Structural Engineering & Statics
where the load goes
Generator

It moves, or it pushes. Never both, and never neither

Rendered here at the parameters it defaults to, with every essay that calls it — which is the same list as the blast radius of changing it.
It moves, or it pushes. Never both, and never neither. A 30 m steel member 30 °C warmer than it was built, in three conditions. Free, it grows 10.8 mm and carries nothing. Held, it moves nothing and carries 75.6 MPa in compression — which is E·α·ΔT and contains neither the length nor the area of the member, so the identical stress arises in a two-metre strut. Held by a spring it does some of each: 3.2 mm of movement and 53.2 MPa, and the split is decided by the spring rather than by the member.

It moves, or it pushes. Never both, and never neither. A 30 m steel member 30 °C warmer than it was built, in three conditions. Free, it grows 10.8 mm and carries nothing. Held, it moves nothing and carries 75.6 MPa in compression — which is E·α·ΔT and contains neither the length nor the area of the member, so the identical stress arises in a two-metre strut. Held by a spring it does some of each: 3.2 mm of movement and 53.2 MPa, and the split is decided by the spring rather than by the member.

10 essays call thermal-restraint. The drawing above is what it returns with no arguments at all; every call below passes it something, because a placement that passes nothing draws whichever member of the family the generator happens to default to rather than the one its essay argues about.

Where it is called

Changing this generator changes every one of these figures.

It moves, or it pushes. Never both, and never neither. A 30 m steel member 30 °C warmer than it was built, in three conditions. Free, it grows 10.8 mm and carries nothing. Held, it moves nothing and carries 75.6 MPa in compression — which is E·α·ΔT and contains neither the length nor the area of the member, so the identical stress arises in a two-metre strut. Held by a spring it does some of each: 3.2 mm of movement and 53.2 MPa, and the split is decided by the spring rather than by the member. Deflection

The movement nobody applied

A temperature change is the only load in this collection that a structure can decline. Let it move and it produces a movement with no stress; hold it and it produces a stress with no movement — and that stress contains no length, no area and no second moment, so a bracket and a bridge girder carry exactly the same one.

 The strain it wants, the strain it is allowed, and the difference. A bridge deck 1.40 m deep with 18 °C at the top face falling away over 10% of the depth. The left curve is the free thermal strain αT(y); the straight line beside it is what a plane section will actually take, ε₀ + κy with ε₀ = 32.0 microstrain and κ = 0.063 per km. The right-hand block is E times the difference, and it reaches -3.98 N/mm² of compression at the surface and 1.83 of tension 140 mm below it. Its resultant force is 8.3e-14 kN and its resultant moment 3.0e-12 kNm, which is what self-equilibrating means: the field is invisible to every equilibrium check that could be made on the member. Sections and stress

The stress nobody restrained

A bridge deck lying loose on its bearings, with nothing holding it anywhere, develops four newtons per square millimetre when the sun comes out. The stress is not caused by restraint. It is caused by plane sections, and it is invisible to every equilibrium check that could be made on the member.

 The least reliable number in the material decides the answer, briefly. What a twenty per cent error in the concrete's tensile strength does to a computed deflection, against how far past cracking the beam is. Well past the cracking moment it does almost nothing — at 1.9 times M_cr the spread is 56 per cent — because the section is nearly fully cracked and the interpolation has run out. Just above cracking it does everything: at 1.19 times M_cr the same twenty per cent moves the deflection by 3658 per cent. Tensile strength is the property with the widest scatter and the least direct test, and a beam designed to sit near its cracking moment has put the answer on it. Deflection

The curvature nobody applied

Concrete shrinks as it dries, by about half a millimetre in every metre. In a symmetrically reinforced member that is a shortening and nothing else. In a member with more steel in one face than the other — which is every beam and every slab — the steel holds one side back and the section bends, with no load on it at all.

 Two drawings of one deck, and they are not the same structure. A 112 m viaduct on five supports, articulated two ways. Above, the fixed point is at the left abutment: the far end has to be given 45 mm of movement, and the friction of every sliding bearing runs one way, so the fixed support takes 660 kN before any wind or braking is applied. Below, the fixed point is at the middle pier: the largest joint halves to 22 mm and the friction now cancels across the fixed point, leaving 0 kN. The movement arrows are drawn at 900 times the scale of the deck, because a 45 mm movement on a 112 m span is thinner than the line the deck is drawn with. Nothing about the deck, the loads or the ground has changed between the two. Structural form

Where the structure is allowed to move

One drawing decides how big every movement joint on a bridge is and where every horizontal force goes, it takes an afternoon, and it appears on no calculation sheet. Move the fixed point from an abutment to the middle pier and the largest joint halves and the horizontal force on that support drops from the whole of the friction to none of it.

 The gap is a sum of five things and only one of them is computed. What a 30 mm movement joint is asked to accommodate, by three combination rules. The top bar is every term at its extreme, added: 33.2 mm, which assumes the hottest day, the fullest floor, the whole of the shrinkage and the worst-placed wall arrive together. The chance of that is about 1.5%. The bottom bar treats them as independent and asks for 16.0 mm. The middle bar is the rule used for actions and almost never for movements — one term at its full value and the rest at their coincidence factors — and gives 25.5 mm. The segments across the top bar are the terms themselves, and the ordering is the finding: the largest is tolerance at 10.0 mm, which is not a structural quantity at all, and the smallest is deflection at 3.2 mm — the only one anybody computes carefully, and 10% of the total. Deflection

The gap nobody computed

A movement joint is sized by adding up everything the structure will do to it, and the deflection calculation — the only term anybody computes carefully — is usually the smallest one in the list. The largest is a construction tolerance, which is not a structural quantity at all, and the sum of the extremes is nearly twice what treating them as independent would ask for.

 Restraint is a fraction, and the length decides how far up it reaches. A 20 m wall 3.0 m high cast against a base that has already hardened — a length-to-height ratio of 6.67. The base holds the bottom of the wall at R = 0.50 and the top of it at 0.304, decaying as 0.609 to the power of the height in wall heights. The free contraction is 380 microstrain, of which 84 per cent is the wall cooling from its own hydration peak and the rest is drying; the concrete's own strain capacity is 50. Everything to the right of the dashed line cracks, which here is the bottom 3.00 m of it. Nothing has been loaded. Internal forces

The steel decides how many, not how much

A wall cast on a base that has already set cools, tries to contract, and is not allowed to. What follows is not a stress problem with a strength on the other side of it. The movement is going to happen; the only question the reinforcement gets to answer is how many pieces it is divided into.

 Steel and concrete happen to match, and nothing else on the list does. The mismatch strain a 40 degree change produces in seven pairs of materials that engineering bonds together, which is the difference of their coefficients of expansion times the temperature. Steel against concrete is 80 microstrain — 17 per cent of the larger coefficient, and by far the smallest on the list. It puts 0.223 N/mm² of tension into the concrete, 7.7 per cent of its tensile strength and 1.9 per cent of the 12 N/mm² a fully restrained member would have carried. Reinforced concrete works because of a coincidence in the third significant figure of two numbers nobody chose, and the same bar in aluminium would put in two and a third times as much. Materials

The coincidence reinforced concrete stands on

Steel expands at twelve microstrain per degree and concrete at ten. Nobody chose either number, they are not equal, and the seventeen per cent between them is the smallest mismatch of any pair of materials engineering bonds together — which is the reason the most-used structural material on earth does not tear itself apart every summer.

 A tenth of a per cent of the thrust is all of the moment. The thrust a two-hinged arch loses to its own axial shortening, against rise-to-span. The flexibility equation's denominator has two terms — ∫y²ds/EI for bending and ∫cos²θ ds/EA for shortening — and their ratio is about (15/8)(i/f)², the square of the radius of gyration over the RISE. At the 10 per cent rise drawn that is 0.10 per cent of the thrust, which sounds like a rounding error and is not: a parabolic arch under a uniform load is funicular, so the rigid solution has NO crown moment at all, and the 0.10 per cent that the rib shortening removes from the thrust leaves 28 kNm behind. The correction that is a tenth of a per cent of the thrust is a hundred per cent of the bending. At a two per cent rise the loss is 2.6 per cent, because a shallow arch's thrust is enormous and its lever arm is not. Deflection

The arch that gets shorter

A parabolic arch under a uniform load is funicular, so the perfect solution gives it no bending at all. Then the rib shortens under its own thrust by a tenth of a per cent, and every kilonewton-metre of moment the arch will ever carry comes from that.

 The summer that is worse than the one before it. The earth pressure behind an integral abutment, summer by summer, as a multiple of the at-rest value it started at. A 60 m deck expands by 10.8 mm at each end and pushes the abutment into the backfill. Granular soil under cyclic strain densifies, so the same movement next year needs a higher pressure to achieve, and K climbs from 0.38 toward 0.96 — a factor of 2.49 on the force, reached after about a century. The design load on an integral abutment describes the bridge's whole life rather than a load case, and it is the only load in this collection that gets larger because time has passed rather than because something was added. Structural form

The summer that is worse than the last

An expansion joint is a hole in a deck that leaks salt water onto the bearings underneath it. Remove it and the thermal movement does not go away — it goes into the soil behind the abutment, twice a day for a hundred and twenty years, and granular soil under cyclic strain gets denser.

 Two restraints, and only one of them cares how much was imposed. Crack width against the restrained strain, for the same 20 m wall restrained two ways. Edge restraint — a wall cast on a base — gives a width proportional to the strain, because the concrete has to accommodate the movement and the cracks are where it does. End restraint — a bay cast between two that have hardened — gives 0.32 mm at every strain on the axis, because the crack opens only until the steel can push the cracking force back into the concrete, and that force is a property of the section. At the 304 microstrain this wall is asked for, the two are 0.17 and 0.32 mm, and the movement is divided into 35 cracks and 19. Internal forces

The bay that is cast last

A wall cast on a base cracks in a way the steel controls: more movement gives wider cracks, and reinforcement decides how many. A bay cast between two walls that have already hardened cracks in a way that has nothing to do with how much movement there was — and the threshold that separates a controlled crack from a single wide one is a quantity of steel rather than a limit on anything.

The library, page 6 of 7 — where thermal-restraint sits