, and below a frequency ratio of root two the springs make things worse. Every transmissibility curve ever drawn passes through exactly one at that ratio, whatever the damping — so a soft mount either works well or fails badly, with nothing in between.

1 rung · dynamics
real Mpeak 32.0a unit load, here and nowhere elseunit mM × marea ÷ EI = 213.33the unit load is the only place the question 'deflection where?' is asked

One deflection, without solving everything

To find how far one point of a structure moves, put an imaginary force of one unit there, multiply two moment diagrams together, and integrate. The answer arrives without ever solving for the deflected shape.

1 rung · deflection
024681012141618200123shedding frequency (Hz)1.2 m across · St 0.18 · 0.9 Hzlock-in6 m/s02468101214161820050100150200wind speed (m/s)cross-wind amplitude (mm)0.40% damping — Sc = 11.2, peak 180.94 mm

The wind that brings its own frequency

Every other load in this subject arrives at whatever rate it happens to arrive at. Vortex shedding arrives at a rate set by the wind speed — so for any chimney, mast or cable there is always a wind speed at which the shedding matches the structure exactly, and it is a breeze rather than a storm.

1 rung · dynamics
100 kNpeak 0.88Two points at maximum radiusthe radius rule finds the peak hereequal radius, stresses differ ×1

The corner that is not the worst point

Check the point furthest from the centroid. It is the standard rule for a weld group under an eccentric load, it is exactly right for some shapes, and for others it misses the peak by sixteen per cent — or picks one of four points it cannot tell apart whose stresses differ by two thirds.

1 rung · connections
0102030405060708090020406080100120140160angle between the weld and the load, degreescapacity, kN0° · 116.83 kN45° · 127.98 kN90° · 143.09 kN×1.22along

The weld that is stronger across than along

The same fillet weld, the same size, the same steel, carries twenty-two per cent more when the load runs across it than along it. The factor is exactly the square root of three over the square root of two, and it comes out of the yield criterion rather than out of a test.

1 rung · connections

All essays