Structural Engineering & Statics
where the load goes
Series

Flexural-torsional — the series

2 essays on one idea, from the one that introduces it to the one that assumes the rest.
  1. A cruciform has three critical loads, not one. The three critical loads of a cruciform in compression, against its length, with the load it actually buckles at drawn over them. At 3000 mm the flexural loads are 921 kN about the major axis and 921 kN about the minor, while twisting about the shear centre takes 700 kN. The lowest root is 700 kN, and the column twists. The shear centre is the centroid, so the three modes are independent and the envelope is simply the lowest of them. The governing mode changes at 3442 mm: below that length the column twists, above it, it bends — because the torsional resistance keeps a term that does not grow when the member is shortened, and the flexural loads have none.

    The column that twists instead of bending

    Euler's column has one mode. A real column has three, and which of them governs is settled by where the shear centre sits. A cruciform strut buckles by rotating about its own length at a load that does not change no matter how short it is made.

    part 1 · stability
  2. A channel has three critical loads, not one. The three critical loads of a channel in compression, against its length, with the load it actually buckles at drawn over them. At 3500 mm the flexural loads are 13970 kN about the major axis and 2306 kN about the minor, while twisting about the shear centre takes 1555 kN. The lowest root is 1484 kN, and the column twists. The shear centre sits 109.7 mm from the centroid, so the modes cannot happen separately: the lowest root of the coupled problem is 4.5 per cent below the lowest of the three, and the Wagner coefficient β is 0.60. The governing mode changes at 5813 mm: below that length the column twists, above it, it bends — because the torsional resistance keeps a term that does not grow when the member is shortened, and the flexural loads have none.

    The third root of the cubic

    A column has three buckling loads and an Euler calculation finds two of them. The third is a twist about the shear centre, and for a section whose shear centre is not at its centroid the three cannot happen separately — so the answer is the lowest root of a cubic and can be a third below anything the two familiar modes report.

    part 2 · stability

All series