Internal forces

The diagram is an integral, and that is why it can be drawn by eye

Load, shear and moment are one function and its two integrals. Once that is seen, the diagrams stop being things to calculate and become things to sketch.

Three curves are drawn one above another for every beam ever analysed, and they are usually presented as three separate calculations. They are not. They are one function and its two integrals, and the relationship is exact.

dVdx=w,dMdx=V.\frac{dV}{dx} = -w, \qquad \frac{dM}{dx} = V.

The shear is the integral of the applied load and the moment is the integral of the shear. Everything about the shapes follows from those two statements, including the rules that let the diagrams be sketched without arithmetic.

Load, shear and moment — a simple spanThe applied load, the shear force it produces and the bending moment that follows, drawn one above another to the same horizontal scale. Shear is the integral of the load and moment is the integral of shear.4 per unit lengthshear16.0moment32.0 at x = 4.00the moment peaks exactly where the shear passes through zero
Fig. 1 The applied load, the shear it produces and the bending moment that follows, drawn one above another to the same horizontal scale. The shear here was computed by summing the load, and the moment by summing the shear.

Why the relations hold

Take a slice of beam of length dx\mathrm{d}x and write its equilibrium.

Vertically, the shear on one face, the shear on the other, and the load applied over the slice must balance. The difference between the two shears is the load carried over that length, which in the limit is dV=wdx\mathrm{d}V = -w\,\mathrm{d}x.

Rotationally, taking moments about one face, the moment on the far face differs from the moment on the near one by the shear times the distance, which in the limit is dM=Vdx\mathrm{d}M = V\,\mathrm{d}x. The load’s own moment about the face is second-order in dx\mathrm{d}x and drops out.

Two lines of algebra on an infinitesimal slice, and every rule below follows.

The rules that fall out

Where there is no load, the shear is constant. The integral of zero is a constant, so the shear diagram is horizontal between point loads.

Under a uniform load, the shear slopes. The integral of a constant is a straight line, and its gradient is the load intensity.

At a point load, the shear jumps. A finite force applied over zero length is a step, and its size is the load. This is the one place the diagram is discontinuous.

The moment is one degree higher. Constant shear integrates to a linear moment; sloping shear integrates to a parabola. A beam under point loads has a moment diagram made of straight lines; the same beam under a uniform load has a parabola.

The moment peaks where the shear crosses zero. The moment is stationary where its derivative vanishes, and its derivative is the shear. This is the single most useful rule in the subject: to find where a beam is worst loaded, find where the shear changes sign.

Load, shear and moment — a simple spanThe applied load, the shear force it produces and the bending moment that follows, drawn one above another to the same horizontal scale. Shear is the integral of the load and moment is the integral of shear.20shear12.5moment37.5 at x = 3.00the moment peaks exactly where the shear passes through zero
Fig. 2 A single point load. The shear is two horizontal steps and the moment is two straight lines meeting at a peak — exactly under the load, which is where the shear passes through zero.
Load, shear and moment — a simple spanThe applied load, the shear force it produces and the bending moment that follows, drawn one above another to the same horizontal scale. Shear is the integral of the load and moment is the integral of shear.1515shear15.0moment37.5 at x = 4.32the moment peaks exactly where the shear passes through zero
Fig. 3 Two point loads. Three flat shear segments and three straight moment segments, with the moment flat in the middle because the shear there is zero — a stretch of beam carrying constant moment and no shear at all.

The middle region of that second figure is worth a moment’s attention. Between two symmetric loads the shear is zero, so the moment is constant. That is pure bending: a length of beam with a moment and no shear, which is exactly what a four-point bending test creates deliberately in a laboratory.

The area rule

Integration between limits is the area under a curve, so the change in moment between any two stations is the area under the shear diagram between them.

M2M1=x1x2Vdx.M_2 - M_1 = \int_{x_1}^{x_2} V \, dx.

That converts the moment diagram into an exercise in adding up rectangles and triangles, which is how it was done before it was done by machine, and how a check is still done by anyone who does not trust the output.

For a simply supported beam with a central point load PP and span LL: the shear is P/2P/2 over the first half, so the area under it is PL/4P L/4, and the moment at mid-span is PL/4PL/4. No calculus, one rectangle.

For a uniform load ww: the shear falls linearly from wL/2wL/2 to zero at mid-span, so the area is a triangle of wL2/8wL^2/8. Two familiar results in two lines each.

The same rule works backwards for checking. If a moment diagram is drawn with a peak in the wrong place, the shear diagram’s zero crossing will not agree with it, and one of the two is wrong.

Load, shear and moment — a simple spanThe applied load, the shear force it produces and the bending moment that follows, drawn one above another to the same horizontal scale. Shear is the integral of the load and moment is the integral of shear.6 per unit lengthshear18.0moment27.0 at x = 3.00the moment peaks exactly where the shear passes through zero
Fig. 4 A load over part of the span only. The shear slopes where the load acts and is flat where it does not; the moment is parabolic under the load and straight beyond it, and its peak is still where the shear crosses zero.

The cantilever, and the sign that stays negative

A cantilever inverts most of the reading, and comparing it with a simple span is the fastest way to internalise the sign convention.

Load, shear and moment — a cantileverThe applied load, the shear force it produces and the bending moment that follows, drawn one above another to the same horizontal scale. Shear is the integral of the load and moment is the integral of shear.4 per unit lengthshear32.0moment-128.0 at x = 0.00the moment peaks exactly where the shear passes through zero
Fig. 5 A cantilever under a uniform load. The moment is hogging everywhere, largest at the support and zero at the free tip — the mirror of the simple span in almost every respect.

The free end has no reaction and nothing beyond it, so both shear and moment are zero there. Both grow toward the support, where the moment reaches wL2/2wL^2/2 — four times the simply supported value for the same span and load.

The factor of four is why cantilevers are expensive and why they are used anyway: a cantilever needs no support at its far end, and eliminating a support is sometimes worth four times the moment. Moving the supports inboard is the compromise between the two, and it is a better deal than either extreme.

The moment being hogging throughout means the tension is in the top fibres for the entire length. A reinforced concrete cantilever has its steel in the top, and a balcony slab with the bars in the bottom is a well-known way to build something that falls off a building.

Reading the diagrams as instructions

The diagrams are usually treated as results. They are more useful as instructions, because each one says what the beam needs at every station.

The moment diagram says how much section modulus is required. Where it peaks, the beam must be deepest or the reinforcement heaviest; where it is small, material can be removed. A haunched beam, thickened over its supports, is a moment diagram made physical.

The shear diagram says where the web works hardest and where shear reinforcement goes — which is near the supports, where the moment is small. The two demands peak in different places, which is convenient and not accidental.

The zero of the moment diagram — the point of contraflexure — says where the tension swaps faces. Reinforcement has to be lapped past it, and a splice placed exactly there is placed at the one station where the bar is doing nothing.

One more integration

The chain does not stop at the moment. Integrating twice more gives the shape the beam takes.

The deflected shape is the moment, integrated twiceA loaded beam with its deflected shape above and its bending-moment diagram below. The shape was obtained by integrating the moment twice and fitting the constants to the supports; the vertical scale is exaggerated enormously.the largest movement, at x = 4.00momentdrawn at roughly three hundred times the real deflection —a beam at its serviceability limit moves about a three-hundredth of its span
Fig. 6 A loaded beam with its deflected shape and its moment diagram, one above the other. The shape is the second integral of the moment, with the constants fixed by the supports.

So load, shear, moment, slope and deflection are one function and its four integrals, and the whole of elementary beam theory is that single chain read in either direction. Reading downward gives the analysis; reading upward — from a required deflected shape back to the load that produces it — is what precamber and form-finding do.

The same beam, cut at x = 5A beam separated at one station. On the exposed face a shear force and a bending moment appear, equal and opposite on the two pieces, with values obtained by summing the forces on whichever piece is easier.2012.57.5shear 7.5moment 22.5the cut, at x = 5nothing was applied here — the internal forces are what the left-hand piece needs
Fig. 7 A single cut. Every ordinate of every diagram above is one of these, computed at one station — which is worth remembering when the curves start to look like properties of the beam rather than of the free bodies behind them.

The free body is still doing all the work; the diagram is only a way of drawing several hundred of them at once.

Where the model stops

Small deflections. The relations are written on the undeformed beam. Where deflection is large enough to change the geometry, an axial force starts contributing moment and the load amplifies itself.

No axial force. A beam-column has both, and the axial force starts contributing moment of its own.

Statically determinate. Every diagram on this page was obtained by statics. A continuous beam has diagrams that depend on the relative stiffness of its spans, and no amount of integration will produce them from the loads alone.

Concentrated loads are not concentrated. A point load is a fiction — a real load spreads over a bearing width, so the shear step is a steep ramp and the moment kink is a small curve. The fiction is harmless for the overall diagram and misleading right at the load, where the local stresses are the design case.

The figures share a specific distortion: the shear and moment diagrams are drawn at whatever vertical scale fits the canvas, and the two scales are unrelated. Comparing the height of a shear ordinate with that of a moment ordinate in these pictures means nothing at all, since the two quantities do not even have the same units. Only the shapes, the signs, and the positions of the peaks are comparable.

The ladder from here

Later rungs: the differential relations derived from a slice. The area rule applied systematically. Diagrams for overhangs and internal hinges. Influence lines, which ask where a moving load produces the worst effect. Continuous beams and moment distribution. The relation between the moment diagram and the deflected shape. Plastic hinges and collapse mechanisms. And frames, where the same three quantities exist in every member and the diagrams are drawn around corners.

The relationships were known to Clapeyron by the 1850s and were being taught as graphical shortcuts long before anyone described them as calculus. The word “integral” appears in almost no nineteenth-century structural text, and the technique is entirely there.