Structural Engineering & Statics
where the load goes
Series

Tension field — the series

3 essays on one idea, from the one that introduces it to the one that assumes the rest.
  1. A buckled panel is a truss that nobody drew. A 1000 × 1000 panel of 6 mm web, at d/t = 167. It buckles in shear at 63.8 N/mm², which is 383 kN — and it then carries 696 kN, 1.82 times as much, because the tension diagonal takes over from the compression one that has gone. The band runs at 22.5° with a membrane stress of 252 N/mm² over a width of 541 mm, and it pulls on the flange at 221.3 N per millimetre of its length. A web that never buckled at all would have reached 953 kN, so the panel ends at 73% of a stocky web's capacity on a fraction of its steel.

    The panel that carries more after it has failed

    Everywhere else in this field a critical load is where the argument ends. A thin web is the exception — it buckles visibly, in waves anybody can see, and then goes on to carry nearly twice as much again by turning itself into a truss nobody drew.

    part 1 · stability
  2. A buckled panel is a truss that nobody drew. A 1500 × 2000 panel of 8 mm web, at d/t = 188. It buckles in shear at 41.0 N/mm², which is 492 kN — and it then carries 1187 kN, 2.41 times as much, because the tension diagonal takes over from the compression one that has gone. The band runs at 18.5° with a membrane stress of 348 N/mm² over a width of 788 mm, and it pulls on the flange at 280.2 N per millimetre of its length. A web that never buckled at all would have reached 2460 kN, so the panel ends at 48% of a stocky web's capacity on a fraction of its steel.

    The tension has to pull on something

    A buckled web carries its shear on a diagonal band of membrane tension, and the band pulls sideways on the flanges and stiffeners that bound it. That pull is the design output nobody plots — it runs from 72 to 603 newtons per millimetre across ordinary panel proportions, it is largest exactly where the panel is most efficient, and at the end of the girder there is nothing beyond to take it.

    part 2 · stability
  3. Two models of one buckled web. The shear resistance of a web 1500 mm deep and 8.0 mm thick in steel of 355 N/mm², as a share of its plastic shear 2,460 kN, against the spacing of its intermediate stiffeners as a multiple of the depth, by Basler's tension field, by the rotated stress field with a rigid end post and with a non-rigid one, and by buckling alone; the dots at the right-hand edge are the same web with no intermediate stiffeners. With stiffeners at the depth Basler gives 0.71 and the rotated field 0.50; at three depths 0.38 and 0.42; with none, 0.14 — buckling alone — and 0.41. The two cross at a spacing of about 2.6 depths. Basler's reserve is a band the stiffeners anchor and it narrows to nothing as they move apart; the rotated field's is spread over the whole web and anchored at its ends, and the spacing reaches it only through the buckling stress.

    Two reserves for one buckled web

    A slender web keeps carrying shear after it buckles, and design uses two models of how: Basler's band of tension anchored on the stiffeners, and the rotated stress field spread over the whole web and anchored at its ends. Given the same 1,500 × 8 mm panel they agree about the buckling and disagree about everything after it — and in particular about what an intermediate stiffener is for. One says stiffeners save 37 per cent of the steel; the other, 1 per cent.

    part 3 · stability

All series