Structural Engineering & Statics
where the load goes
Concept

Snap-through — where it appears

A shallow structure jumping to a distant equilibrium position because the one it was in stopped being stable rather than because anything broke. It is a limit point rather than a bifurcation, so it happens to a perfect structure as well as an imperfect one and is a property of the shape.

Named by 3 essays across 2 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

A load with a maximum in it, and nothing bifurcates. Load against apex movement for a two-bar frame of half-span 1000 mm and rise 150 mm. The load rises to 133.4 kN at a movement of 64 mm — well short of the 150 mm that would bring the apex level — and then falls. Past that point the frame can only be held by taking load away, so under a dead weight it goes: 260 mm of movement at constant load, arriving inverted and in tension. The minimum on the path is -133.4 kN, the exact negative of the maximum, because the geometry is symmetric about the flat position and the arithmetic knows it.

The roof that jumps

Every stability failure in this collection so far has been a bifurcation — a straight thing discovering it can be bent. A shallow frame does something else entirely. It stays perfectly symmetric, deforms steadily, and at some point the load it can carry starts to fall while it is still moving in the direction it was pushed.

stability · Snap-through The arch does not squash; it leans. The first two buckling modes of the same rib, drawn against its undeformed shape at an exaggeration of a few hundred. The first, at wcr L³/EI = 49.7, is antisymmetric: one half rises while the other falls and the crown moves sideways. The second, at 117.1, is symmetric — the whole rib settling. The two differ by a factor of 2.36, which is why an arch is braced against sideways movement of its crown rather than against the load it is carrying, and why a tied arch with a single hanger at midspan is doing nothing for the mode that governs it.

The arch that leans instead of squashing

A masonry arch is asked whether a line of thrust fits inside it. A steel rib is asked a different question entirely: it is a column carrying an axial force along its whole length, and the mode it buckles in puts one half up and the other half down while the crown moves sideways.

stability · Arch buckling Held up by a pressure nobody can feel. An air-supported roof of 60 m span and 9 m rise. The membrane has no bending stiffness whatever, so the only thing that can hold it in tension is a pressure difference, and the pressure has to exceed the load per unit plan area and nothing else: 0.25 kN/m² of fabric plus 0.6 of snow is 0.85 kN/m², so 1.19 kN/m² does it — 1190 pascals, which is 1.17 per cent of an atmosphere and 121 millimetres of water. Ears do not notice it. A door does: at 2.1 kN on an ordinary leaf, the building needs an airlock rather than a handle. And the whole of it arrives at the foundation as 3365 kN of uplift — 17.9 kN on every metre of perimeter — which is the bill the pressure's smallness conceals.

Held up by the air inside

A membrane has no bending stiffness at all, so the only thing that can hold it in tension is a pressure difference. The pressure needed to hold up a roof is smaller than the pressure a closed door makes — and the same pressure arrives at the foundation as hundreds of tonnes of uplift.

structures · Pneumatic structure

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

BucklingAnchorageAntisymmetric modeArchBifurcationBracingCable netCritical loadCurvatureEffective lengthEigenvalueEquilibrium

All concepts