Structural Engineering & Statics
where the load goes
Concept

Portal frame — where it appears

A frame of two columns and a beam with rigid corners, which carries lateral load by bending rather than by triangulation. Its corners are where the moment is largest and where the haunch that carries it is added.

Named by 6 essays across 5 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

A portal frame swaying under 20 kN. A portal frame pushed sideways, solved by the stiffness method because statics cannot divide the load between two columns. The base shears come out at 10.0 and 10.0 and add to the applied 20; the peak moment is 22.2. The sway is drawn hugely exaggerated, and the moment diagram is plotted on each member's tension face.

The frame that leans, and what stops it

A rectangle of pinned bars folds flat. Make the corners rigid instead of adding a diagonal and it does not — which buys an unobstructed opening and costs bending in every member of it.

structures · Portal frame The moment does not stop at the end of the beam. A portal frame of 8 m by 4 m with fixed bases, carrying 20 kN/m on the beam. The bending moment is drawn on the tension side of every member, and it runs round the corner without a break: 65.2 kNm arrives at the end of the beam and 65.2 kNm leaves down the column, which is the same number, since joint rotational equilibrium is one of the equations the frame solve satisfied. Midspan carries 94.8 kNm, and the two add to 160.0 — the 160.0 kNm of a simply supported span, to 0.0e+0 kNm. The corner takes 61% of the wL²/12 a fully built-in beam would have carried, because the columns are springs rather than walls: the beam-to-column stiffness ratio is 1.27. The beam's moment crosses zero 0.92 m from the corner and the column's 1.33 m above its base.

The moment that goes round the corner

At a rigid knee the bending moment does not stop at the end of the beam. It turns and runs down the column, and in the same instant the beam's shear becomes the column's axial force — while the block of steel that has to carry the turn appears on no member diagram anywhere.

internal-forces · Corner moment The point the rafter turns about, which is off the frame. A pitched portal of 8 m span and 4.0 m to the eaves, with a 1.5 m rise, collapsing. Each rigid part of the mechanism rotates about some point: the left column about its base hinge, the right about its own. The rafter between them does neither, and its centre is found by one rule — two bodies joined at a hinge share that hinge, so the second body's centre lies on the line through the first body's centre and the hinge, extended. Two hinges give two lines and they cross at (8.0, 11.0) metres, which is 5.5 m above the ridge and outside any drawing of the frame itself. From there the whole collapse is two ratios of lengths and no trigonometry: the load factor is 1.339. Flatten the roof and the centre descends; make the two lines parallel and it goes to infinity, which is the statement that the rafter translates instead of turning.

The point the mechanism turns about

A collapsing frame is a chain of rigid pieces, and every piece is rotating about some point. Find those points and the whole collapse load reads off two ratios of lengths, with no trigonometry anywhere — and for a pitched roof the point in question is well above the top of the drawing.

equilibrium · Instantaneous centre The worst section of a haunched rafter is inside the haunch. Utilisation along a 15.3 m portal rafter carrying 8 kN/m, with an eaves moment of 500 kNm and an apex moment of 150, haunched over 3 m from 906 mm deep down to the rafter's own 453. The moment is largest at the eaves and the depth is largest there too, so the eaves is at 0.42; the apex is at 0.31. The peak is 0.46 at 2.98 m — the haunch tip, where the section has just become the bare rafter and the moment is still 226 kNm. The dashed curve is the same rafter with no haunch, which reaches 1.02 and does not pass.

The section that governs is inside the haunch

A tapered cantilever has its worst section somewhere along it because the moment grows linearly and the modulus quadratically. A haunched rafter has the same competition with a step in it, and the step is where the check lands — at neither end of the member, at a station no formula names.

sections · Tapered member A portal on a stepped base — the two passes added. Bending moments on a single-bay portal with columns of 5 m and 3.5 m under one horizontal beam of 9 m, carrying 10 kN/m down and 60 kN across, with fixed bases. This frame is the two passes added. The corner moments are 5.8 and 99.1 kNm, and the short column's top carries 17.01 times what the tall one does. The diagram is drawn on the tension side of each member.

Every joint balanced, and the frame still leaning

Moment distribution enforces one equation per joint, and a frame free to translate has one more equation than it has joints. So a table that balances perfectly can describe a structure held up by a prop nobody built — and finding the prop, then removing it, is a second pass whose unknown is a distance rather than a rotation.

deflection · Moment distribution The interior panel is designed by the case that designs nothing else. The shear across the column-web panel at each kind of joint of a frame of two 8 m bays and two 4 m storeys with fixed bases, 457 mm beams and 254 mm columns with 8.6 mm webs, under five load cases, the worse direction of sway taken where there is one. Full gravity: roof corner 106, roof interior 0, floor exterior 143, floor interior 0 kN; One bay loaded: roof corner 115, roof interior 117, floor exterior 150, floor interior 154 kN; Sway: roof corner 25, roof interior 40, floor exterior 53, floor interior 89 kN; Gravity + sway: roof corner 131, roof interior 40, floor exterior 196, floor interior 89 kN; Pattern + sway: roof corner 141, roof interior 157, floor exterior 203, floor interior 242 kN. The floor interior panel is empty under full gravity and carries 89 kN under gravity with sway, the case that governs the members; under one bay loaded with sway it carries 242 kN — 2.7 times as much, more than any exterior panel's 203 kN, and 70 per cent of the web's shear resistance.

The panel that gravity leaves empty

A corner joint's panel carries the difference between a beam's flange couple and half a column's shear, and full gravity load is what makes that large. An interior joint has a beam on each side, and under full gravity their two couples cancel: the panel between them carries nothing at all, in the load case that sizes every member around it. It fills under the two loads that are not symmetric. A pattern load hands it one beam's moment, and sway hands it two beams' moments turning the same way. Together they put more shear through it than through any exterior joint, in a combination that governs no member.

internal-forces · Corner moment

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

SwayEquilibriumFree bodyHaunchMoment connectionMoment diagramPanel zonePlastic hingeBending momentBound theoremsCarry-overCollapse load

All concepts