Structural Engineering & Statics
where the load goes
Ladder

Multicell torsion — the ladder

One essay so far against this idea. A ladder is the distinct arguments that stand against one idea, and this one has room to grow.
  1. The web down the middle carries no torsion at all. A 2-cell box 3.0 m wide and 1.5 m deep under 4000 kNm of torque. Statics gives one equation, T = 2 Σ q_i A_i, and there are 2 unknown flows — so the section is torsionally redundant and the missing statements are that every cell twists by the same amount. Solving that system gives 444.4 and 444.4 N/mm in the cells, so the internal web carries 0.00 N/mm — 0.00 per cent of the outer wall's. J is 2.3679e+12 mm⁴ against 2.3679e+12 for the same outline with no internal web at all, a ratio of 1.000000. The same walls slit open would give 7.413e+10, so closure is worth 32 times and the internal web is worth what the ratio says.

    Two cells, one equation, and a web with nothing in it

    Bredt's formula answers a single closed cell because a single closed cell has one unknown and one equation. Put a web down the middle and there are two unknowns and still one equation — and the answer, when the missing statement is supplied, is that the new web carries exactly nothing.

    rung 1 · sections

All ladders