Structural Engineering & Statics
where the load goes
Concept

Modal combination — where it appears

The rule that turns the separate peak responses of a structure's modes into one design value, because the peaks do not occur at the same instant. The square root of the sum of squares assumes the modes are independent; the complete quadratic combination adds a cross term whose sign is the sign of the two contributions.

Named by 3 essays across one field — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

Buildings that sway alike need almost no gap between them. The separation two adjacent buildings need, against the ratio of their periods. The obvious answer is the sum of what each can do — 340 mm — and it is wrong, because the two peaks do not occur at the same instant. The right combination is the one modal responses use, √(u₁² + u₂² − 2ρu₁u₂), with ρ the cross-correlation coefficient of the two responses. ρ depends on the period ratio and behaves the opposite way to intuition: at a ratio of one the two buildings sway together, ρ = 1, and the gap collapses to the difference of the two, 100 mm. At the 0.57 drawn ρ is 0.029 and the gap is 248 mm — 27 per cent less than the sum, and 99 per cent of the square root of the sum of squares.

The gap between two buildings

Two towers side by side in an earthquake need a gap. The obvious answer is the sum of what each can move, and it is wrong — because the two peaks do not happen at the same instant. What decides the answer is the ratio of the two periods, and buildings that sway alike need almost no gap at all.

dynamics · Pounding The cross term has the sign of the two contributions. Four responses of the floor, each combined three ways and divided by the complete quadratic combination at ρ = 0.50. Base shear: modal 927 and 839 kN, so the root-sum-square is 0.82 of it and the absolute sum 1.15. Base torque: modal -8640 and 8640 kNm, so the root-sum-square is 1.41 of it and the absolute sum 2.00. Flexible edge: modal 60 and -6 mm, so the root-sum-square is 1.05 of it and the absolute sum 1.15. Stiff edge: modal -5 and 47 mm, so the root-sum-square is 1.05 of it and the absolute sum 1.15. Where the two modes push the same way the root-sum-square is short; where they push opposite ways it is long.

The twist the combination rule invents

Two modes close together respond together, and the square root of the sum of squares assumes they do not. The error has the sign of the two modal contributions: where they agree, as they do in base shear, the rule comes up short, and where they oppose, as they always do in torque, it comes up long — by a factor of five for a floor whose stiffness sits twenty centimetres off its mass, a torque the building does not have.

dynamics · Mode shapes A mode that points wherever the asymmetry points. A square floor 24 m on a side, equally stiff in both directions, with a period of 0.80 s. Four copies are drawn on top of each other, each made stiffer by one part in 1,000,000 along a different direction: 0°, 20°, 45°, 70°. The first mode each one returns lies along 90°, 110°, 135°, 160° — at right angles to its stiffening, whatever the size of it — and the two periods differ by one part in 1,000,000. Four structures no instrument could tell apart have first modes pointing four different ways. The floor with no asymmetry at all has no first mode: every direction is one.

Two modes that are really a plane

A building equally stiff in both directions has two translational modes with one period, and they are not a pair of shapes but a whole plane of them. The pair an analysis returns is chosen by asymmetries of a millionth, so any result that depends on the pair — a square-root combination, a comparison with measured modes — inherits a choice the building never made. Damping then decides whether the difference can be seen at all.

dynamics · Mode shapes

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Natural periodDampingModal analysisMode shapeOrthogonalityResponse spectrumEccentricityEigenvalueFrequency responseImpactLoad pathModal mass

All concepts