Structural Engineering & Statics
where the load goes
Concept

Stiffness distribution — where it appears

How stiffness is arranged through a structure, which decides where load goes before any question of strength arises. Changing it changes the internal forces without changing the loading, which is why strengthening one element can overload another.

Named by 3 essays across 2 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

A portal frame swaying under 20 kN. A portal frame pushed sideways, solved by the stiffness method because statics cannot divide the load between two columns. The base shears come out at 10.0 and 10.0 and add to the applied 20; the peak moment is 22.2. The sway is drawn hugely exaggerated, and the moment diagram is plotted on each member's tension face.

The frame that leans, and what stops it

A rectangle of pinned bars folds flat. Make the corners rigid instead of adding a diagonal and it does not — which buys an unobstructed opening and costs bending in every member of it.

structures · Portal frame Two centres, and the distance between them is a torque. A storey 30 by 18 m with its walls drawn heavy, pushed in one direction by 1000 kN. The force acts through the centre of mass and the storey turns about the centre of rigidity — the stiffness-weighted centroid of the walls, at x = 15.0 m — and the distance between the two is an eccentricity of 0.00 m before the 5% that has to be assumed anyway. The table below the plan splits each wall's force into its direct share and its torsional one. Torsion relieves the walls near the centre of rigidity and loads the far ones, so the wall in trouble is not the wall carrying the most: west wall is asked for 8% more than its direct share, and the walls at right angles to the push carry 19 kN each with nothing applied along them at all.

The corner that moves most

A lateral force is shared out in proportion to stiffness only if it passes through the centre of rigidity, which is not the centre of the plan and not the centre of mass. The distance between the two is a torque, and the wall that pays for it is the one furthest away and carrying least.

structures · Plan torsion Where the drift went. Storey drift at the target displacement, for the same frame with and without a soft ground storey at 50 per cent of the others' stiffness and strength. The regular frame spreads 219 mm over every storey; the soft one reaches 266 mm and puts 5.58 per cent of it into the ground storey against 0.53 next to it — a concentration of 5.9 against 1.7. The roof goes 22 per cent further, and where that extra displacement lands is the whole of the difference between the two buildings.

Weaker in one place, and better on every average

Take an eight-storey frame and make its ground storey half as stiff and half as strong. Its ductility demand falls, its first mode carries more of the mass, and its period lengthens into a gentler part of the spectrum. Three global numbers all improve, and the building is the one that collapses.

dynamics · Pushover

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Storey driftAccidental eccentricityBase shearCapacity curveCentre of rigidityCollapse mechanismDiaphragmDuctility demandEccentricityInstantaneous centreJoint rigidityLateral system

All concepts