Structural Engineering & Statics
where the load goes
Concept

Ring buckling — where it appears

The collapse of a ring or a tube under external pressure into a lobed shape, at a critical pressure proportional to the cube of the wall thickness over the radius. Restraint from surrounding ground raises both the critical pressure and the number of lobes, so an embedded ring is very much harder to buckle than a free one.

Named by 2 essays across 2 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

The cheapest way out of being round. A ring under uniform external pressure, drawn in its first four buckling modes with the pressure each one needs underneath it, in N/mm². The pressure has no direction: it stays normal to the wall wherever the wall goes, so it does work on any change of shape that reduces the enclosed area, and the ring buckles into whichever shape is cheapest. Bare, that is the oval — n = 2 at 3EI/R³ — and the modes rise as n² − 1, so three lobes cost 2.67 times as much. Nothing in the drawing prefers any orientation, which is the point — a column has an axis to buckle about and a ring has none.

The pressure that needs no direction

Every buckling problem in this collection has had a load with a direction — a column pushed along its axis, a plate along its edge, an arch by what is on it. A buried pipe has none. The pressure is the same everywhere, it stays normal to the wall as the wall moves, and it does work on any change of shape that reduces the area inside.

stability · ring buckling The lining that carries less for being weaker. Bending moment and hoop thrust in a circular lining, against the lining's own bending stiffness, both as fractions of the free-ring values. The ground arrives already stressed — 500 kPa vertically and 300 horizontally at K₀ = 0.6 — and the difference between them tries to squash the hole into an ellipse. A lining stiff enough to refuse absolutely collects the whole distortion pressure, p₂R²/3 = 300 kNm/m; one flexible enough to go with the ground collects nothing, because there is no curvature change left to resist. The thrust is the flat line: it comes from the mean stress rather than the difference, so it does not move at all. Putting 8 joints in this ring drops the moment to 34% of the solid one and leaves the thrust exactly where it was, which is why a segmental lining is jointed and why the intuition carried over from a beam is inverted here.

The lining that is stronger for being weaker

A tunnel lining is not loaded. The ground arrives already stressed and the hole wants to squash into an ellipse; the lining's only job is to refuse, and how much moment it collects depends entirely on how hard it refuses. Make it stiffer and it takes more. Make it flexible — put joints in it, make it thin — and it takes almost none, while the hoop thrust it carries does not move at all.

structures · tunnel ring

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Second momentStiffnessBuckling modeCollapse loadConstruction sequenceCritical loadEarth pressureElastic foundationEquilibriumExternal pressureFlexibility ratioFree body

All concepts