Structural Engineering & Statics
where the load goes
Concept

Flat slab — where it appears

A slab supported directly on columns with no beams between them. The load reaches the columns through the slab's own two-way bending and the shear round the column perimeter. Its total moment between supports is fixed by statics and only its distribution across the panel is a matter of stiffness.

Named by 10 essays across 3 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

A check made on a perimeter, not on a section. One bay of a flat slab, 7.2 m square, on a 400 × 400 mm column. The heavy closed line is the control perimeter, 2d from the column face with its corners rounded at that radius — 4427 mm long against 1600 mm round the column itself. The shaded area inside it delivers no shear across it and is subtracted from the load; everything outside arrives through the perimeter. At 12 kN/m² that is 604 kN across 4427 × 225 mm, a shear stress of 0.606 N/mm² against a resistance of 0.658.

A check made on a perimeter, not on a section

Every shear check in this collection is made on a plane cut through a member. A slab sitting on a column has no such plane, because the shear leaves in every direction at once — so the check is made on a closed line, and a line grows with the column while the load grows with the square of the bay.

internal-forces · Punching shear Two of these move and the third cannot. The first span of a 3-span beam under 5 kN/m, with the stiffness of the middle span swept over a factor of 25. The support moment and the mid-span moment both move — that is what redundancy does, and it is the whole reason a continuous beam has to be analysed rather than read off. Their combination does not: the mid-span ordinate plus the average of the two end moments is 30.6 kNm at every point on this axis, which is wL²/8 for this span and this load and contains nothing else. The largest departure anywhere on the sweep is 2.3e-16 of the value, which is the arithmetic of the stiffness solution rather than a property of the beam. Continuity buys a distribution and not a capacity, and this is the line that says so.

Two of these move and the third cannot

Cut one span of a continuous beam free and add up the forces on it. What comes out is that the mid-span moment plus the average of the two end moments equals the free bending moment of that span, with nothing else in it — no stiffness, no support settlement, no analysis at all. Continuity moves moment about. It does not reduce the total, and it never has.

internal-forces · Static moment A check made on a perimeter, not on a section. One bay of a flat slab, 7.2 m square, on a 400 × 400 mm column. The heavy closed line is the control perimeter, 2d from the column face with its corners rounded at that radius — 4427 mm long against 1600 mm round the column itself. The shaded area inside it delivers no shear across it and is subtracted from the load; everything outside arrives through the perimeter. At 12 kN/m² that is 604 kN across 4427 × 225 mm, a shear stress of 0.697 N/mm² against a resistance of 0.658.

Turn the column, and the slab passes

A flat slab that is comfortable under gravity fails its punching check the moment a moment arrives at the column, and nothing about the load has changed. The fix is not more concrete. It is the column's plan shape and, at equal area, which way round it is turned — worth more than adding half again as much column.

internal-forces · Punching shear More props, heavier slabs — unless they go in after the weight. The heaviest load any slab carries during construction, as a multiple of its own weight, against the number of levels of props under the slab being cast. Every level a shore that carried the wet concrete and moves up with the formwork: 2.00, 2.25, 2.37, 2.44 w for one to four levels. One level of shores and the rest backprops, put in snug after the formwork is struck: 2.00, 1.50, 1.33, 1.25 w. The same number of props, differently timed: a shore enters the load path before the weight it carries and passes it down, and a backprop enters after and shares only what arrives later.

Loaded twice over before it is a month old

A concrete floor in a building going up a storey a week carries, in its first weeks, the wet weight of the floors being cast above it, handed down through the props. By Grundy and Kabaila's arithmetic that is twice its own weight on a single level of shores, and more with more levels — 2.25 on two, 2.37 on three — because every prop that carried wet concrete passes its load down the stack. The same props put in after the formwork is struck carry nothing until something new arrives, and the peak falls to 1.5, 1.33, 1.25. The heaviest day of a floor's life is decided by when its props went in, not how many there are.

materials · Maturity The perimeter the edge leaves, and where its middle is. A 400 × 400 mm column at the edge of a 260 mm slab (d = 225 mm) carrying 12 kN/m², on a 7.2 m end span. Heavy line: the control perimeter 2d out, cut by the slab's edge — 2,614 mm, against 4,427 for the same column inside the slab. Wide band beneath it: the reduced perimeter u1 of EN 1992-1-1, 2,214 mm, its legs cut back from the edge. Open circle: the perimeter's centroid, 363 mm in from the column's centre. Filled: the load's resultant, 631 mm in, set by the slab's end moment of 170 kN·m on a shear of 269 kN — 269 mm beyond it, into the slab. The general multiplier on the shear is 1.78; u1/u1 gives 1.18 and the shortcut 1.4.

The perimeter whose middle is not the column's

At an edge column the slab's own edge cuts the control perimeter, and what is left has its centroid 363 mm inside the column's centre. The slab's end moment moves the shear's resultant inward too, by a distance that grows with the end span. What twists the perimeter is the gap between the two: nothing at a 5 m end span, enough by 7.2 m to put the check at 1.23 of its resistance where the 1.4 shortcut reads 0.97. And a bigger column makes it worse.

internal-forces · Punching shear The studs reach out to where the concrete is enough. One column of a 260 mm flat slab (d = 225 mm) carrying 12 kN/m² on 400 × 400 mm internal columns, the moment it hands the column putting the shear 300 mm off centre, on a 10.0 m bay, to scale. The inner check, on the control perimeter 2d out (solid), needs reinforcement: 12 rails of studs, 6 perimeters of them from 0.5d at 0.75d spacing, 1,415 mm² on each perimeter. The outer perimeter (dashed), where the concrete alone carries the shear, stands 5.4d from the face — 9,173 mm long against the control perimeter's 4,427 — and the last studs must be within 1.5d inside it, 3.9d from the face.

The studs that send the check outward

Shear studs round a column fix a failing punching check, and they turn one check into three. The studs carry the control perimeter; past them the concrete alone must carry a perimeter long enough to need no help, and that outer perimeter stands further from the column the larger the load, so the studs follow it out. At a 10 m bay they reach four effective depths from the face, and the steel they need grows as the shear to the power 3.5. The third check, at the column face, is the one no stud reaches, and it ends the series at 11.8 m.

internal-forces · Punching shear Where in a slab's first month its heaviest load lands. The load on the sixth floor of a frame of 250 mm slabs on a 7.5 m grid cast a floor every 7 days at 20 °C, on one level of shores and one of backprops, as a multiple of its own weight, against its age. Rigid and snug, no creep: a peak of 1.51 w at 14 days; steel springs and creep: a peak of 1.71 w at 21 days; the same, 1.0 mm of slack: a peak of 1.78 w at 7 days. Snug and rigid, the slab carries its heaviest load twice, a week apart, as the struck slab and then as the one below it. With creep the second is the heavier, because in the intervening week the slab above has sunk onto the backprops; with slack, the first.

The backprop that takes load nobody gave it

The arithmetic of propped construction says a backprop put in snug carries nothing until the next floor is cast, and then only a share of it. Count the props as the springs they are and that barely changes, because a steel prop is about seven times stiffer than the slab per square metre. Two other things change it. The young slab just struck creeps onto its backprops within a day and hands a quarter of a slab's weight down to the one below, which then carries 1.71 times its weight rather than 1.5. And a millimetre of slack at installation — about half the slab's own deflection — gives the struck slab back everything a backprop was meant to save.

materials · Maturity The shadow an opening casts on every perimeter. One column of a 260 mm flat slab (d = 225 mm) carrying 12 kN/m² on 400 × 400 mm columns, the shear 300 mm off centre, on a 10.0 m bay, to scale, with a 300 × 300 mm opening 225 mm (1.0d) from the column. The two tangents from the column's centre to the opening's corners (dashed) enclose 38.9 degrees, and every perimeter loses the part between them: 458 mm of the control perimeter 2d out (solid), 1,093 mm of the outer perimeter (dashed), the lost parts drawn faint. With the opening the outer perimeter stands 6.13d from the face instead of 5.36d, and the studs need 7 perimeters instead of 6; one of the 12 rails runs into the hole.

A hole takes a tenth of every perimeter

A 300 mm riser cut a slab's depth from a column throws a shadow from the column's centre, and EN 1992-1-1 deletes whatever part of a punching perimeter falls inside it. The outer perimeter, being longest, loses the most length — but it loses the same share as the control perimeter, a tenth of each, because the shadow is an angle. The cost arrives somewhere less obvious: a seventh ring of studs, 24 per cent more steel, and studs needed in a bay a third of a metre shorter than before.

internal-forces · Punching shear The water that rises after the basement is finished pushes on its slab first. Section through a line of columns of a 20 × 30 m basement dug 9 m, its 0.9 m slab held down at six columns and by 8 storeys above, designed for a water table 3 m below the ground. The water table as designed is 3 m below the ground, a 6 m head under the slab; dashed, the same water risen 1.0 m. The slab bows up between its columns and walls under the uplift less its own weight (exaggerated). As designed, the building holds itself down at 0.65 of its weight's capacity, the slab is at 0.37 of its bending strength and its cracks are 0.140 mm against the 0.200 mm long set for every crack in concrete that must keep water out. With the water 1.0 m higher: 0.76, 0.45, and 0.176 mm against the same 0.200.

The basement that leaks before it floats

A water table that rises after a basement is finished is a load that grows through the building's life, and the building's flotation check is the last thing it troubles. A metre of rise adds a sixth to the uplift on the whole building but over a quarter to the net load on the slab, which carries the water less its own weight. The slab's cracks, which a watertight basement is designed to, are the first thing to run out of room — and the limit for the cracks that pass right through it tightens as the water rises.

equilibrium · Uplift A core drilled into a slab the studs were laid out for without it. One column of a 260 mm flat slab (d = 225 mm) carrying 12 kN/m² on 400 × 400 mm columns, the shear 300 mm off centre, on a 10.0 m bay, to scale, its studs laid out for the slab without a hole — six rings of 14 mm studs on twelve rails, the last ring 4.25d from the face — and a 150 mm core 225 mm (1.00d) from the face. Its shadow from the column's centre takes 20.3 degrees of every perimeter. The studs' outer perimeter stands where the last ring leaves it, 5.75d out (solid); with the core the slab needs it at 5.74d (dashed), so the outer check is at 1.00 of its capacity, and the control check's studs at 0.79. No rail runs into it.

The core drilled after the slab was built

A building in use acquires new services, and a core drilled through a flat slab beside a column is a routine instruction. The studs round the column were laid out for a slab without the hole, and the drill finds whatever is there. Whether it cuts a stud matters less than it looks. What decides is the outer perimeter, which the hole pushes outward while the studs stay where they are, and whether the slab survives is set by a margin nobody chose: the room left when the studs were rounded up to a stock size and the rings to a whole number.

internal-forces · Punching shear

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Control perimeterEffective depthPunching shearBrittle failureEccentricityShear reinforcementBackproppingConstruction sequenceEarly-age strengthLoad sharingProgressive collapsePropping

All concepts