Structural Engineering & Statics
where the load goes
Concept

Compression flange — where it appears

The flange a bending moment puts into compression, and the one that decides where a beam has to be braced against buckling sideways. It is a column with nothing holding it sideways, so where it is restrained and how stiffly decides the beam's capacity rather than the section's own strength.

Named by 7 essays across one field — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

The length at which a beam stops being a beam. Elastic critical moment against the distance between lateral restraints, with the section's plastic capacity drawn across it. The two cross at 3803 — beyond that length the beam buckles sideways before it reaches the strength its cross-section has, and the capacity is set by the restraints rather than by the steel.

The beam that fails sideways

A deep narrow beam bending in its strong plane can, at a moment well below its capacity, swing out of that plane and twist. The failure has nothing to do with how much it can carry and everything to do with what is holding it.

stability · Lateral-torsional A brace on the wrong flange never gets there, however stiff it is. The critical moment of an 8 m beam against the stiffness of a single midspan brace, drawn three times for the three heights the brace could sit at. On the compression flange it climbs from 143 kNm to the two-half-wave plateau of 447 — the beam braced into two 4.0 m beams — and reaches 99% of it at 447 kN/m. At the shear centre it needs 2252 kN/m, 5.0 times as much. On the tension flange it never arrives at all: at the stiffness that would have done the job on the other flange it has bought a factor of 1.068, and a stiffer brace in the same place buys the same nothing. Past the plateau the beam stops using the brace, which is where the idea of an ideal stiffness comes from.

The brace on the wrong flange

A brace on a column has one property that matters, and it is stiffness. A brace on a beam has two, and the second decides whether the first is worth anything: put the identical restraint on the tension flange and it does not reach the answer at any stiffness whatever.

stability · Beam bracing The restraint chooses the buckling length, and it is not the member's. A compression flange 12 m long held sideways not at points but everywhere, by a restraint of 0.35 N/mm per mm of length. Unrestrained it would buckle at 173 kN in a single half-wave, drawn faintly. Restrained it buckles at 1968 kN — 11.4 times as much — in two half-waves, because the sum n²π²EI/L² + kL²/n²π² has its minimum there and every other n is worse. The effective length that answer implies is 3555 mm, which is 0.30 of the member and is a property of the restraint rather than of the span.

Held everywhere, and it forgets its length

A brace at a point divides a member's buckling length. A restraint spread along the whole member does something else — the member chooses its own number of half-waves, and past a few of them the critical load stops depending on the length at all.

stability · Continuous restraint The length at which a beam stops being a beam. Elastic critical moment against the distance between lateral restraints, with the section's plastic capacity drawn across it. The two cross at 4086 — beyond that length the beam buckles sideways before it reaches the strength its cross-section has, and the capacity is set by the restraints rather than by the steel.

The load that moves with the twist

A beam about to buckle sideways is beginning to rotate, and everything attached to it rotates with it. A load hung from the top flange swings out over the side and drives the rotation on; the same load hung underneath swings back and stops it. Two identical beams, two different capacities, and the only difference is a height.

stability · Load height What a torsional brace buys, and the stiffness it takes. The critical moment of an 8 m beam against the stiffness of a single rotational restraint at midspan — a cross-frame or a stiffened connection to a secondary beam, resisting the twist rather than the sideways movement. It climbs from an unbraced 143 kNm to the same two-half-wave plateau of 447 a lateral brace reaches, and gets to 99% of it at 253 kNm/rad. Nothing in the calculation refers to a height, which is the difference that matters: a torsional brace cannot be put on the wrong flange because it is not attached to a flange in the sense the lateral one is.

Twice the moment, four times the brace

A lateral brace has to be on the right flange and its demand is very nearly linear in the load. A torsional brace has no flange to be wrong about, and its demand is exactly quadratic — so the restraint that is indifferent to where it is attached is the one that gets expensive fastest.

stability · Beam bracing The coefficient a web gets depends on where its neutral axis is. The plate buckling coefficient for an internal element against ψ = σ₂/σ₁, the ratio of the stresses at the two edges of the panel. Uniform compression is ψ = 1 and k = 4; a gradient running from compression to zero is ψ = 0 and k = 7.81; pure bending is ψ = −1 and k = 23.92, six times the value a column's flange gets. The 1800 × 12 mm web drawn here starts at ψ = −1.000 and k = 23.92 and ends at ψ = −0.910 and k = 21.63, because losing width from the compressed half drops the neutral axis and deepens the compression zone. The curve is steepest exactly where a bending web sits, so a small movement of the neutral axis costs 2.29 of coefficient.

Classified by a gradient it does not have

A web in bending is the one plate whose buckling coefficient cannot be looked up. It depends on the stress gradient, the gradient depends on where the neutral axis is, and the neutral axis depends on how much of the web the coefficient has just taken away — so the answer is a fixed point, and the calculation everyone does is its first term.

stability · Plate buckling At the tip it is the tension flange that swings. The buckled shape of a 3.00 m cantilever of 457 mm universal beam carrying a load at its tip at the shear centre, root built in: slope and warping held, seen from above: the sideways movement of the top flange and of the bottom flange along the length, scaled so the larger is one. The cantilever hogs, so its bottom flange is in compression, and that flange bows out furthest 0.58 of the way from the root, where it moves 0.15 — and has come back to 0.00 by the tip. The top flange, in tension, swings out to the full 1.00 at the tip. The section twists as it goes, so the flange that is doing the buckling is not the flange that moves most at the end. Critical moment at the root: 1266 kN·m.

The flange that swings is in tension

A cantilever hogs, so its bottom flange is the one in compression and the one that buckles. At its tip the bottom flange barely moves: the section turns about it, and the flange that swings out is the top one, in tension. So the restraint that matters at a cantilever's tip is on the flange every rule for spans calls the wrong one — and the root, which a drawing shows as a single line, moves the critical moment by a factor of thirty-four.

stability · Moment gradient

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Lateral-torsional bucklingWarpingBracingCritical momentEffective lengthEigenvalueImperfectionCritical loadLateral restraintPlate girderShear centreBrace

All concepts