Structural Engineering & Statics
where the load goes
Generator

The redundant-beam generator

Rendered here at the parameters it defaults to, with every essay that calls it — which is the same list as the blast radius of changing it.
One support too manyThe same uniformly loaded beam with three sets of restraints, and the bending moment in each. Adding restraint moves moment from mid-span to the supports and lowers the peak — but only the first case can be solved by statics.simply supportedstatics alonesag 32.0propped at one endneeds stiffnesssag 18.0hog 32.0built in at both endsneeds stiffnesssag 10.7hog 21.3the load never changes; only what is holding the endsthe built-in case peaks at two-thirds of the simple span's moment

7 essays call redundant-beam. The drawing above is what it returns with no arguments at all; every call below passes it something, because a placement that passes nothing draws whichever member of the family the generator happens to default to rather than the one its essay argues about.

Where it is called

Changing this generator changes every one of these figures.

m 4 + r 3 − 2j 8 = -1a mechanismm 5 + r 3 − 2j 8 = 0statically determinatem 6 + r 3 − 2j 8 = +1one member too manystatics can answer only the middle case Equilibrium

Counting the unknowns, and finding out whether statics can answer

Two equations per joint, one unknown per member, one per restraint. Subtract, and the sign of the answer says whether the structure is a mechanism, solvable, or beyond what equilibrium alone can settle.

 00.050.10.150.20.250.30.3501020304050overhang, as a fraction of the spanbest at 21% — peak 8.8sagging, mid-spanhogging, over the supportmoving the supports in by a third of the way halves the worst moment Internal forces

Where to put the supports, which is not at the ends

Moving the supports of a uniformly loaded beam inward by about a fifth of its length halves the worst bending moment. The load has not changed and nor has the beam.

 sagging hinge at 4.69hinge at the fixed endlowest upper bound: 7.29every hinge position gives an upper bound on the collapse loadassumed position of the sagging hingecoefficient 11.66 Mp ÷ L² Internal forces

After the first yield, which is not the end

A steel beam whose extreme fibre has reached yield has not failed. It has started forming a hinge, and collapse waits until there are enough hinges to make a mechanism.

 moment19.6 sagging24.5 hogging30.6 if the spans were simplereactions 14.0 38.5 38.5 14.0 — the inner supports carry far more than a sharethe continuous case needed stiffness; the comparison did not Internal forces

The moment over the support, and what it buys

Run a beam over its supports instead of stopping at each one, and the mid-span moment falls by a third while a new moment appears where there was none. Nothing was added but continuity.

 simply supportedstatics alonesag 32.0propped at one endneeds stiffnesssag 18.0hog 32.0built in at both endsneeds stiffnesssag 10.7hog 21.3the load never changes; only what is holding the endsthe built-in case peaks at two-thirds of the simple span's moment Deflection

One support too many, and what it costs to know

Add a redundant restraint and the load has two routes to the ground. Equilibrium cannot say how it splits, and the answer turns out to depend on stiffness — which is a different kind of question.

 real Mpeak 32.0a unit load, here and nowhere elseunit mM × marea ÷ EI = 213.33the unit load is the only place the question 'deflection where?' is asked Deflection

One deflection, without solving everything

To find how far one point of a structure moves, put an imaginary force of one unit there, multiply two moment diagrams together, and integrate. The answer arrives without ever solving for the deflected shape.

 this support 0.01 lowmoment19.6 sagging24.5 hogging30.6 if the spans were simplereactions 14.0 38.5 38.5 14.0 — the inner supports carry far more than a sharethe continuous case needed stiffness; the comparison did not Deflection

The support that moved

A redundant structure knows things statics cannot see. Settle one support by ten millimetres and a complete set of bending moments appears — in equilibrium with no load at all, and larger for a stiffer beam.

The whole library