Structural Engineering & Statics
where the load goes
Concept

Pounding — where it appears

The collision of two adjacent structures that sway into each other in an earthquake because the gap between them is smaller than their relative movement. Momentum fixes the impulse each one takes, while the force behind it depends on a contact stiffness nobody knows to within orders of magnitude.

Named by 2 essays across one field — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

Where two buildings touch, and what is there when they do. Closure between an 8-storey building 24 m tall and a 4-storey one 15 m tall, drawn against height, with the 50 mm gap between them. The two swaying out of phase close on each other more the higher up they are, so they first touch at 7.6 m and are in contact above it. The dots are the taller building's floors: its storeys are 3.00 m and the other's are 3.75, so two of them arrive part way up a column rather than at a slab. A blow at mid-height of a column asks it for a shear of half the impact and an end moment of Fh/8, neither of which is a demand any part of the design contains.

The floor that arrives at a column

The gap between two buildings is computed from their roof displacements, which is where each of them moves most. It is not where they touch, and it is not what is there when they do — a slab edge meeting a column part way up its height is a different event from two slabs meeting, and it is the one that appears in the photographs.

dynamics · Pounding One collision, four contact laws, one impulse. Contact force against time for one collision between 500 t and 300 t closing at 1.94 m/s, under four contact laws sharing one contact constant of 2.8×10^9 N/m^1.5. The elastic linear spring peaks at 19.7 MN and lasts 58 ms; the Hertz law peaks at 22.0 MN over 61 ms. Set to a restitution of 0.65, the spring and dashpot peaks at 16.8 MN and ends pulling at 3.5 MN, a tension two faces in contact cannot carry, while the damped Hertz law peaks at 20.1 MN and returns a restitution of 0.77 instead. The areas under the curves are the impulses: 600 kN·s for the spring and dashpot, which is what momentum requires at 0.65, 646 for the damped Hertz law, and 727 for both elastic laws.

The force that belongs to the model

When two buildings meet, momentum decides what each of them feels, and no contact law can change it. What the contact law decides is the force, and the force it reports is the contact stiffness somebody assumed, raised to a power. Four laws and a hundredfold change of stiffness move the buildings by a few per cent and the force by a factor of eight.

dynamics · Pounding

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

RestitutionCollapse mechanismColumnDampingDetailingDiaphragmEnergy dissipationImpactImpact factorImpulseMode shapeNon-linear response

All concepts