Structural Engineering & Statics
where the load goes
Series

Strut-and-tie — the series

2 essays on one idea, from the one that introduces it to the one that assumes the rest.
  1. A truss drawn inside a solid, and solved as one. A deep member 4000 mm between bearings and 2000 mm deep, carrying 1200 kN at mid-span. The model is two struts and one tie, on a lever arm of 1600 mm, and it is solved by the truss solver rather than by a formula: the tie comes back at 750 kN and each strut at 960 kN, at 38.7° to the horizontal. Spread over a strut width of 812 mm the compression is 3.0 N/mm² against a limit of 15.8 for concrete cracked across its own strut, and the tie needs 1724 mm² of steel. A beam calculation on the same member would have asked the tie for 702 kN, which is 7% less than the model does.

    When there is no section to design

    Beam theory needs a section, and a section needs the strain to be linear across it. Within about a depth of a support, a load, a corner or a hole it is not — and those are the regions structures actually fail in.

    part 1 · internal-forces
  2. A truss drawn inside a solid, and solved as one. A deep member 5000 mm between bearings and 2500 mm deep, carrying 2400 kN at mid-span. The model is two struts and one tie, on a lever arm of 2000 mm, and it is solved by the truss solver rather than by a formula: the tie comes back at 1500 kN and each strut at 1921 kN, at 38.7° to the horizontal. Spread over a strut width of 1031 mm the compression is 3.7 N/mm² against a limit of 18.1 for concrete cracked across its own strut, and the tie needs 3448 mm² of steel. A beam calculation on the same member would have asked the tie for 1404 kN, which is 7% less than the model does.

    The node is the part that is checked

    A strut-and-tie model is safe if every part of it can carry what the model asks. The struts are wide and lightly stressed, the ties are steel and easy, and the whole of the difficulty collects at the points where they meet — in a volume of concrete a few hundred millimetres across that no drawing shows.

    part 2 · internal-forces

All series