Structural Engineering & Statics
where the load goes
Concept

Squash load — where it appears

The load at which a stub member yields over its whole section, unaffected by any residual stress because that field is self-equilibrating. It is the ceiling every column curve starts from, and reaching it requires a section whose plates cannot buckle before its fibres yield.

Named by 7 essays across 3 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

Two ways to fail, and the curve between them. The exact plastic interaction between axial force and moment for two sections of identical area, both normalised by their own squash load and their own plastic moment. The rectangle stands 25.0% of its plastic moment outside the straight line at an axial ratio of 0.50; The I-section stands 6.0% of its plastic moment outside the straight line at an axial ratio of 0.12. Every section here is symmetric about its centroid, so the equal-area axis and the centroid coincide and it makes no difference which the moments are taken about. The straight line is the rule that says the two capacities share out in proportion, and everything between it and a curve is capacity that rule gives away.

Two ways to fail, and the curve between them

A column carrying both compression and bending has two capacities and a rule for sharing them out. The rule is a straight line, the truth is a curve, and for a rectangle the straight line gives away a quarter of the plastic moment at half the squash load.

materials · Interaction Why the curve sags, and why the two axes are not the same column. The same column curve with the sag computed rather than drawn. A hot-rolled section carries a residual compression of 30% of yield at its flange tips before anything is applied, so the tips yield first and what is left resisting a change of shape is the elastic core. About the major axis the stiffness follows the core's width; about the minor axis it follows its cube. The worst loss is 27% at λ = 74 about the minor axis against 23% about the major, and the whole effect lives between λ = 75 and λ = 89 — outside that band nothing has yielded, or everything has. No imperfection appears anywhere in this figure.

The column that had yielded before it was loaded

A real column sits below both of the two straight answers over the whole middle of the slenderness range, and the usual explanation — that it was not straight — is only half of it. The other half is that the flange tips had already yielded when it left the rolling mill.

stability · Inelastic buckling The one length a section carries into a column. Four profiles of equal area, with the radius of gyration r = √(I/A) drawn as the distance it is — a pair of lines either side of the centroid, at the depth the whole area would have to sit at to give the section the second moment it has. As a 4 m pin-ended column the same 3000 mm² of material carries between 7 and 3146 kN, in the ratio of the squares of those radii and of nothing else.

The one length a section takes into a column

A section has an area, a second moment, two section moduli, a shear centre and a torsion constant. A column has heard of exactly one of them, and it is none of those — it is the length √(I/A), which is where the whole area would have to sit to give the section the stiffness it has.

sections · Radius of gyration The load did not move; the section did. A lipped channel 200 by 65 mm at 2 mm thick, drawn twice on top of itself: the outline as fabricated, and the part of it still working once the plates have buckled. The web is held on both edges, so it loses its middle; the flanges are held at the web, so an unlipped one would lose its free edge. What survives is not symmetric with what was drawn, so the centroid moves 8.0 mm — and a load applied along the axis it was designed to arrives 8.0 mm off the section that has to carry it. At the 177 kN this section will take, that is 1.42 kNm of bending nobody applied.

What is left after it ripples

A thin plate that buckles locally has not failed. It has stopped taking load in its middle and gone on taking it near its edges, so the member is now made of a different section from the one that was drawn — and the new one has its centroid somewhere else, which turns a concentric load into an eccentric one.

sections · Effective cross-section Not where the two loads meet. How much a column loses below the weaker of its two single-mode capacities, against the ratio of its local critical load to its global one. The received claim is that the worst place is where the two coincide; the arithmetic says otherwise. The erosion is largest at a ratio of 0.47 — 23% — sits within a per cent of that for every ratio below about a half, and at exact coincidence is only 2%. What the curve does say is the useful half of the folk claim: once the plates are stocky enough that the local critical load is twice the global one, the interaction is nothing at all, and the section is worth thickening only up to there.

Two ways of buckling at once

A thin-walled column can bow as a whole or ripple in its plates, and each has its own critical load. The received advice is that the worst arrangement is the one where the two are equal. The arithmetic says the opposite — at coincidence the interaction costs two per cent, and the expensive region is where the plates go first.

stability · Mode interaction The stub column a bearing stiffener makes, in plan. A plan through the girder at the bearing. The 8 mm web runs across; the pair of 100 × 12 stiffeners stands off it; and the shaded strip of web either side — 15ε t_w, or 98 mm each way — is the width that buckles with the stiffeners rather than independently of them. Together they are an area of 3962 mm² with a second moment of 9.01·10⁶ mm⁴ about the web's centreline, a radius of gyration of 48 mm over a buckling length of 900 mm — 0.75 of the depth, because the flanges hold the ends. That is a slenderness of 0.25, at which the column curve returns 0.98: the stub column reaches 98 per cent of its squash load, and the section's own strength is very nearly the whole answer.

A column nine hundred millimetres long

The patch-load check asks how much of a web a flange can spread a wheel over, and answers in a plate-buckling reduction that throws seven tenths of it away. A pair of stiffeners does not improve that answer. It replaces the question with a different one, from a different family, with a different failure in it.

stability · Patch loading The four corners of an opening, on the tee's own interaction diagram. The plastic interaction of the tee left above and below a 400 × 300 mm opening — every point on it computed by sweeping the plastic neutral axis through the section rather than from an interaction formula. Its squash load is 1519 kN and its plastic moment 32.2 kNm. At the working load the global moment puts 301 kN into each tee — compression above the hole, tension below — and the shear puts the same Vierendeel moment of 6.3 kNm into all four corners. The line is the path the demand takes as the load rises, and it reaches the surface at a load factor of 3.89 against 1.49 for first yield at one corner: the elastic check is finding one corner and the mechanism needs all four.

Four corners and a mechanism

The check on a hole in a web adds an axial stress to a local bending stress and compares the sum with the yield stress at one corner. What ends the opening is four hinges arriving together — and the gap between the two is a factor that varies along the span from two and a half to exactly one.

sections · Web opening

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

SlendernessSection classificationBucklingCold-formedColumn curveCritical loadEccentricityEffective lengthEffective widthLocal bucklingPlastic momentPlastic neutral axis

All concepts