Structural Engineering & Statics
where the load goes
Generator

A built-up column has a second way to bend

Rendered here at the parameters it defaults to, with every essay that calls it — which is the same list as the blast radius of changing it.
A built-up column has a second way to bend. A 12 m column of two chords 300 mm apart, joined by double lacing. On the left it buckles the way a solid column does, by bending; on the right the chords stay straight and the lattice racks, which a solid column cannot do at all. Neither happens alone, and the two flexibilities add rather than the two stiffnesses — so the critical load is 1287 kN against an Euler load of 1341 kN, which is 96% of it, and the column behaves as though its slenderness were 80 rather than 79.

A built-up column has a second way to bend. A 12 m column of two chords 300 mm apart, joined by double lacing. On the left it buckles the way a solid column does, by bending; on the right the chords stay straight and the lattice racks, which a solid column cannot do at all. Neither happens alone, and the two flexibilities add rather than the two stiffnesses — so the critical load is 1287 kN against an Euler load of 1341 kN, which is 96% of it, and the column behaves as though its slenderness were 80 rather than 79.

3 essays call laced-column. The drawing above is what it returns with no arguments at all; every call below passes it something, because a placement that passes nothing draws whichever member of the family the generator happens to default to rather than the one its essay argues about.

Where it is called

Changing this generator changes every one of these figures.

A built-up column has a second way to bend. A 12 m column of two chords 300 mm apart, joined by double lacing. On the left it buckles the way a solid column does, by bending; on the right the chords stay straight and the lattice racks, which a solid column cannot do at all. Neither happens alone, and the two flexibilities add rather than the two stiffnesses — so the critical load is 1287 kN against an Euler load of 1341 kN, which is 96% of it, and the column behaves as though its slenderness were 80 rather than 79. Stability

The column made of two columns

A solid column buckles when its bending stiffness runs out. A laced one has a second way to go — the lattice shears, the chords stay straight — and the two flexibilities add rather than the two stiffnesses. A battened column reaches 23% of its own Euler load and behaves as though its slenderness were twice what it is.

 The average is not the answer, and it is unsafe. Critical load of a pinned column whose middle third has been given a different stiffness, against the whole-column Euler load, with the two numbers a hand check reaches for beside it. The eigenvalue is taken from K − P·Kg over 24 elements, so nothing here is a formula for a stepped column — it is the same computation the uniform case gets. At a middle third of 0.50 times the rest the true load is 0.612 of Euler's, the arithmetic average says 0.832 and the weakest segment says 0.496. The average is high by 36% and it is high on the unsafe side, because the third of the column it is averaging over is the third where the mode has all its curvature. The weakest-segment answer is safe everywhere and wasteful by about as much. Stability

An average stiffness is not a safe stiffness

Euler's load belongs to a column of one EI. Give the same column two, and the temptation is to average them — which is wrong, and wrong in the unsafe direction by a quarter. Buckling weights stiffness by the square of the curvature of the mode, so the middle of a pinned column decides everything and the ends decide almost nothing.

 A built-up column has a second way to bend. A 24 m column of two chords 800 mm apart, joined by single lacing. On the left it buckles the way a solid column does, by bending; on the right the chords stay straight and the lattice racks, which a solid column cannot do at all. Neither happens alone, and the two flexibilities add rather than the two stiffnesses — so the critical load is 3832 kN against an Euler load of 4629 kN, which is 83% of it, and the column behaves as though its slenderness were 66 rather than 60. Stability

The lacing decides the force it has to carry

A perfectly straight column carries no shear, so the diagonals of a built-up column are resisting a force that exists only because the column is crooked. Computing it turns out to be circular — the shear is amplified by the very flexibility the lacing supplies — and the rule of thumb that replaces the calculation is wrong by a factor that grows as the lacing gets worse.

The library, page 3 of 7 — where laced-column sits