Structural Engineering & Statics
where the load goes
Series

Pushover — the series

3 essays on one idea, from the one that introduces it to the one that assumes the rest.
  1. Where the demand crosses the capacity. Base shear against roof displacement for a eight-storey frame pushed with a triangular load pattern. It is elastic to 1994 kN, where the first storey reaches its shear capacity, and flattens as each of the others follows — 7 yield events in the order 3, 4, 2, 1, 5, 6, 7. The demand is a displacement rather than a force: the elastic spectrum at the building's own period of 0.93 s gives 173 mm, and the participation factor of 1.26 makes that 219 mm at roof level. Against an idealised yield of 70 mm that is a ductility demand of 3.10.

    Pushed over until it will not stand

    A structure in an earthquake is asked for a displacement rather than a force. A pushover answers a different question cheaply — how much base shear the frame has against how far its roof moves — and the whole art is in what happens when the two are laid over each other.

    part 1 · dynamics
  2. Where the drift went. Storey drift at the target displacement, for the same frame with and without a soft ground storey at 50 per cent of the others' stiffness and strength. The regular frame spreads 219 mm over every storey; the soft one reaches 266 mm and puts 5.58 per cent of it into the ground storey against 0.53 next to it — a concentration of 5.9 against 1.7. The roof goes 22 per cent further, and where that extra displacement lands is the whole of the difference between the two buildings.

    Weaker in one place, and better on every average

    Take an eight-storey frame and make its ground storey half as stiff and half as strong. Its ductility demand falls, its first mode carries more of the mass, and its period lengthens into a gentler part of the spectrum. Three global numbers all improve, and the building is the one that collapses.

    part 2 · dynamics
  3. Two capacity curves that agree, from two answers that do not. Base shear against roof drift for the same eight-storey frame with a soft ground storey, pushed with a fixed triangular pattern and with one recomputed from the tangent stiffness at every step. At a roof displacement of 426 mm they differ by 8.7 per cent — which is the number a capacity-spectrum procedure reads, and it is the number that is nearly the same. The storey drifts underneath these two curves differ by a factor of 3.8 at the fourth floor, and the drift is what the analysis was run for.

    The pattern that stopped describing the building

    A pushover analysis pushes with a load pattern chosen to resemble the first mode, and by the time the structure has done anything worth analysing it no longer has that mode. Recomputing the pattern as the frame softens changes the base shear by nine per cent and the drift at the fourth floor by a factor of four.

    part 3 · dynamics

All series