Structural Engineering & Statics
where the load goes
Theme

The load must go somewhere — page 11

Essays 241 to 244 of 244 on this thread, in the same order.
A portal on a stepped base — the two passes added. Bending moments on a single-bay portal with columns of 5 m and 3.5 m under one horizontal beam of 9 m, carrying 10 kN/m down and 60 kN across, with fixed bases. This frame is the two passes added. The corner moments are 5.8 and 99.1 kNm, and the short column's top carries 17.01 times what the tall one does. The diagram is drawn on the tension side of each member. Deflection

Every joint balanced, and the frame still leaning

Moment distribution enforces one equation per joint, and a frame free to translate has one more equation than it has joints. So a table that balances perfectly can describe a structure held up by a prop nobody built — and finding the prop, then removing it, is a second pass whose unknown is a distance rather than a rotation.

 The whole line works, and the axis is not a choice. A weld group 200 mm deep carrying 15 kNm about an axis in its own plane, together with 100 kN of vertical shear. The bending force per unit length runs linearly from 1125 N/mm at one extreme to the same the other way at the other, through zero at the group's own centroid — and the centroid is where the neutral axis is because a weld carries compression across its throat as readily as tension. The 250 N/mm of shear runs along the weld and is uniform over the whole 400 mm, so the two components are perpendicular to one another and are combined on the throat rather than added as vectors in the plane. Connections

The eccentricity at right angles to the drawing

A bracket's load stands off the plane of its welds as well as being offset within it, and the second eccentricity produces a completely different object — bending about an axis through the group rather than torsion about a point in it. The weld line has no compression zone to argue about, so its neutral axis is its own centroid, and the whole length works.

 Three fasteners, three completely different clocks. What each of three shear fasteners carries against how far the joint has moved. A 400 kN fillet weld is linear to 0.4 mm and then gone — it is stiff and it is not ductile. A 380 kN bolt in a hole 2 mm larger than itself carries nothing until the hole closes and then rises over several millimetres of hole elongation. A 250 kN preloaded bolt is at its slip resistance in under a tenth of a millimetre and holds it until it slips. Two of these in one joint are at the same displacement, so the one that gets there first carries the load — and the weld gets there 23 times sooner than the bearing bolt does. Connections

Two fasteners that never arrive together

Every steel code forbids adding a weld's capacity to a bolt's in one shear joint, and states it as a rule rather than deriving it. It is derivable. Two fasteners in parallel are at the same displacement rather than the same force, and a weld has ruptured at four tenths of a millimetre while a bolt in a standard hole has not yet touched the side of it.

 Two ways for the same plate to fold. An end plate 200 mm wide with a bolt 45 mm from the web face and 55 mm from the edge, and the two families of yield line it can collapse along. The circle closes round the bolt and is 283 mm of hinge — a circle round the bolt. The straight pattern runs out to the plate's free edges and is 249 mm — hinges to the plate edges. The plate folds along whichever is cheaper, which here is the fan, and the 200 mm that comes out is the length of the equivalent tee stub — a dimension that is nowhere on the plate and is 100 per cent of its width. Connections

How much of the plate is bending

A tee stub is an object nobody builds, and the whole component method rests on replacing a real end plate with one. The length of the substitute is not a dimension of the plate — it is the length of the cheapest fold the plate can collapse along, and two families of fold compete for it on a criterion with no strength in it at all.

All themes