Structural Engineering & Statics
where the load goes
Concept

Erection stability — where it appears

The stability of a structure in the states it passes through while being built, in which restraints are missing and the load has fallen by less than the capacity. The bracing that will hold the structure up is not there yet, so the governing case for a member is frequently a state that exists for a single afternoon.

Named by 3 essays across 2 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

Whether the floor shares the load out by stiffness or by area. The share of a uniform storey force taken by each of three equally stiff walls, against the stiffness of the floor plate that spans between them. A plate far stiffer than the walls translates almost rigidly, every wall deflects the same and the share is the ratio of stiffnesses — 60% to the middle wall here, the same as everyone else. A plate far softer than the walls behaves as a continuous beam over them and the middle wall takes 33%. Neither end is the tributary-area answer of 50%, which assumes a plate that is both soft and discontinuous over the wall, and which nothing here ever reaches.

The floor is a beam lying down

A floor plate spans horizontally between the walls that resist a lateral load, carries a distributed inertia load, and has chords, a web and a span-to-depth ratio like any other beam. Its stiffness decides whether the walls share the load by their stiffness or by the area of floor nearest them — and the familiar tributary answer turns out to be neither limit.

structures · Diaphragm How stiff a brace has to be before the frame stops swaying. The effective length factor of a swaying portal against the stiffness of a horizontal spring at its head. The curve starts at k = 1.317, the unbraced value, and falls to 0.774 — the factor for the same frame with its head held — at a brace stiffness of 23.2 EI/L³. Past that point the frame buckles in the non-sway mode, which the brace does not restrain, and further stiffness buys nothing at all. The threshold is worth stating as 1.41 N꜀ᵣ/L, which is the form the number is memorable in: for a storey carrying a thousand kilonewtons over four metres it is about 0.35 kN per millimetre of sway. Against the frame's own lateral stiffness of 12.0 EI/L³ it is a factor of 1.93.

The most dangerous day is before it is finished

A structure is analysed once, complete, with every restraint present. It spends weeks in states nobody drew — a beam landed with no deck on it holds 17% of the moment its section is worth, a frame not yet braced buckles at a third of the load it will, and a bolt not yet tightened is a pin where the analysis assumed a fixity.

stability · Erection stability A fourth power, and then a cliff. The factor of safety against rolling, against beam length, for one section hung from a roll axis 0.9 m above its centre of gravity. Nothing about the section changes along this axis. z̄ goes as the fourth power of the length — 0.236 m at 30 m becomes 0.747 m at 40 — and the factor of safety is proportional to (y_r − z̄), so it does not decline gently: it falls away and then stops existing. The working factor of 1.5 is lost at about 41 m, and past 42 m there is no hook height at all at which this beam hangs stably. Which is why long girders are lifted with the picks moved inboard, or with the beam braced, or not in one piece.

Hung from above and still unstable

A rigid body hanging from a point above its centre of gravity is a pendulum and cannot fall over. A beam is not rigid, and tilting it puts a component of its own weight sideways — which bows it, which moves its centre of gravity further out. Past a length there is no hook height at which it hangs stably at all, and the length arrives as a fourth power.

stability · Lift stability

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Temporary worksAccidental eccentricityBracingCentre of gravityCentre of rigidityChord forceCollectorConstruction sequenceDeep beamDiaphragmEffective lengthEquilibrium

All concepts