Structural Engineering & Statics
where the load goes
Depth

Series — page 11

A field says what an essay is about. A series follows one idea essay by essay — from the question that introduces it to the one that assumes all the others.
Where the wind's energy is, and where the structure can reach it. The gust spectrum at a mean speed of 30 m/s, plotted as n·S(n) against frequency on a logarithmic axis so that equal areas are equal energy. Its total variance is 27 m²/s², which the closed form 6·K·U² gives as 27. Most of the energy is below a hundredth of a hertz — gusts lasting a minute or more. A structure at 0.2 Hz sits far out on the tail, and still takes 90% of its response from there, because the resonant part is amplified by π·f₀/(4·ζ) and the damping is 1.2%. A stiffer structure at 2 Hz takes 22%.

Gust response

  1. 1 The wind is a spectrum
1 essay · dynamics The windward guy tightens, the leeward one gives way. A 120 m mast on three guy levels, at a wind of 3 N/mm, with the deflection drawn 0.54 times its true size. The guys start at 160 kN each and end at 259 against 95, 299 against 83, 221 against 112 kN. The leeward guys still carry a real force — the lowest keeps 28 per cent of its partner's tension — and supply almost none of the restraint, because their tangent modulus has fallen to 54 per cent of the steel's. The mast top moves 100 mm, its worst bending moment is 554 kNm at 40 m, and it is carrying 801 kN of axial load that nothing but the guys put there.

Guyed mast

  1. 1 Held by something that goes soft
1 essay · structures Every level added is a longer span, not a shorter one. Steel per square metre of floor against the number of levels in the hierarchy, for a 12 m bay with a deck that can span 3.0 m. A bending level's weight per unit area is 3ρqrL/8σ — it contains the SPAN and not the spacing — so breaking a floor into more levels cannot make the members lighter by making them closer together. It adds one more system, and the last system always spans the whole bay: a second level costs 52 per cent more steel than one, and a third 107 per cent. The structural zone grows with it, 730 mm to 1346 mm. Hierarchy is not an economy, it is a way of reaching, and it is paid for in both currencies at once.

Hierarchy

  1. 1 Every level is a longer span
1 essay · structures The free body that makes a hoop force a pressure times a radius. Half a ring cut along a diameter, with the pressure drawn normal to the wall wherever the wall is. Vertical equilibrium of the half ring is the whole derivation: the pressure acts over the projected width 2R whatever the shape of the arc, the two cut faces carry N each, so N = pR — 300 kN per metre here at 1 MPa on a 0.3 m radius. The result contains no wall thickness, no second moment, and no length along the pipe, which is why a hoop force is the one internal force in this collection that arrives with no lever arm attached to it. The stress does contain the thickness — 25 MPa at 12 mm — but the force does not, and a thicker wall carries exactly the same force at a lower stress.

Hoop tension

  1. 1 The force that is only a radius
1 essay · internal-forces A tie is worth all of itself and a strut is not, which is worth nine per cent. The same 20 floors carried two ways, with every member drawn at the width its own force requires. Hung, the loads accumulate upward, so the largest hanger is at the top: 18.0 MN at 355 N/mm² with no buckling reduction of any kind. On columns they accumulate downward and the largest column is at the bottom, at the same force — but every column above it is understressed by its own slenderness, worst at the top where a 900 kN column still has to be 4.8 × 10³ mm² to reach χ = 0.529. Over the height the hangers total 0.002 m³ of steel against 0.002: a saving of 9.0 per cent, which is the average χ and nothing else.

Hung structure

  1. 1 Hung from the top, and nine per cent lighter
1 essay · structures Three paths out of the same critical load. Load against sideways movement past the critical load, for three systems whose critical loads are identical. The stable one climbs, so a real structure with a small crookedness reaches nearly the full load and keeps going. The unstable one falls symmetrically, so the imperfect structure has a maximum below the critical load and it matters not at all which way it leans. The asymmetric one falls one way and climbs the other, so the direction of the imperfection decides everything. All three are drawn at an imperfection of 0.02 radians.

Imperfection sensitivity

  1. 1 A third of what the theory promised
1 essay · stability The chords take the shear the web is credited with. A cantilever of 6 m tapering from 400 to 1200 mm, under a 120 kN tip load, with the shear divided between the web and the two inclined chords. The chord force is M/z and it is not horizontal, so its vertical component is real: V_web = V − (M/z)·dz/dx, which is Résal's result of 1899. At the root the web is left with 33 per cent of the applied shear — exactly d₀/d₁ for a straight taper, with no length, load or material in it. Turn the same member round and the figure becomes 300 per cent: the chords stop helping and start adding, at the section where the moment is largest as well. And the limit is worth having — a member whose depth is proportional to its moment leaves the web nothing to do at all, which is the triangular cantilever every crane jib is.

Inclined chord

  1. 1 The shear the chords take
1 essay · internal-forces The check that depends on a date. Total deflection and the deflection occurring after the brittle finishes are built, for one 12 m beam, against the day those finishes go up. The total barely moves — the beam ends up where it ends up. The increment falls from 32 mm at a week to 14 mm at a year, because creep is fast at first and slow later and a partition built early inherits nearly all of it: 44% of the final creep has already happened by day 28. The span/500 limit is 24 mm and the span/250 limit is 48; this beam passes the first only after day 25. Camber subtracts from both terms of the difference and therefore changes the upper curve and not the lower one, which is the reason a cambered beam can satisfy every total-deflection check and still crack the wall.

Incremental deflection

  1. 1 The limit that depends on a date
1 essay · deflection The same beam, the same load, and one of them has to lift it. Two lower-bound models of one beam, differing only in which chord the 600 kN is applied to. The chord forces are identical in both — the moment diagram does not know where the load arrived — and so are the struts. What is not identical is the vertical at the load: nothing in the top-loaded model, and the whole 600 kN in the hung one, because a bottom-chord panel point touches no strut and the load has nowhere to go but up. That tie is 1200 mm² of steel against the 96 mm² the shear calculation asks for over the same length — a factor of 12.5, in the same place, and additional to it.

Indirect support

  1. 1 The load that has to be lifted
1 essay · internal-forces The point the rafter turns about, which is off the frame. A pitched portal of 8 m span and 4.0 m to the eaves, with a 1.5 m rise, collapsing. Each rigid part of the mechanism rotates about some point: the left column about its base hinge, the right about its own. The rafter between them does neither, and its centre is found by one rule — two bodies joined at a hinge share that hinge, so the second body's centre lies on the line through the first body's centre and the hinge, extended. Two hinges give two lines and they cross at (8.0, 11.0) metres, which is 5.5 m above the ridge and outside any drawing of the frame itself. From there the whole collapse is two ratios of lengths and no trigonometry: the load factor is 1.339. Flatten the roof and the centre descends; make the two lines parallel and it goes to infinity, which is the statement that the rafter translates instead of turning.

Instantaneous centre

  1. 1 The point the mechanism turns about
1 essay · equilibrium The summer that is worse than the one before it. The earth pressure behind an integral abutment, summer by summer, as a multiple of the at-rest value it started at. A 60 m deck expands by 10.8 mm at each end and pushes the abutment into the backfill. Granular soil under cyclic strain densifies, so the same movement next year needs a higher pressure to achieve, and K climbs from 0.38 toward 0.96 — a factor of 2.49 on the force, reached after about a century. The design load on an integral abutment describes the bridge's whole life rather than a load case, and it is the only load in this collection that gets larger because time has passed rather than because something was added.

Integral bridge

  1. 1 The summer that is worse than the last
1 essay · structures Two ways to fail, and the curve between them. The exact plastic interaction between axial force and moment for two sections of identical area, both normalised by their own squash load and their own plastic moment. The rectangle stands 25.0% of its plastic moment outside the straight line at an axial ratio of 0.50; The I-section stands 6.0% of its plastic moment outside the straight line at an axial ratio of 0.12. Every section here is symmetric about its centroid, so the equal-area axis and the centroid coincide and it makes no difference which the moments are taken about. The straight line is the rule that says the two capacities share out in proportion, and everything between it and a curve is capacity that rule gives away.

Interaction

  1. 1 Two ways to fail, and the curve between them
1 essay · materials Moment against rotation, for three real joints. Three connections on one plot, with the classification boundaries for a beam of EI/L = 14000 drawn as rays through the origin. web cleats is pinned, flush end plate is semi-rigid, extended end plate is semi-rigid. The boundaries are multiples of EI/L, so the same joint is rigid on a short stiff beam and semi-rigid on a long slender one.

Joint stiffness

  1. 1 Neither pinned nor rigid, which is every real connection
1 essay · connections The middle third, computed. The kern of a 400 × 600 mm rectangle, computed by asking, for every direction, how far the resultant can move before the far face would be pulled. It reaches ±100.0 mm vertically and ±66.7 mm horizontally, which are h/6 and b/6 exactly, and the region between is a rhombus rather than the ellipse the two numbers suggest — a resultant on a diagonal has less room than either axis allows.

Kern

  1. 1 The middle third
1 essay · sections Steel has a third direction and it is not as good. Through-thickness strain demand against weld size, on a 30 mm plate, with the ductility the plate can supply in each of its three directions drawn across it. Rolling stretches the plate's inclusions into flat stringers, so a bar cut along the rolling direction, one cut across it and one cut THROUGH it are three different specimens of one steel — 60, 45 and 15 per cent reduction of area, which converts exactly to a true fracture strain of ln(1/(1 − Z)): 0.916, 0.598 and 0.163. A factor of four in the reported percentage is 5.6 in the strain the material can take. The demand goes as the deposited area over the square of the thickness, so doubling the weld size quadruples it: the 12 mm throat drawn asks for 5.4 per cent, which an ordinary plate supplies and a plate with a bad inclusion cluster does not.

Lamellar tearing

  1. 1 The direction a plate was never tested in
1 essay · connections Two shapes that are the wrong way up for each other. Deflected shapes of a 20-storey building under a uniform wind, drawn to the same scale. The wall alone bends: its shape is flattest at the base and steepest at the top, reaching 146 mm. The frame alone shears: it is steepest at the base where the storey shear is largest, reaching 140 mm. Tied together at every floor they reach 58 mm — less than a quarter of either, and less than the 72 mm two springs in parallel would give, because each is stiff exactly where the other is not.

Lateral system

  1. 1 How a tall building stands still
1 essay · structures The length at which a beam stops being a beam. Elastic critical moment against the distance between lateral restraints, with the section's plastic capacity drawn across it. The two cross at 3803 — beyond that length the beam buckles sideways before it reaches the strength its cross-section has, and the capacity is set by the restraints rather than by the steel.

Lateral-torsional

  1. 1 The beam that fails sideways
1 essay · stability Every section is hogged and sagged before the bridge exists. The bending moment envelope of a launched deck, section by section along its own length, taken over every position of the launch. In service each section has one sign; during the launch 100 per cent of them see both, because each passes over every pier and through every span on its way out. The worst launch moment is 42568 kNm against 40500 in service, and with no launching nose at all it would be 185977. That is why a launched bridge is a constant-depth box with symmetric flanges: the design case is not a load, it is a history.

Launched bridge

  1. 1 Every section was somewhere else
1 essay · structures The neutral axis is wherever the first moment vanishes. A 300 by 600 section with 1800 mm² of steel at a depth of 540, carrying 250 kNm after the tension side has cracked. The neutral axis is no longer at mid-depth: it has risen to 234.5 mm from the top, which is where the first moment of the compression zone plus the transformed steel vanishes. The compression is 15.4 N/mm² at the top fibre and the steel carries 301 N/mm²; the resulting couple is 541 kN on a lever arm of 462 mm, which multiplies back to the 250 kNm applied. The uncracked section would have had 6673×10⁶ mm⁴ against the cracked 3809×10⁶ — a loss of 43% of the stiffness.

Lever arm

  1. 1 Where the steel is, not how much of it
1 essay · sections A fourth power, and then a cliff. The factor of safety against rolling, against beam length, for one section hung from a roll axis 0.9 m above its centre of gravity. Nothing about the section changes along this axis. z̄ goes as the fourth power of the length — 0.236 m at 30 m becomes 0.747 m at 40 — and the factor of safety is proportional to (y_r − z̄), so it does not decline gently: it falls away and then stops existing. The working factor of 1.5 is lost at about 41 m, and past 42 m there is no hook height at all at which this beam hangs stably. Which is why long girders are lifted with the picks moved inboard, or with the beam braced, or not in one piece.

Lift stability

  1. 1 Hung from above and still unstable
1 essay · stability

All essays