Structural Engineering & Statics
where the load goes
Concept

Self-excitation — where it appears

A load manufactured by the structure's own movement, which has a threshold rather than a magnification and grows without bound past it. Its energy comes from a steady flow rather than from an oscillating load, which is why a bridge can be destroyed by a wind that never changed speed.

Named by 4 essays across 2 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

The damping a crowd leaves behind, and the number of people that uses it up. Total damping ratio against pedestrians, for a structure with 0.60% of its own and a modal mass of 120 tonnes at 0.5 Hz. Each person walking laterally puts a force in phase with the deck's velocity into it — about 300 N·s/m per person — so the crowd subtracts from the damping, and at 30.16 people what is left is nothing. Below the threshold a disturbance dies away. Above it, the structure feeds itself and the motion grows out of nothing at all — which is what makes this a different mechanism from resonance rather than a severe case of it.

The bridge that was pushed by its own sway

A crowd walking on a bridge that moves sideways adjusts its footing to stay balanced, and the adjustment pushes the bridge the way it is already going. The crowd is a damper with the sign reversed, and past a certain number of people the total damping is negative.

dynamics · Crowd synchronisation The damping a wind leaves behind, and the speed that uses it up. Total damping ratio against wind speed, for a structure with 0.60% of its own and a modal mass of 25 kg per metre at 1.2 Hz. The aerodynamic damping of a section whose lift falls with angle of attack is negative and grows with speed, so at 4.14 m/s what is left is nothing. Below the threshold a disturbance dies away. Above it, the structure feeds itself and the motion grows out of nothing at all — which is what makes this a different mechanism from resonance rather than a severe case of it.

The motion that feeds itself

A steady wind contains no frequency at all, and it can destroy a bridge. The force that does it is manufactured by the structure's own movement, so there is no excitation to resonate with — there is a wind speed above which the equilibrium is unstable, and below which nothing happens.

dynamics · Aeroelastic instability Two frequencies that meet, and a determinant that never moves. The two natural frequencies of Ziegler's two-bar column against the follower load Pℓ/k, with the determinant of its stiffness matrix drawn along the top. The determinant is k² at every load — it varies over this whole axis by 1.1e-16 of itself, which is round-off — so a static buckling analysis of this structure finds no critical load whatever and reports it as stable everywhere. The frequencies say otherwise: they approach, meet at Pℓ/k = 2.0858, the closed form (7 − 2√2)/2, and become a complex pair, which is oscillation that grows. With no damping that merge is also where the column goes unstable. Adding any internal damping at all drops the load at which that happens to 1.4643, which is 41/28 and 30% below the undamped value; the limit of the damped system is not the undamped system, which is the paradox Ziegler found in 1952 and which was taken for an arithmetic error for a decade.

The load it cannot buckle under

Every stability calculation on this site rests on an assumption nobody states: that the load has a potential, so a critical load is where a total potential energy stops being a minimum. A load that turns with the structure it is pushing has no potential, and the static analysis of such a column returns no critical load at all — a determinant that never vanishes, for a column that fails at a perfectly finite one.

stability · Follower force One actuator, a tower and a floor. The peak amplification of a mode with 1 per cent damping under velocity feedback of gain 0.10, against the mode's frequency on a logarithmic scale, for control loops whose delay is 10, 25, 50 milliseconds. The dotted line is the mode without control, 50. With 10 ms: 4.6 at 0.2 Hz, 4.5 at 2 Hz and 5.0 at 8 Hz; with 25 ms: 4.6 at 0.2 Hz, 4.6 at 2 Hz and 19.0 at 8 Hz, unstable from 9.8 Hz; with 50 ms: 4.5 at 0.2 Hz, 5.3 at 2 Hz and unstable at 8 Hz, unstable from 4.9 Hz. A delay is a fixed time and a period is not, so the same loop that damps a tall building's sway is too late for a floor.

The actuator that arrives late

A tuned mass damps a structure because its force arrives a quarter of a cycle behind the motion. Replace the mass with an actuator told to push against the structure's velocity, and the same quarter-cycle is fatal: the push that was damping becomes stiffness, the stiffness becomes a source of energy, and a gain that would have cut the response tenfold makes the structure vibrate by itself. The delay is a few hundredths of a second, which is nothing to a tower and everything to a floor.

dynamics · Tuned mass damper

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

DampingFlutterNegative dampingStability thresholdTuned mass damperAeroelastic instabilityAeroelasticityBucklingCritical loadCritical velocityCrowd loadingDamping ratio

All concepts