Structural Engineering & Statics
where the load goes
Depth

Series — page 8

A field says what an essay is about. A series follows one idea essay by essay — from the question that introduces it to the one that assumes all the others.
The two braces balance until one of them buckles. An inverted-V brace after the compression member has gone. While both braces are elastic they carry equal and opposite forces and their vertical components cancel on the beam above, which is why the beam in a chevron bay is usually sized for gravity alone. The compression brace buckles at 445 kN and then sheds most of what it was carrying — 30% is left here — while the tension brace goes on to yield at 1065. The difference between the two vertical components is 659 kN, applied at the middle of the span with no help from either brace, and it asks the beam for 1317 kNm against the 200 kNm the gravity load asks for — 6.6 times as much. The beam drawn does not: 1517 kNm against a capacity of 731. The force is not a load case anybody applies; it is what the frame leaves behind on its way to the state it will actually be in.

Chevron brace

  1. 1 The force the brace leaves behind
1 essay · structures A force may be moved anywhere, at the price of a couple. A 80 kN force applied 250 mm off the centreline of a body, and the same force applied ON the centreline together with a couple of 20 kNm. The two systems are equivalent: they have the same resultant force and the same moment about every point in space, so no equilibrium equation written about the body can tell them apart. What they are not is the same loading — the stresses inside the body differ, and they differ over a distance of about the body's own depth. The offset is drawn to a scale that keeps the arrow on the body; the number beside it is the real one.

Column eccentricity

  1. 1 The moment the beam left behind
1 essay · internal-forces A joint is springs in series. The five components of an end-plate joint, with each bar the flexibility it contributes. The column flange in bending is 39.62% of the total on its own, and doubling its stiffness raises the joint's by a factor of 1.25 — while doubling the stiffest component buys 1.05. The joint's rotational stiffness is 25227.71 kN·m per radian.

Component method

  1. 1 A joint made of springs in series
1 essay · connections The same concrete, held sideways. Two stress-strain curves for one concrete. The lower is a cylinder test: it peaks at 30 N/mm² near a strain of 0.002 and has nothing left by 0.0035, because it fails by splitting apart sideways. The upper is the same material inside a 12 mm hoop at 100 mm centres, which cannot stop it expanding but can make the expansion stretch steel: the lateral pressure of 2.48 N/mm² — 8% of the strength it is multiplying — takes the peak to 44.4 and the ultimate strain to 0.028. The strength gain is 1.48 times and the strain gain 8.0; the area under the curve, which is the toughness, goes up by 11. It is the third number the confinement is provided for.

Confinement

  1. 1 Squeezed sideways into a different material
1 essay · materials The same curve, computed twice and from opposite ends. A cantilever of 6 m, with its deflected shape drawn from a double integration of M/EI and the bending moment of its conjugate beam drawn on top of it. The conjugate is the same span carrying M/EI as a load, with its supports transformed — a real fixed end becomes a free end and a real free end becomes a fixed one, because a fixed end has no slope and no deflection and the conjugate therefore needs no shear and no moment there. The two curves agree to 4.7e-6 of the largest deflection, which is the trapezium rule and not the method. The largest deflection is 36.00 mm against the closed form's 36.00. The reaction of the conjugate beam is -9.000 milliradians, which is the real beam's rotation at that support — so the whole of a slope calculation is one reaction.

Conjugate beam

  1. 1 The beam whose moment is a deflection
1 essay · deflection A bolt group under an eccentric load. A 3 by 2 bolt group carrying 100 kN at 150 mm from its centroid, with the resultant force on each bolt drawn to scale, by the elastic vector method. The load is shared equally and the torque is not, so the worst bolt carries 50.37 kN against 16.67 kN of direct shear alone — 3.02 times as much.

Connection design

  1. 1 The connection is not a point, and every diagram so far says it is
1 essay · connections The props decide where the stress ends up. Bottom-fibre stress in the steel of a 12 m composite beam carrying 12 kN/m of wet concrete and 18 kN/m afterwards. Unpropped, the bare steel takes the first stage alone and reaches 292 MPa; propped, the finished composite section takes everything and reaches 186 MPa — a ratio of 1.57. 62% of the unpropped beam's final stress was locked in before the slab was structural at all. The deflections differ by 1.73 times for the same reason, and no drawing of the finished beam distinguishes the two.

Construction sequence

  1. 1 The structure that was never complete
1 essay · structures 3 continuous spans against 3 simple ones. The bending moment in a continuous beam, solved by the stiffness method, drawn over the moment in the same spans made simply supported. The peak sagging moment falls from 30.6 to 19.6, and a hogging moment of 24.5 appears over the supports where there was none.

Continuity

  1. 1 The moment over the support, and what it buys
1 essay · internal-forces Cover enters twice, and the strength of the concrete enters once. How long a 20 mm bar has before the cover over it splits, against the cover, split into the two halves it is always split into. Initiation is the time for the chloride front to reach the bar, which goes as the square of the cover — Fick's law and nothing else — and it is 9.1 years at 35 mm and 36.2 at 70. Propagation is the time from there to a split cover, which is short: 0.9 years, because the cover cracks at a section loss of 0.21% and no strength check in this collection would notice a loss that small. The pressure the cover can take grows with the cover too, so cover appears in both terms and the concrete's own tensile strength appears in one of them, linearly. That asymmetry is why every durability clause in every code is about cover and crack width, and hardly at all about strength.

Corrosion

  1. 1 The load that comes from inside
1 essay · materials Pull it along the girder and it just unfolds. One period of a 30° trapezoidal corrugation, 300 mm of flat and 260 mm of incline, and the same period pulled along the girder's axis. The fold opens by bending the inclined panels out of the web's own plane, so the axial flexibility contains the plate's t³ where a flat web's would contain t — and the effective modulus that comes back from solving the cell as a frame is 222 N/mm², which is 10.6 parts in ten thousand of the steel's 210 GPa. A web with a thousandth of the stiffness carries a thousandth of the stress, which is why the flanges of a corrugated girder carry the whole moment and why the section has 9 per cent less second moment than the flat-webbed girder it replaces. The fold buys freedom from stiffeners and pays for it here.

Corrugated web

  1. 1 The web that carries no bending
1 essay · sections Balanced, and four times as heavy on the bearing. A bascule leaf of 900 kN whose centroid is 9 m from the trunnion, balanced by 2700 kN at 3 m on the other side. What balancing achieves is exactly one thing: the moment about the pivot is zero at every opening angle, because both terms carry the same cosine. What it costs is two things that are not zero. The reaction on the trunnion becomes 4.0 times the leaf's own weight, since both weights are still there. And the rotational inertia rises by 33%, so the balanced leaf is the hardest one to start and to stop — which is why the counterweight is put as close to the pivot as it will fit, at the price of being heavy: the same balance at twice the radius weighs 1350 kN and carries 1.25 times the inertia.

Counterweight

  1. 1 Balanced, and four times as heavy
1 essay · equilibrium The same steel, and a crack three times as wide. Calculated crack width against bar diameter, with the area of steel held at 1340 mm² per metre throughout — so the spacing changes with the square of the diameter and the amount of reinforcement does not change at all. The width runs from 0.173 mm at 8 mm bars to 0.372 at 25, a factor of 2.15 for identical steel. The reason is in the crack spacing: after a crack forms the bar has to re-anchor the concrete's tensile force before the next one can, and the length that takes is proportional to the bar's diameter. Of the 337 mm spacing drawn, 35% is the cover term and 65% is the bar term — and the cover term is the one that puts crack control and durability in opposition, because cover protects the bar and widens the crack that reaches it.

Crack width

  1. 1 The same steel, and a wider crack
1 essay · sections The deflection goes on growing, and sometimes it does not stop. Second-order deflection of a sustained-loaded concrete column against age, on a log time axis. Creep takes the effective modulus down, which takes the buckling load down with it — from 11580 kN on the day to 3309 in the long term, 29 per cent of it — so the amplifier 1/(1 − N/N_cr) grows even though nothing was added to the load. At 2200 kN the column settles: 25 mm of eccentricity on the day and 60 mm at the end, a factor of 2.4 for a load that never changed. At 5294 kN — still only 46 per cent of the day-one critical load — it does not settle, and the divergence arrives at 55 days for no new reason at all.

Creep buckling

  1. 1 The column that fails years later
1 essay · stability The damping a crowd leaves behind, and the number of people that uses it up. Total damping ratio against pedestrians, for a structure with 0.60% of its own and a modal mass of 120 tonnes at 0.5 Hz. Each person walking laterally puts a force in phase with the deck's velocity into it — about 300 N·s/m per person — so the crowd subtracts from the damping, and at 30.16 people what is left is nothing. Below the threshold a disturbance dies away. Above it, the structure feeds itself and the motion grows out of nothing at all — which is what makes this a different mechanism from resonance rather than a severe case of it.

Crowd synchronisation

  1. 1 The bridge that was pushed by its own sway
1 essay · dynamics Where a bar may stop, and how far past there it goes anyway. The tension the bottom steel must carry along a 9 m beam, and the resistance of the bars actually present, drawn as a staircase. The demand is the moment diagram divided by the lever arm and then SHIFTED 270 mm toward midspan, because the truss inside the beam delivers its shear diagonally — the two constructions agree to 0.36 per cent, which is the second-order term and nothing else. Each curtailed layer then runs a further 1150 mm to develop, so the outer layer stops at 245 mm rather than the 1665 mm the moment diagram allows. The tail is 1420 mm at each end — 16 per cent of the span — and it is what turns a 20 per cent saving into 2.2.

Curtailment

  1. 1 Where a bar may stop
1 essay · sections Every pressure points at the pin, so the water lifts nothing. A radial gate of radius 8 m holding 6 m of water, with its pivot 6 m above the sill. The pressure on a curved surface cannot be obtained by multiplying anything by anything, so it is integrated round the arc: the horizontal component comes to 176.6 kN/m and the vertical to 110.5. Both are recoverable without any integral at all — the horizontal is the pressure force on the surface's own vertical projection, γH²/2 = 176.6, and the vertical is the weight of the water standing above it, 110.5. They agree to 0.000 per cent. And because every pressure is normal to a circle, every one of them passes through the centre: the moment of the whole 208 kN/m about the pivot is -3.4e-15 kNm, against 353 for a flat gate on the same hinge.

Curved surface pressure

  1. 1 Every pressure points at the pin
1 essay · equilibrium How much a harmonic force is magnified, at four damping ratios. Displacement amplitude divided by the deflection the same force would produce if it were applied slowly, against the ratio of the forcing frequency to the structure's own, at 1%, 2%, 5%, 10% of critical damping. At the natural frequency the magnification is 50, 25, 10, 5 respectively — one over twice the damping ratio, and nothing else in the problem enters it.

Damping

  1. 1 The only thing that stops it
1 essay · dynamics Deflection goes as the fourth power of the span. Deflection against span for a constant load intensity and section, with two slower relationships drawn faintly behind it for comparison: the load itself, which grows in proportion to the span, and the bending moment, which grows as its square. Doubling the span multiplies the deflection by sixteen, while the moment only quadruples.

Dead load

  1. 1 The weight that has to be known before it can be found
1 essay · equilibrium Half the beam does nearly all of the deflecting. The virtual-work integrand M·m/EI along the member, normalised to its own peak, with the running share of the answer beside it. The integrand is a density: it says how much of the deflection each millimetre of the beam produced. For this case the half nearest the root supplies 87.5 per cent of it, and the rest of the member supplies the remainder. Stiffening the busy 50 per cent by 1.5 times takes the deflection down by 29.2 per cent; the same material spent on the quiet end takes it down by 4.2 — a factor of 7.0 for the same steel. The map of what is contributing is not the map of where the moment is largest, and the second is the one that gets drawn.

Deflection distribution

  1. 1 Where a deflection comes from
1 essay · deflection Four details, and no material anywhere on the plot. Stress range against cycles to failure for four detail categorys — 160, 112, 71, 36 N/mm² at two million cycles. The lines are parallel because they share a slope of three, and the spread between them is a factor of 4.4 in stress and therefore 88 in life. Nothing on this plot depends on the strength of the steel: the same detail in a grade twice as strong lies on the same line. At a stress range of 62 N/mm² the lives are 160: unlimited, 112: 2.1e+7, 71: 3.0e+6, 36: 3.9e+5 cycles. The knee in each line is the constant-amplitude limit, past which the slope becomes five.

Detail category

  1. 1 The detail decides and the steel does not
1 essay · connections

All essays